Also known as: declaratory judgment · DJ
Written by attorneys · grounded in primary & secondary sources — see below
A judicial determination of the rights or legal relations of parties in an actual controversy. The declaration binds the parties and may be enforced through other judicial remedies without awarding damages or issuing coercive orders.
Daniel Diaz, a state health official, enforced a statute that Daniel claimed violated federal environmental law by restricting access to public lands. Daniel sued in federal court seeking a declaration that the statute was unconstitutional as applied to his planned activities. The court issued declaratory relief clarifying that the statute could not be enforced against Daniel going forward.
Deborah Dunn, a shareholder in Dawson Steel, alleged that the company's proxy materials for a merger vote contained false statements. She filed suit requesting a declaration that the proxy solicitation violated federal securities law. The declaration established the legal rights of shareholders without requiring immediate rescission of the merger.
Select any source to read its text and confirm it supports the definition.
Diana Delgado, a physician, challenged a state criminal statute restricting abortions. She sought declaratory relief that the statute was unconstitutional. The court declared the statute void, resolving the legal relations between physicians and the state without issuing an injunction.
Dover Bank owned a historic terminal subject to city landmark restrictions that blocked redevelopment plans. The bank sued for a declaration that the restrictions violated due process. The court issued declaratory relief determining the constitutionality of the application of the law to the property.
Destiny Davis, an environmental group member, sought a declaration that federal agency actions threatened endangered species habitats. The court addressed whether declaratory relief was available by examining whether the plaintiff demonstrated concrete injury sufficient for an actual controversy.
Demetrius Douglas, a trustee, filed an action seeking a declaration of rights under a will probated in another state. The court examined whether it had jurisdiction to issue declaratory relief determining the validity of the trust provisions.
A federal court may issue declaratory relief against a state officer to address ongoing violations of federal law. The officer is treated as acting without state authority when the conduct violates the Constitution or federal statutes.
No. The existence of another adequate remedy does not preclude a declaratory judgment that is otherwise appropriate under the federal rules.
The plaintiff must demonstrate an actual dispute between adverse parties involving legal rights and obligations. Hypothetical or advisory controversies are insufficient.
Declaratory relief states the parties' rights without ordering compliance or awarding damages. An injunction affirmatively commands or prohibits conduct.
…Justices White and Rehnquist filed dissenting opinions. Syllabus This is an action by a pregnant single woman (Roe) for a declaratory judgment and injunctive relief against the Texas abortion laws, which make it a crime to procure or attempt an abortion except on medical advice for the purpose of saving the mother's life. A…