Concept
Sexual-Offense Departures
Admissibility of character
Sexual-Offense Departures
Rule 404(a)(2)(B) lets a criminal defendant offer evidence of an alleged victim's pertinent trait, but its opening words limit the option: it is "subject to the limitations in Rule 412."1 That phrase flags the first of two departures from the ordinary scheme. Ordinarily the propensity bar is the default, the defendant decides whether to open the subject of character, and the prosecution answers only after he does. In sexual-assault and child-molestation cases that scheme no longer holds, and the two changes run in opposite directions. One narrows what a defendant may prove about the alleged victim. The other widens what the prosecution may prove about the defendant.2
The victim-side change answered a record of abuse. Juries, judges, and commentators tended to overvalue a complainant's sexual history as proof of consent. They also misused it, treating it as a reason not to worry much about a rape even if one occurred. And admitting it turned rape trials into trials of the victim, which brutalized her and discouraged other victims from coming forward.3
The defendant-side change is newer. The Federal Rules and some state codes now allow prosecutors, and plaintiffs in civil cases, to offer evidence of the defendant's character in the case-in-chief, a step the old structure withheld until the defendant chose to open the door.4 The amendments rest on perceived differences between these cases and others, and they remain controversial.5
Rule 412 comes first because it directly limits the victim-trait option taught earlier. Rules 413 through 415, the propensity rules for accused offenders, follow.
Rule 412 Rape Shield
Rule 412 is a rape shield law. It bars proof of an alleged victim's "other sexual behavior," meaning past acts, and of the victim's "sexual predisposition," meaning opinion or reputation testimony, in criminal and civil cases involving sexual misconduct.6 The Advisory Committee's note applies the bar to a victim's dress, lifestyle, or fantasies when a party offers them to suggest sexual character.7
The rule stands in front of the victim-trait option. Rule 404(a)(2) otherwise lets a defendant offer a bad trait of the victim, and Rule 412 removes one trait from that option, the victim's "character for chastity" in the language of older cases.8 The first question about any defense proffer concerning an alleged victim is therefore whether it describes sexual behavior or sexual predisposition. If it does, Rule 412 answers before any analysis of a pertinent trait under Rule 404(a)(2)(B) begins.
Two features of the evidence explain the bar. First, it proves little: a person's past sexual conduct is rarely relevant to how that person acted sexually on a specific occasion.9 The common-law practice of cross-examining complainants about their sexual behavior, on the theory that it bore on credibility and consent, shows how thin the justification was. Courts did not think such questioning bore on the credibility of women testifying in other kinds of cases, and they allowed it in rape trials even when clinical evidence made any suggestion of consent ridiculous.10 Second, the evidence does harm. It creates a trial within a trial over the victim's moral character, and a factfinder who thinks the victim has low moral character may treat her as someone who was "asking" for sex whether or not she consented this time. The factfinder may also overvalue the step from past consent to present consent.11 Weak value set against those harms explains a bar that opens in criminal cases only through narrow exceptions.
In a criminal case the court may admit three kinds of evidence despite the prohibition:
- Specific instances of the victim's sexual behavior, offered to prove that someone other than the defendant was the source of semen, injury, or other physical evidence.12
- Specific instances of the victim's sexual behavior with the person accused, offered by the defendant to prove consent or offered by the prosecutor.13
- Evidence whose exclusion would violate the defendant's constitutional rights.14
The first exception has nothing to do with the victim's disposition. It becomes relevant when the prosecutor alleges that the defendant had sex with the victim and the defendant denies it. The prosecutor may then offer semen or bruising suggesting intercourse, and the defendant may answer with specific instances showing that someone else was the source.15 The second exception reaches only behavior with the accused, so a defendant who wants to show consent through the complainant's encounters with other people gains nothing from it. Because the first two exceptions name only specific instances, reputation and opinion evidence about a criminal complainant's sexual behavior has no route in.
The third exception rarely does any work. Occasions when excluding evidence satisfies the Federal Rules yet violates the accused's constitutional rights are infrequent, because the drafters crafted the rules to minimize constitutional concerns. Applying Rule 412 can still restrict a defense so severely that constitutional principles override the prohibition, but that happens only when the proffered evidence is strongly probative of the defendant's innocence.16 Olden v. Kentucky is the standard illustration. The Court found error in refusing to let the defendant ask the complainant whether she had claimed rape to preserve her relationship with the boyfriend she was living with.17
Civil cases use a different test. The court may admit evidence of a victim's sexual behavior or sexual predisposition only if its probative value substantially outweighs the danger of harm to any victim and of unfair prejudice to any party, and it admits reputation evidence only if the victim has placed the reputation in controversy.18 This inverts the Rule 403 balance. Rule 403 favors admission, while this standard favors exclusion, so the party who wants the evidence carries the burden.19 An employer defending a harassment suit who offers evidence of the plaintiff's private dating life must clear that bar.
A proponent under Rule 412(b) must also follow a procedure. The proponent files a motion that describes the evidence and states its purpose, at least 14 days before trial unless the court sets a different time for good cause, and serves it on all parties and notifies the victim or the victim's guardian or representative.20 Before admitting the evidence, the court must hold an in camera hearing, meaning a private one, at which the victim and the parties may attend and be heard. Unless the court orders otherwise, the motion, the related materials, and the record of the hearing stay sealed.21 The judge therefore rules on a written proffer before any of the evidence reaches the jury.
On an exam, work a sexual-misconduct stem in this order. First, decide whether the defense proffer concerns the alleged victim's sexual behavior or predisposition. Second, exclude reputation and opinion in a criminal case. Third, admit specific instances only if they fit one of the three exceptions and pass the motion and hearing.
Rules 413 Through 415
Rule 413(a) provides that in a criminal case in which a defendant is accused of sexual assault, the court may admit evidence that the defendant committed any other sexual assault, and that the evidence "may be considered on any matter to which it is relevant." Rule 414(a) gives the same permission when the defendant is accused of child molestation and the other act is another child molestation. Rule 415(a) carries both into a civil case involving a claim for relief based on a party's alleged sexual assault or child molestation.23 These rules mirror Rule 412. Rule 412 is essentially exclusionary as to a victim's sexual behavior and predisposition, while Rules 413 through 415 are essentially inclusionary as to the accused's.24
The inclusion reverses Rule 404(b)(1), which bars evidence of a crime or other act offered to prove character in order to show conduct in conformity.25 The newer rules rest on the premise that an alleged offender's collateral sexual behavior of the same type as the charged conduct has strong probative value.26 Under Rule 413(a) the jury may follow the inference that Rules 404(a)(1) and 404(b)(1) otherwise forbid: the defendant assaulted before, so he is the kind of person who assaults, so he probably did so this time.27 The prosecutor need not wait for the defendant to open the subject of character, because the amendments allow the evidence in the case-in-chief.28
Critics raise two objections, and both appear in the sources. First, the premises conflict. Rule 412 assumes that a person's past sexual conduct is rarely relevant to how the person acted on a specific occasion, while Rules 413 through 415 treat a defendant's past sexual offenses as relevant to his conduct on a specific occasion.29 Second, the rules can add convictions only among defendants who would be acquitted under the ordinary rule and who have an alleged history of sexual assault. Whether that improves accuracy depends on how many of those defendants are innocent. Even if only 10% are, raising the chance of convicting all of them runs against the principle that it is far worse to convict an innocent man than to let a guilty man go free.30 For exam purposes the rules apply as written.
The rules reach only offenses of the same type. Rule 413 applies when the defendant is accused of sexual assault and the other act is another sexual assault, and Rule 414 applies only to a child-molestation charge and another child molestation. A prior sexual assault offered in a murder or robbery trial, or a non-sexual offense offered in a sexual-assault trial, stays under Rule 404(b), where it comes in only for a purpose other than propensity.31 Rule 413(c) leaves the other rules of evidence in place, so evidence that falls outside Rules 413 through 415 can still come in under Rule 404(b)(2) for a purpose such as motive, intent, or identity.32 The limit tracks the justification. The premise that same-type collateral behavior strongly predicts the charged behavior gives out when the earlier act and the charged act are different kinds of wrongs.33
Each rule defines its offense category by statute and conduct, and Rule 415 applies only to a civil claim for relief based on a party's alleged sexual assault or child molestation, so a negligence or contract claim between the same parties does not qualify.34 Test the other act against the definition, not against the label the stem uses.
Each rule also carries a disclosure requirement. The prosecutor in a criminal case, and the offering party in a civil case, must disclose the evidence to the opponent, including witnesses' statements or a summary of their expected testimony, at least 15 days before trial or at a later time the court allows for good cause.35
Rule 403 stays in force, because Rule 413(c) leaves the other rules of evidence in place. The court can still exclude evidence whose probative value is substantially outweighed by dangers such as confusion, remoteness, or time consumption.36 The balance still works differently here than under Rule 404(b). When evidence is offered under Rule 404(b), the court weighs only the probative value for the non-character purpose, and the risk that jurors will convict on propensity counts as prejudice. Under Rules 413 through 415 the jury may draw the propensity inference, so that inference counts as probative value and its use cannot be called prejudicial.37 The inference thus moves from the prejudice side of the scale to the probative side, which makes exclusion of a same-type prior offense highly unlikely, though not impossible.38
The second step does most of the work on an exam, because the stem usually describes an offense that is not a sexual assault in language that sounds close to one. Students most often get the fourth step backward, because the usual instinct to count propensity as prejudice must be set aside when Rule 413, 414, or 415 applies.