An offense committed against the state or the community at large, and dealt with in a proceeding to which the state is itself a party. Not all public wrongs are crimes. A breach of contract with the government, for example, constitutes a public wrong even though it remains civil in nature.
See Our Sources
How its tested
Common Examples
6
Merger of Conspiracy into Completed Robbery
Pablo Perez and Philip Powell agree to rob a bank and then carry out the robbery. Because the substantive offense was completed, the conspiracy merges into the felony. The completed robbery constitutes a public wrong that the state prosecutes directly rather than pursuing the preliminary agreement separately.
Grand Jury Indictment for Embezzlement
Phoebe Park is charged with embezzling public funds under a government contract. The conduct amounts to a public wrong against the community. The Fifth Amendment therefore requires a grand jury indictment before she can be held to answer for the offense.
Pilar Pena faces trial for arson, a crime punishable by more than one year in prison. The offense is a public wrong prosecuted by the state. Under the applicable rule the government receives six peremptory challenges and the defense receives ten.
Prior Act Evidence in Fraud Prosecution
Pierce Patterson is prosecuted for defrauding a state agency. The government seeks to introduce evidence of a prior similar scheme. Because the charged conduct is a public wrong, the prior act cannot be admitted to prove that Patterson acted in conformity with a criminal character.
Withdrawal from Client Planning Tax Fraud
Priya Prasad learns that her client intends to use her services to file false tax returns with the government. The planned conduct would constitute a public wrong. The lawyer must withdraw because the client persists in seeking assistance with the crime or fraud.
Duress Defense in Government Contract Dispute
Peak Performance threatens to commit arson against Paragon Construction unless Paragon signs a new supply contract with the state. The threat of a crime renders the agreement voidable. The threatened conduct would have been a public wrong prosecuted by the state.
4 common questions
Students Frequently Ask...
What distinguishes a public wrong from a private wrong?
A public wrong is an offense against the state or community at large that is pursued in a proceeding in which the state is a party. A private wrong invades an individual right and is pursued by the injured person.
Must every public wrong be prosecuted as a crime?
No. A public wrong may be civil rather than criminal. A party that breaches a contract with the government commits a public wrong even though the claim remains civil.
How does the concept of public wrong affect merger of inchoate offenses?
When the substantive offense is completed, the inchoate conduct merges into the completed crime. The completed offense is treated as the public wrong that the state prosecutes.
Does the Fifth Amendment grand jury requirement apply to public wrongs?
The Fifth Amendment requires a grand jury indictment for capital or otherwise infamous crimes. Those offenses qualify as public wrongs that the state must prosecute through formal indictment.
410 U.S. 113 (1973)
…a pregnant single woman (Roe) for a declaratory judgment and injunctive relief against the Texas abortion laws, which make it a crime to procure or attempt an abortion except on medical advice for the purpose of saving the mother's life. A licensed physician (Hallford), who had been performing abortions, and a married…