Also known as: stales · staled · staling · staleness
Written by attorneys · grounded in primary & secondary sources — see below
A claim, piece of information, or conviction that has lost reliability or legal force because of the passage of time.
Scott Summers sought support for his nonmarital child six years after birth. The state statute barred the action while allowing marital children to sue indefinitely. The court applied intermediate scrutiny and struck down the limit because the state failed to show it substantially advanced prevention of stale claims.
Sabrina Shah's affidavit relied on an informant's observation of drug activity three weeks earlier. Officers obtained a warrant and searched the hotel. The court held the information stale and found no probable cause because the facts no longer supported a current location of contraband.
Select any source to read its text and confirm it supports the definition.
Spencer Silver sued in federal court after a state court dismissed his contract claim on statute of limitations grounds. The defendant argued the dismissal barred the federal action everywhere. The court ruled the dismissal did not preclude the claim in another jurisdiction with a longer period because the first judgment merely barred a stale remedy.
Santiago Sanchez faced trial five years after arrest. He argued the delay violated due process because witnesses' memories had faded. The court rejected the claim, noting that statutes of limitations serve as the primary protection against stale criminal charges rather than the speedy trial clause.
Seth Shapiro's estate faced a creditor claim filed months after publication of notice. The creditor argued due process required actual notice. The court held that self-executing statutes of limitations protect against stale claims without additional state action triggering constitutional notice rules.
Solomon Silver discovered his painting in a museum decades after its theft. He sued for replevin. The court applied the discovery rule rather than adverse possession because requiring open possession of personal property would bar valid claims while failing to prevent truly stale disputes.
Information supporting probable cause for a search must show that evidence is presently located in the place to be searched. When the facts are too old, the items may no longer be there, rendering the information stale and insufficient for a warrant.
Supporting sources
Convictions more than ten years old are presumptively inadmissible for impeachment. The proponent must give advance written notice and show that probative value substantially outweighs prejudice under a heightened standard.
Supporting sources
They protect defendants from defending against old disputes where evidence has deteriorated and memories have faded. They also conserve judicial resources and provide repose after a legislatively determined period.
Supporting sources
No. Once the execution period on the face of the warrant expires, the warrant is stale and supplies no authority for the search. Officers must obtain a new warrant rather than rely on the expired one.
Supporting sources
…a speedy process, so that liberty will not be long restricted prior to an adjudication, and evidence of fact will not become stale; that in a system committed to the resolution of issues of fact by adversary proceedings the right to confront opposing witnesses must be guaranteed; and that if issues of fact are tried to…