Also known as: points of law · question of law
Written by attorneys · grounded in primary & secondary sources — see below
A discrete legal proposition at issue in a case.
Apex Electric and Metro Plumbing both sue Titan Builders after project delays. They join as plaintiffs because their claims raise the same point of law about whether Titan breached its scheduling duties. The court allows joinder under the rule requiring a common point of law.
Prime Logistics sues a supplier for breach. A third party moves to intervene claiming its own supply contract was affected by the same conduct. The court grants intervention because the intervenor shares the point of law about contract interpretation.
Select any source to read its text and confirm it supports the definition.
Pearl Porter sues in federal court under diversity jurisdiction after a car accident in State A. The court must decide whether a point of law on contributory negligence comes from state or federal sources.
Perry Pratt litigates a tort claim in federal court. The judge identifies a point of law about burden of proof and applies state law under the Erie framework to avoid forum shopping.
Preston Pratt sues TSC Industries for misleading proxy statements. The court treats materiality as a point of law when the omitted fact is so obvious that reasonable minds could not differ.
Pacific Bank seeks approval of a class settlement. The court resolves a point of law about whether absent class members received adequate notice before binding them to the judgment.
A point of law concerns the legal standard or rule that applies to the facts, while factual questions concern what happened. In joinder under Rule 20, parties may join when their claims share at least one common point of law even if their specific damages differ.
Intervention is allowed when the proposed intervenor presents a claim or defense that shares a common point of law with the main action. The court evaluates whether that shared legal issue will arise in both proceedings.
Under Erie, federal courts apply state law to substantive points of law to prevent forum shopping and ensure equal protection of state-created rights. Procedural points of law may follow federal rules.
Materiality is a point of law when the omitted information is so obviously important that reasonable minds could not differ on its significance to investors.
A point of law arises when the court determines whether notice to absent class members satisfies constitutional requirements before a judgment can bind them.
…extended for a criminal trial is the severe injustice risked by confronting an untrained defendant with a range of technical points of law, evidence, and tactics familiar to the prosecutor but not to himself. This danger shrinks markedly in the police station where indeed the lawyer in fulfilling his professional…