Concept
A Statement Relating to the Event
Excited utterance
A Statement Relating to the Event
Rule 803(2) reaches a statement “relating to a startling event or condition,” and its verb is looser than the one in the neighboring exception.1 The present sense impression in Rule 803(1) covers only a statement “describing or explaining” an event or condition.2 The Advisory Committee’s note ties the difference to what each exception assumes. Without a startling event, spontaneity may be trusted no farther than a description or explanation. Once an event has excited the declarant, the statement need only “relate” to it, and the permissible subject matter widens.3
Courts apply the requirement liberally. “Relating to” was chosen to reach beyond description and explanation, yet the rule still demands a relationship between the exciting event and the statement, and that relationship preserves the trustworthiness the exception depends on.4 The same wording also clarifies how the theory of an excited utterance differs from that of a present sense impression, a contrast this chapter takes up below.5
The test looks at the link and not at the form of the words, so a qualifying statement can take many shapes. If the statement relates to the event, it does not matter that it contains an opinion, supplies details, accuses someone of a crime, or serves the declarant’s interest. It is admissible even if the witness denies making it at trial.6 The Advisory Committee illustrated the breadth with two cases. In Sanitary Grocery Co. v. Snead, a slip-and-fall case, a clerk’s remark, “That has been on the floor for a couple of hours,” was held admissible. In Murphy Auto Parts Co. v. Ball, a driver’s statement that he had to call on a customer and was in a hurry to get home was admitted on the issue of his agency.7 Each remark goes to a circumstance surrounding the event instead of describing it: the clerk spoke to how long the hazard had been on the floor, and the driver to his errand and his haste. A statement about consequences qualifies as well. Suppose a witness to a car bombing, still excited, comments on the late arrival of medical personnel. Her comment relates to the explosion, the cause of her excitement.8
United States v. Boyce shows a court applying the test to a single phrase in a 911 call. Portis called 911 to ask the police for help with a domestic battery and told the operator that Boyce had a gun. When the operator asked whether she had seen it, she answered “Yes!” several times, and on further questioning she said she was “positive.”9 Boyce argued that her reference to a gun described a separate, earlier time when he possessed one and had nothing to do with the battery.10 The court of appeals found no abuse of discretion in the district court’s ruling that the gun statement related to the battery.11 Even if the gun was not within arm’s length while Boyce struck her, a victim who knows her assailant has access to a gun nearby will naturally think of the potential for more lethal force, and that is a subject likely to come up in describing the assault. The court framed the working question in the words of a treatise it quoted: if the subject matter of the statement is such as would likely be evoked by the event, the statement should be admitted.12
Statements that identify or describe the person responsible fit the same reasoning. In one case the declarant told an officer that she had been raped and shot, described her assailants as two young men who fit the description of Henyard and Smalls, and said they had taken her children. The court found she was still experiencing the trauma of what she had just survived and held the statements properly admitted.13 The startling event may also be a later one. Another court held that the display of a photograph, on the facts before it, was a sufficiently startling event to render the statement made in response admissible.14 An attack on the declarant instead of on the link gets a different answer. In Jeffers, the defendant argued that the statement rested on the unreliable perceptions of a declarant under the influence. The court replied that reliability, like competency, lies within the trial court’s sound discretion, and that credibility remains for the jury.15
The breadth has a limit. As an excited utterance goes beyond describing the exciting event and deals with past facts or with the future, it may take on a reflective quality, and a court must scrutinize it more carefully for true spontaneity. That the statement does not describe the exciting event is one factor the trial court weighs in deciding whether the words are a spontaneous, impulsive expression excited by the event.16 The distance is a factor and not a bar, but it works against the proponent.
The burden of showing the connection rests on the proponent, as Hall illustrates. The proponent, Hall, offered a witness’s account that O’Toole or his wife said they “had to get out of town because of the Jessica Roach abduction.” On its face the remark pointed at the abduction, yet the court of appeals found no error in excluding it. Hall offered no evidence of who uttered the statement and none of when. A proponent must show that the statement was made under such circumstances, and so soon after the occurrence, as to preclude reflection or deliberation.17 A remark that names the event therefore does not prove itself. The relation element is only one of three, and satisfying it cannot rescue a statement that fails the others.
A stem testing this element usually lets the declarant’s words wander, so assess each part of the statement by its tie to the event.
The third step settles most problems because it asks the question the Boyce court asked. The fourth step is where a statement that has drifted from the occasion draws closer scrutiny, and where a proponent who lays no foundation loses, as in Hall.