Concept
Procedural Tools
Judge and jury roles in deciding fault
Procedural Tools
Two clauses of § 328B of the Restatement (Second) of Torts decide most of what a trial judge must do when asked to take an issue from the jury. Section 328B(a) gives the court the question whether the evidence makes an issue on which a jury may reasonably find the facts to exist or not exist.1 Section 328B(d) gives the court the question whether the defendant has conformed to the standard of conduct in any case in which the jury may not reasonably come to a different conclusion.2 Section 328C gives the jury its own list of questions, again only “in any case in which different conclusions may be reached on the issue.”3
Those clauses divide the work, but they do not by themselves bring a single question before the judge. Evidence law treats the respective roles of judge and jury as part of the structure of the adversary system,4 and in that system the division takes effect only when a party, or the court, invokes a procedure. Four procedures do the job.
Three of them are motions asking the court to decide an issue itself because no reasonable jury could decide it the other way, and they differ chiefly in timing. A motion for summary judgment comes before trial and is decided on documentary evidence. A motion for directed verdict, which federal practice calls judgment as a matter of law, comes at trial and is decided on the evidence admitted.5 A motion for judgment notwithstanding the verdict comes after the jury has answered and tests the verdict against the same standard.6 The test stays constant; the record and the cost of an error change with the calendar.
The fourth tool works on whatever the motions leave behind. The judge's instructions identify the factual disputes the jury should resolve and state the rules of law it should apply, and the form of the verdict determines how much of the jury's reasoning the court can later see.7 The motion that states the reasonable-jury test most directly comes first.
Directed Verdict and JML
A motion for directed verdict puts the § 328B questions to the court while the trial is still under way. A defendant's motion tests the legal sufficiency of the plaintiff's evidence: it assumes that evidence to be true and contends that the plaintiff nevertheless cannot recover. A plaintiff's motion runs the other way. It assumes the defendant's evidence to be true and contends that the plaintiff is entitled to recover as a matter of law anyway.8 Federal practice now uses one name, judgment as a matter of law, for the motion made before the verdict and for the one made after it.9
The motion asks whether reasonable minds could differ. The Supreme Court has said that the trial judge must direct a verdict if, under the governing law, there can be but one reasonable conclusion as to the verdict, and that a verdict should not be directed if reasonable minds could differ about the import of the evidence.10 A widely quoted federal formulation supplies the method. The court considers all of the evidence, not just the evidence that supports the non-movant, but reads it in the light and with all reasonable inferences most favorable to the party opposed to the motion. If the facts and inferences point so strongly and overwhelmingly for one party that reasonable people could not arrive at a contrary verdict, the court should grant the motion. If substantial evidence opposes it, meaning evidence of such quality and weight that reasonable and fair-minded people exercising impartial judgment might reach different conclusions, the court should deny the motion and submit the case to the jury. A mere scintilla of evidence cannot present a jury question.11
That inquiry is not a contest over who is ahead. The motion is not decided by which side has the better of the case, and it need not wait until probative facts are wholly absent; what a jury question requires is a conflict in substantial evidence. Weighing conflicting evidence and inferences, and judging the credibility of witnesses, remain the jury's work.12
One standard serves both functions that § 328B assigns the court. When the party carrying the burden offers no evidence, or only a scintilla, on an element of its case, the motion works as the sufficiency ruling of § 328B(a), and the opponent wins as a matter of law.13 When the facts are settled and every reasonable inference points the same way about the defendant's care, the motion works as the conformity ruling of § 328B(d), and the ruling can favor either party.14
Defendants make this motion far more often than plaintiffs, and the burden of proof explains why. A plaintiff carries that burden, so a directed verdict for the plaintiff is hard to win, and a plaintiff strong enough to win one is likely to win before the jury anyway.15
The directed verdict has a pretrial counterpart in the motion to dismiss for failure to state a claim. A motion to dismiss assumes the plaintiff's allegations to be true and contends that the plaintiff still cannot recover, so it tests the legal sufficiency of what was alleged. The directed verdict makes the same contention about what was proved, which is why it is in effect the trial equivalent of the motion to dismiss.16 Because the court must know what the plaintiff has to establish before it can say the plaintiff failed, the rules of tort law are embedded in rulings on directed verdicts, just as they are embedded in rulings on the admissibility of evidence.17
Two states can therefore treat the same record in opposite ways. Suppose a plaintiff sues over a product's design and submits evidence of the dangers the design poses, along with proof of causation and damages, but offers no evidence that a safer alternative design was feasible. The defendant moves for a directed verdict on that ground. The court grants the motion in a state whose rule is that a design is not defective unless a safer alternative was feasible, and denies it in a state whose rule does not require that proof.18 The witnesses and the proof are identical in both states. The substantive rule differs, so the same record is insufficient in one state and sufficient in the other. A student asked whether a directed verdict should be granted therefore starts with the elements the governing law requires and measures the evidence against them.
The question can also come out the other way when the proof covers every element and the dispute concerns what the evidence shows. In the Sindorf litigation, Fridkis clearly indicated that Sindorf had been fired, although, as far as the record showed, Sindorf had resigned. It did not appear that Langton told Fridkis that Sindorf was fired. If Fridkis did not know that Sindorf was not fired, the court observed, stating that he was fired could be found to be a reckless disregard of truth.19 What a speaker knew is a matter on which the evidence leaves room for inference, and a statement that “could be found” reckless is one that a factfinder may so find. The contrast with the design example is instructive. There a missing element let the court decide by rule; here the inference is open, and where reasonable minds could differ, the jury decides.
A court that thinks a directed verdict is warranted need not grant it on the spot. It may let the jury decide and rule on the same question afterward, which is the office of the next motion.
Judgment Notwithstanding the Verdict
The court's power under §§ 328B(a) and 328B(d) does not expire when the jury speaks.21 A motion for judgment notwithstanding the verdict (j.n.o.v.) asks the court to enter judgment for the movant even though the jury has returned a verdict for the other side. Federal practice treats the request as a renewed motion for judgment as a matter of law, and the word “renewed” signals that the movant is pressing a request first made during trial.22 The standard does not change with the calendar. The same formulation governs both motions: the court considers all the evidence, reads it most favorably to the party opposing the motion, and grants the motion only when reasonable people could not arrive at a contrary verdict.23
With a verdict in hand, the judge asks whether a reasonable jury, on a record read favorably to the winner, could have found as this one did. Weighing the evidence and judging credibility still belong to the jury.24 A supermarket spill shows the question at work. A customer reaching for something on a shelf knocks over a bottle of cooking oil, and the next shopper slips on the oil within a minute and a half. A sympathetic jury might call the store unreasonable for not cleaning up the oil and find it negligent. A judge might still grant the store's renewed motion for judgment as a matter of law, on the ground that it would be unreasonable to require anyone to clean up a spill of liquid in a supermarket aisle within 90 seconds.25 The jury's sympathy does not decide the ruling. What decides it is whether any rational jury could treat so short an interval as a failure of care.
A judge inclined to direct a verdict may do better to submit the case, because a wrongly directed verdict is costly. If the court takes the case from the jury and the appellate court later holds that the case belonged to the jury, no verdict exists, and the only remedy is a new trial held simply to see what the jury would have decided. If the court instead submits the case and the jury finds for the plaintiff, the court can grant the defendant's j.n.o.v. while the jury's verdict stays on record. The appellate court then either affirms, or reverses and enters judgment for the party in whose favor the jury ruled, with no new trial. The jury was given the chance to decide, and nothing remains to be repeated.26
The practice rests on a lopsided pair of costs. Letting the trial run to verdict costs the deliberation that a correct directed verdict would have saved. A wrongly directed verdict costs an entire second trial. A judge who is confident in the ruling gives up little by waiting, and a judge who may be mistaken avoids a much larger loss.
The same motion also corrects a verdict that contradicts itself. When the jury returns a special verdict, the court can compare the answers. If the jury finds the defendant negligent but finds that the negligence caused the plaintiff no injury, and still awards damages, the court can see that the plaintiff failed to prove causation and grants the defendant's j.n.o.v.27 A general verdict that reports only the winner and the amount would hide the same mistake. The section on instructions and verdict forms returns to that choice.
A motion for a new trial on the ground that the verdict is against the weight of the evidence is a different request. J.n.o.v. asks whether a reasonable jury could have found as it did. The new-trial ruling rests in the trial court's discretion, so it is ordinarily nonreviewable. The discretion must still be exercised under ascertainable legal standards, and an appellate court shown special or unusual circumstances that clearly indicate an abuse may reverse, but appellate courts rarely find that the trial court abused its discretion.28
Summary Judgment
Summary judgment puts the reasonable-jury question to the court at the earliest point at which the record can answer it. In Anderson v. Liberty Lobby, Inc., the Supreme Court explained that under Rule 56(c) the judge grants the motion when there is no genuine issue as to any material fact and the moving party is entitled to judgment as a matter of law. Once a properly supported motion is made, the adverse party “must set forth specific facts showing that there is a genuine issue for trial.”30 The Court has described the “genuine issue” standard as “very close” to the “reasonable jury” standard for directed verdict. The primary difference is procedural: summary judgment motions are usually made before trial and decided on documentary evidence, while directed verdict motions are made at trial and decided on the evidence that has been admitted.31 What the preceding subsections said about the jury's power to decide for either side when reasonable minds could differ therefore applies before trial as well.
At this stage the judge's function is not to weigh the evidence and determine the truth of the matter but to determine whether there is a genuine issue for trial. There is no issue for trial unless there is sufficient evidence favoring the non-moving party for a jury to return a verdict for that party.32 The judge makes no findings of fact. The inquiry is a threshold one: whether any genuine factual issues remain that can be resolved only by a finder of fact because they may reasonably be resolved in favor of either party.33 The Court agreed that the standard mirrors directed verdict practice, under which a verdict is directed if there can be but one reasonable conclusion and is not directed if reasonable minds could differ about the import of the evidence.34
When a defendant moves on the ground that the plaintiff lacks proof of a material fact, the judge asks not whether the evidence unmistakably favors one side but whether a fair-minded jury could return a verdict for the plaintiff on the evidence presented. A scintilla of evidence supporting the plaintiff's position is not enough. There must be evidence on which the jury could reasonably find for the plaintiff, which means that reasonable jurors could find by a preponderance of the evidence that the plaintiff is entitled to a verdict.35
Adickes v. S.H. Kress & Co. makes the same point from another direction. The Court there emphasized that the availability of summary judgment turned on whether a proper jury question was presented, and one of the issues in that case was whether private persons and law enforcement officers had conspired.36 The motion fails whenever the record presents a question that a jury is entitled to answer.
The ban on weighing the evidence protects the jury's function. Section 328C(a) gives the jury the facts wherever different conclusions may be reached,37 and the record before the judge on summary judgment consists of documents. A judge who picked the more believable of two conflicting affidavits would be deciding a fact that the evidence lets reasonable jurors resolve either way. The judge's task is only to determine whether such a fact is genuinely in dispute.
A dated letter from the tenant to the owner describing the loose tread would give a jury something from which to infer notice, and the same motion would be denied. If the owner's manager then swore never to have received the letter, the sworn denial would create a conflict for the jury to resolve, and the judge would have no warrant to choose between the two accounts on a preference about who is more believable. Students most often overreach here: a judge's doubt that the non-movant will win at trial is no ground for granting the motion, because the only question is whether a rational jury could find for that party.
Because the motion asks only whether a trial is needed, the court's inquiry ends as soon as it finds a genuine factual issue.38 That is the Restatement's allocation exercised before any jury is sworn: the court decides whether the evidence lets a jury reasonably find the facts, and it decides conformity as a matter of law only where the jury could not reasonably come to a different conclusion.39
Instructions and Verdict Forms
Section 328B(c) gives the court the standard of conduct that the defendant's legal duty requires, and § 328C(b) gives the jury the question whether the defendant conformed to that standard in any case in which different conclusions may be reached.41 A fixed standard does no work until the jurors hear it, so the allocation needs a point of handoff, and the court's instructions at the close of the evidence supply it. There the judge identifies the factual disputes the jury should resolve and the rules of law it should apply to its findings in deciding between a verdict for the plaintiff and one for the defendant.42
In a negligence case the instructions carry the substantive rules of tort law: the concept of negligence, the requirement that the defendant's negligence, if any, have caused the plaintiff injury, the rules governing damages, and the way the jury is to decide whether any defense the defendant raises should prevail.43 Jurors must then work largely from memory. Instructions are typically given orally, and except in very lengthy cases jurors do not take notes.44 The charge is the channel through which the law reaches the jury room, and the clearer it is, the more fully jurors can attend to the factual questions that are theirs.
Where the court has fixed only the general standard, the jury ordinarily hears that standard in general terms: a short definition of negligence and of the reasonable person test, which jurors apply to the facts as they find them. If some special variation of the test governs, as it does for physicians and minors, the jury is told so. And when a court declares certain conduct negligent as a matter of law, presumptively negligent, or evidence of negligence, the jury is instructed accordingly.45 The charge thus follows the court's choice at the standard-setting step. A general standard produces a general instruction, and a more specific standard produces a more specific one.
Behind the phrase “reasonable person” sits a weighing of risk against the cost of avoiding it. A railroad deciding whether to build an overpass shows how that weighing can favor a defendant. Suppose two injuries would be caused in a decade, the average injury would cost $500,000, and the overpass would last 30 years. The expected injury cost is then $3 million, against a $12 million cost of averting the six likely accidents. On those assumptions the railroad's decision may well be reasonable, because the investment may exceed what society, through the mechanism of tort law, is willing to require.46 That is the kind of choice the jury evaluates when it decides whether the defendant conformed to the standard.
In a case with several defendants, the instructions must also keep each defendant's own conduct in view. Consider two co-workers, Whiting and Hahn, who worked on the same job. The facts do not indicate that Hahn was negligent, because she was not responsible for cutting off the power, and she is not liable for Whiting's negligence simply because they worked the same job. A rule to the contrary would be a tough one indeed, making employees liable for the torts of any co-worker.47 A charge that blurred that distinction would invite jurors to charge one defendant with another's fault.
The jury reports its answer in one of two forms, and the choice controls what the court can learn from it. In most cases the jury returns a general verdict, stating only whether it finds for the plaintiff or the defendant and, if the former, the amount of damages. In most states the court may instead ask for a special verdict, in which the jury answers specific questions about whether the plaintiff proved each element and whether any defense succeeded.48 The special form helps in two ways. A jury returning a general verdict must try to remember an oral charge, whereas a jury returning a special verdict normally receives a written list of the questions it must answer. And the court can examine the answers to see whether they are internally consistent.49
Comparative negligence shows the consistency check at work. A plaintiff, Rousseau, who was 10 percent negligent himself, sues two defendants, one of them a city. Suppose the jury, on a special verdict form, finds that the city's negligence did not cause the injuries, yet counts the city's negligence anyway in assigning fault. The form exposes the conflict, and the judge can reinstruct the jury on proximate cause and send it back to deliberate further and clarify its verdict. That may well save the trial if the jury returns a consistent verdict after the supplemental instruction.50
A general verdict in the same case would have hidden the mistake. A jury that wrongly counted the city's negligence, although it did not cause the injuries, would probably have returned a verdict against each defendant for $90,000, which is Rousseau's damages reduced by his 10 percent negligence. That looks like a perfectly permissible verdict even though it rests on a misunderstanding of the law, and the general verdict often hides such mistakes.51 The same holds for a jury that finds negligence without causation and still awards damages: if it made that mistake before returning a general verdict for the plaintiff, the mistake could not be detected.52
What the court does about an inconsistent special verdict depends on what the answers show. If the jury finds the defendant negligent but finds that the negligence caused the plaintiff no injury, and still awards damages, the answers establish that the plaintiff failed to prove causation, and the court grants the defendant's motion for judgment notwithstanding the verdict.53 If the inconsistency traces to a misunderstood rule, as with the city's causal role, reinstruction gives the jury a second chance to return a coherent verdict.54
General verdicts remain the norm even so, and the states differ on special verdicts: some require them, others permit them, and one or two bar them entirely.55 The persistence of the general verdict may reflect something the law finds desirable in insulating jury deliberations from judicial review, which a special verdict removes by exposing each answer to examination.56 A student should therefore not assume that a general verdict shows what the jury found on each element. It shows only the winner and the amount.