Concept
Duration and Damages
False imprisonment
Duration and Damages
Section 35 of the Restatement (Second) of Torts sets out the elements of false imprisonment,1 and under it an actor who intentionally confines another is liable if the person confined knew of the confinement or was harmed by it.2 Those elements ask for no measurable loss, and they ask for no minimum period of confinement. Once the plaintiff shows an intentional confinement, the burden shifts to the defendant to prove legal justification,3 so only two questions remain: whether the defendant can prove a justification, and how much the jury should award.
The tort needs no proof of loss because of what it protects. Assault compensates the fright a plaintiff feels before the punch connects;4 false imprisonment compensates the knowledge that she is not free to leave. The essence of the tort is the mental harm of knowing that one cannot move about at will, so where the confinement causes no other harm, the plaintiff must be aware of it at the time or there is no tort.5 If recovery also required bruises or lost wages, a defendant who deliberately locked a person in a room for an afternoon, leaving her unhurt and no poorer, would owe nothing. Nominal damages close that gap. They are a small sum awarded for the invasion itself, and they record that the defendant violated a right even though the plaintiff cannot price the injury.
Confinement for any appreciable time, however short, is sufficient,6 so a defendant cannot escape liability by pointing to the clock. The affront occurs when the plaintiff's freedom is overcome; the clock measures only how long it lasted. Banks v. Fritsch illustrates the consequence: an intentional confiner is liable for nominal damages when the plaintiff cannot prove actual damages. Time and injury therefore bear on how much the plaintiff recovers and never on whether she recovers. An answer that dismisses a five-minute detention because the plaintiff was unhurt confuses the amount of damages with the existence of the claim.
A plaintiff who can prove injury recovers more than a token. One store clerk accused of theft testified that the incident made her throat swell so that she could not breathe, and that she could no longer work in a store for fear of making mistakes and being treated that way again. Such consequences could support a substantial award. In some states punitive damages may also be available, which gives a plaintiff a reason to sue even when her physical or economic damages are small.7 Awareness still controls the proof. A plaintiff who knew of the confinement needs no other harm, but one who never knew of it recovers only if the confinement harmed her.8
Big Town Nursing Home, Inc. v. Newman shows the other end of the range. The plaintiff tried to escape the nursing home five or six times, and staff caught him and brought him back against his will each time. He was carried back to Wing 3 and locked and taped into a restraint chair for more than five hours, then put back in the chair on later occasions. The home's administrator testified that Wing 3 held senile patients, drug addicts, alcoholics, the mentally disturbed, incorrigibles, and uncontrollables, and that "they were all in the same kettle of fish."9 The court explained that exemplary damages may be imposed when the act causing actual damages is a wrongful act done intentionally in violation of the plaintiff's rights. It found that standard met because the home acted in utter disregard of his legal rights, knowing that no court order authorized his commitment and that its own admission agreement provided he was not to be kept against his will. The court of appeals then found the amount of damages excessive and offered a remittitur; the plaintiff accepted it, and the judgment, so reformed, was affirmed.10 The presence or absence of malice will aggravate or mitigate the damages.11
The rule that no other harm need be shown belongs to the intentional tort alone. Section 35(2) provides that an act not done with intent to confine does not make the actor liable for a merely transitory or otherwise harmless confinement, even though the act carried an unreasonable risk of confinement and would be negligent or reckless if that risk threatened bodily harm.12 A careless defendant thus faces no false imprisonment claim for a brief, harmless confinement, and any negligence claim would need proof of actual damage. The difference follows from culpability. A defendant who chooses to confine has committed the wrong the tort condemns, so the plaintiff may recover for the invasion itself. A careless defendant has chosen no such invasion, and where nothing was lost there is nothing for the law to award.