39 S.W.3d 474 (Ky. App. 2001)
In June 1996, Wade Banks was seventeen years old and a junior at Bourbon County High School.1 His last class of the day was Agriculture Wood Construction, taught by John Fritsch. Banks had either skipped the class or left early on multiple occasions during the semester.2
On June 4, another student warned Banks that Fritsch had a chain and planned to secure him to prevent skipping. Banks went to class anyway.3 Fritsch entered carrying a large log chain over his shoulder and key locks on his belt loop. After taking roll, Fritsch directed Banks to put his leg on a chair, secured the chain around his ankle, led him outside, wrapped the chain around a tree, locked it, and told him not to go anywhere.4 The rest of the class followed. Banks later removed the chain, attempted to leave, and was chased down, tackled, and carried back by classmates. Fritsch then placed a second chain around Banks's neck and secured it to the tree.5 After about fifteen minutes Banks sat down and cried. Fritsch eventually removed the neck chain but tightened the ankle chain. The two discussed Banks's grades. Fritsch checked his records and offered to let Banks pass if he painted three remaining troughs. Banks agreed, completed the work, and received a passing grade. Banks testified the entire episode lasted about an hour and a half.6
Fritsch testified the chaining began as a joke suggested by other students several days earlier. He stated Banks never objected, appeared to enjoy the attention, and that the incident lasted only twenty-five to thirty minutes.7 Another teacher saw Banks leaving the classroom with the chain on his ankle and observed that everyone, including Banks, seemed to be laughing. The same teacher also saw students lead Banks back after the chase.8
After the incident Banks saw a psychologist once. He testified that he frequently thought about the event, experienced flashbacks, and sometimes cried. Other students teased him and he received negative media attention. Banks decided not to return to Bourbon County High School and instead moved to Columbia, Missouri, to live with his father for his senior year. His family members stated he had difficulty dealing with the incident and often seemed withdrawn.9
A jury trial was held on July 21, 1999. At the close of Banks's case the Bourbon Circuit Court granted Fritsch's motion for directed verdict, finding sufficient evidence of false imprisonment and assault and battery but no evidence that Banks had been damaged by the conduct. The trial court entered judgment for Fritsch on all counts. Banks appealed.10
Whether the trial court erred in directing a verdict for Fritsch on the false imprisonment and assault and battery claims based on the absence of evidence that Banks suffered damages?11
The tort of false imprisonment protects the personal interest in freedom from physical restraint.12 It may be maintained without proof of actual damages.13 The tort is complete after even a brief restraint on the plaintiff's freedom, and the plaintiff may recover nominal damages.14 Since the injury is in large part a mental one, the plaintiff is also entitled to damages for mental suffering, humiliation and the like.15 A plaintiff need not prove actual damages in a claim for battery because a showing of actual damages is not an element of assault or battery.16 When no actual damages are shown for a battery, nominal damages may be awarded.17 Furthermore, a recovery for emotional distress caused by the assault or battery is allowable as an element of damages in an action based upon those torts.18
Yes. The established facts show that Banks testified he was deeply upset by the chaining and thought about it often.19 After the incident was publicized, other students gave him a hard time about it on several occasions and he received unwelcome negative media attention.20 Banks decided he could not return to Bourbon County High School and instead moved to Columbia, Missouri, to live with his father for his senior year, testifying that the move was traumatic and that it was difficult for him to fit in at the new school.21
Banks saw a psychologist once prior to the move. He further testified that he sometimes experiences flashbacks and starts to cry over memories of the chaining. His family members stated that Banks had a hard time dealing with the incident and often seemed withdrawn.22 Although there was contrary evidence that Banks did not express distress during the chaining itself, the jury could have returned a verdict for an amount greater than nominal damages based on this testimony of humiliation, embarrassment, and emotional distress.23 The degree of humiliation or embarrassment actually suffered is a factual matter for the jury to decide, so the trial court erred in directing a verdict on these claims.24
The trial court erred in directing a verdict for Fritsch on the false imprisonment and assault and battery claims.25
Whether the tort of outrageous conduct is available under the facts presented in this case?26
The tort of intentional infliction of emotional distress, or outrage, is intended as a gap-filler providing redress for extreme emotional distress where traditional common law actions do not apply.27 Where an actor’s conduct amounts to the commission of one of the traditional torts such as assault, battery, or false imprisonment for which recovery for emotional distress is allowed, and the conduct was not intended only to cause extreme emotional distress in the victim, the tort of outrage will not lie.28
No. The established facts indicate that Banks may recover emotional damages arising from false imprisonment, assault or battery.29 There is no evidence supporting a finding that Fritsch’s actions were intended only to cause Banks extreme emotional distress rather than to touch him or deprive him of his liberty.30 Fritsch testified that the idea of chaining Banks started as a joke between him and the other students in the class. Rather, Fritsch merely intended it as a light-hearted prank to impress on Banks the importance of staying in class and finishing his assignments.31
Because the traditional torts already provide a remedy for the emotional distress shown on these facts, the tort of outrageous conduct is not available.32
The tort of outrageous conduct is not available under the facts presented in this case.33