Concept
The Marriage Requirement
Marital communications
The Marriage Requirement
The first question in any marital-communications dispute is whether the speakers were spouses. The Supreme Court has held that confidential communications between husband and wife are privileged against compelled disclosure, and the protection covers the content of confidential statements made during the marriage.1 Federal courts break that holding into elements: the words or acts must be intended as a communication, the speakers must be validly married, and the communication must be confidential, meaning it was not made in the presence of, or likely to be overheard by, third parties.2 The marriage element comes first because a privilege for what spouses say to each other has nothing to attach to if the speakers were not spouses when they spoke.
A valid marriage opens the door but does not decide the case. A husband's request that his wife watch a bank for activity was not protected, even though the two were married, because he made it in a third person's presence.3 Exceptions also survive a valid marriage: the privilege does not attach to a communication made to further an ongoing or future crime.4 Courts apply the privilege narrowly throughout, because it obstructs the truth-seeking process and society has a strong interest in the administration of justice.5
The court examines the marriage on the day of the statement, not on the day of trial. The spouses must have been married when they spoke,6 and a confidence shared during a viable marriage keeps its protection even if the witness has since divorced the party.7 Measuring status at trial instead would strip divorced spouses of protection for confidences they shared in good faith, and it would let a couple who married after a damaging conversation claim a privilege for words spoken before the marriage began.
Asking whether a marriage existed when the statement was made raises two questions. Was the marriage legally valid, and was it still a living marriage? The next subsection takes up validity, and the one after it takes up permanent separation.
Valid Marriage
The first prerequisite is a marriage recognized as valid by state law at the time of the communication. The Sixth Circuit listed it first among three prerequisites in United States v. Porter,8 and the Ninth Circuit's formulation likewise requires a valid marriage alongside the communication and confidentiality elements.9 Even in federal court, state law decides whether the marriage existed.10
Borrowing the state's answer makes sense for two reasons. States control family law, so a federal court that wrote its own definition of marriage for evidence purposes would recognize spouses the state does not, or deny the privilege to couples the state treats as married for every other purpose. And because courts construe the privilege narrowly,11 a bright line drawn from legal status keeps the privilege from expanding with the sympathies of each case, which a test built on the parties' feelings or beliefs would invite.
Because state family law supplies the answer, the same living arrangement can produce a privilege in one state and none in another. States vary widely on common-law marriage, under which a couple who live together and hold themselves out as married can become spouses without a license or ceremony, and the family-law answer controls the evidentiary one.12
The claimant carries the burden of proving the marriage. In United States v. Jarvison, the Tenth Circuit recognized that the burden of establishing a privilege rests on the party asserting it and found the burden met where the government conceded that the couple could establish common-law marriage: they had cohabited for decades, official records and investigative reports showed that they held themselves out as husband and wife, and the wife testified under oath that she was his wife.13 That case involved the spousal testimonial privilege, but the confidences privilege likewise requires a valid marriage,14 so a showing of this kind satisfies its first element. Confidentiality works differently. Once the marriage is shown, the communication is presumed confidential, and the burden falls on the government to overcome that presumption, which it can do with proof that the spouses did not intend the statement to be private.15
The same dependence on legal status explains how the privilege reaches same-sex spouses. Obergefell v. Hodges recognized same-sex marriage as constitutionally protected, and the privilege follows legal marriage. Whether it also protects statements made earlier, while a couple lived in a committed arrangement that the law did not yet treat as marriage, is an open question, though one source suggests that it may well.16
A ceremony alone cannot create a legal marriage, and the privilege follows the law rather than the ceremony. In People v. Catlin the defendant went through a marriage ceremony with Edith Ballew while his divorce from his second wife was not yet final, so the two were not legally married when he spoke to her.17 The California Supreme Court held that the marital privilege applies only in the case of a valid marriage. It added that the defendant had offered no authority for treating a bona fide belief in the marriage's validity as a basis for the privilege, had not claimed such a belief at trial, and in any event suffered at most harmless error.18 The refusal makes sense because a good-faith test would ask courts to decide what a claimant privately believed about the status of a divorce, evidence that only the claimant can supply and that every bigamist has a reason to offer. A rule keyed to legal status asks only what the records show.
A marriage that has soured presents the opposite situation, and the answer turns on the same fact. In State v. Serrano the defendant invoked Oregon's marital communications privilege for a note in which his wife told him of her affair and for a conversation in which she told him she had become pregnant as a result. The state answered that the wife meant to end the marriage, that the marriage was in disrepair, and that the defendant would receive a windfall from a marriage that was barely intact.19 The Oregon Supreme Court refused to create a marital-health exception. The legislature listed three exceptions to the marital privileges (offenses by one spouse against the other, matters occurring before the marriage, and civil actions between the spouses), and it provided none for a troubled marriage; the court treated that omission as decisive.20 The statute's plain wording shows that the legislature intended the existence of a legal marriage to set the scope of the protection, so the privilege applies if the statements were made while the marriage was legally intact. Serrano applies a state statute, but its refusal to grade marriages is general, since courts will not inquire into the quality of the marriage.21
Read together, Catlin and Serrano show which fact carries the analysis. The marriage in Catlin never existed in law, so the sincerity of the ceremony changed nothing. The marriage in Serrano existed in law, so the wife's plan to leave changed nothing. On an exam, sincere belief, unhappiness, and talk of divorce are distractors, and the question to ask is whether the spouses were legally married on the date of the statement. Federal courts add one qualification, which the next subsection takes up: objective evidence that a legally intact marriage has permanently ended.22
Permanent Separation
Federal courts qualify the rule against grading marriages by asking whether the spouses had permanently separated when they spoke. In Porter the Sixth Circuit held the privilege inapplicable where the spouses have permanently separated, even if they were never legally divorced, and it noted that the Second, Seventh, Eighth, and Ninth Circuits had already recognized the same exception.24 Porter's wife, Jones, had been hospitalized twice with a miscarriage and its complications, had not seen him in over a week, and then moved out, with nothing in the record suggesting that they ever reconciled. Ten or twelve days later he telephoned to tell her that he had gone to Florida with two alleged coconspirators to buy a kilo of cocaine.25 By trial the couple had divorced, which removed any bar to her testifying, but a divorce does not by itself end the privilege for confidential marital communications, so the confidences privilege was the only protection Porter could invoke.26 The court held that this privilege did not cover the call, because the spouses had permanently separated by the time it was made.27
The Sixth Circuit presented the exception as the product of a balance between the need to protect spousal communications and the search for truth. It stressed that privileges are construed narrowly because they exclude relevant evidence, and it concluded that the search for truth outweighs any need to protect the confidentiality of separated couples.28 The balance comes out that way because of what the privilege is for. It exists so that spouses feel free to share their deepest feelings without fear that those feelings will later be exposed in court,29 much as the lawyer-client privilege exists so that clients will confide in their attorneys.30 A privilege that works by encouraging candor has something to encourage only while the spouses are still dealing with each other as spouses. Once they have permanently separated, shielding their words encourages nothing, yet the cost is the usual one, because a relevant statement stays from the factfinder. A call to a wife who has already moved out, with no sign of reconciliation, is a poor example of the intimate exchange the privilege was built to foster.
The exception can coexist with the refusal to weigh marital quality because it rests on evidence a judge can observe. Courts decline to ask how good a marriage was, yet they will look for objective evidence that it is no longer viable, and the usual markers are a formal or permanent separation or a divorce filing by one spouse. Communications made after those events are not privileged, even though the marriage continues in law.31 Frequent quarrels and a private wish to leave describe the quality of the relationship, which courts refuse to evaluate, and they do not supply the objective evidence the exception requires.
Whether the spouses were permanently separated is a preliminary question of fact, and the trial judge resolves it. The Sixth Circuit directed district courts to make a finding on that question as of the time of the communication, and it said the finding can rest on facts developed at a jury-out hearing or during the trial itself. It declined to require a detailed investigation of the marriage or the weighing of a prescribed list of factors, and it described the task as no harder than the other fact-finding calls judges make under the Federal Rules of Evidence.32 A hearing outside the jury's presence lets the judge decide the question without exposing the jurors to a statement that may turn out to be privileged. Fixing the finding to the date of the communication applies the same timing rule that governs the marriage requirement: a confidence shared while the marriage was viable keeps its protection whatever happens to the relationship afterward, a point developed in the section below on survival after the marriage ends.33
The Oregon Supreme Court reached the opposite conclusion about marital breakdown in Serrano, and the difference lies in the source of the law. The state urged the court to exclude any communication directed at ending the marriage, reasoning that admitting it would not advance the privilege's purpose of preserving marriages, since the wife was intending to dissolve the marriage when she spoke.34 The court answered from the text of the statute, which protects confidential communications made during a legal marriage and lists exceptions that include nothing for a marriage in poor health.35 The two decisions fit together once you see where each exception comes from. The permanent-separation exception is a limit that federal judges added to a common-law privilege, while a judge applying a statute may not insert an exception the legislature left out. On the reasoning of Serrano, a call between spouses who have moved apart but remain legally married would stay inside the Oregon privilege, although the same call falls outside the privilege in the Sixth Circuit.
An essay on this element therefore asks two questions in order. The first is which jurisdiction's law governs, since a statute may leave no room for a separation exception. The second, in federal court, is whether objective evidence showed that the spouses had permanently separated on the date of the statement.