Concept
Cover Damages
Aggrieved buyer's remedies when the seller breaches
Cover Damages
When a seller fails to deliver or repudiates, or when the buyer rightfully rejects or justifiably revokes acceptance, § 2-711(1)(a) lets the buyer “cover” and have damages under the next section “as to all the goods affected whether or not they have been identified to the contract.”1 Cover is the buyer’s own replacement transaction: the buyer buys substitutes and recovers the extra it had to pay over what the contract promised. The last clause of that paragraph matters most when the seller never delivered, because a seller that repudiates before setting goods aside cannot answer a cover claim by pointing out that nothing was identified to the contract.
The drafters built the remedy around a real purchase because they distrusted the older market measure. In their view, a market comparison was often arbitrary: it overcompensated a buyer who bought substitutes for less than the court’s market figure and undercompensated one who paid more.2 Cover, the new measure in § 2-712, replaces that estimate with a transaction the buyer actually made.3
As a measure of damages, cover is optional. A buyer may skip it and sue for the difference between market and contract price, but that remedy applies only when and to the extent the buyer has not covered.4 The same word does a second job in the Code, because buying substitutes is also a way of minimizing loss, and a buyer who wants consequential damages may be required to do it.5 What counts as cover can differ with the job, and this section treats cover only as a measure of damages.6 It asks three questions: what a replacement purchase must be to qualify, how damages are computed once it does, and whether a buyer that makes or draws on its own goods has purchased anything at all.
Requirements for Valid Cover
Section 2-712(1) permits cover “by making in good faith and without unreasonable delay any reasonable purchase of or contract to purchase goods in substitution for those due from the seller.”7 Three requirements follow from that sentence. The buyer must act in good faith, must act without unreasonable delay, and must buy goods that reasonably substitute for those due. A replacement that misses any one is not cover in the Code’s sense, though a binding contract to purchase counts as readily as a completed purchase.
Each requirement closes a different route to an inflated recovery. The formula pays the buyer the amount by which its replacement cost exceeds the contract price, so the buyer’s own transaction fixes the seller’s bill and the seller can review it only afterward.8 A buyer sure of reimbursement has reasons to buy lavishly, to upgrade, to gamble on the market, or to relabel a purchase it would have made anyway. Disputes therefore gather around four questions: whether the buyer paid too much, delayed unreasonably, lacked good faith, or bought goods of higher quality or grade that are not a reasonable substitute.9 The seller in KGM Harvesting Co. v. Fresh Network contested none of the four and pressed a windfall objection instead.10
The delay requirement gives the buyer room before it limits the buyer. The official comment to § 2-712 says that “without unreasonable delay” is not meant to limit the time the buyer needs to look around and decide how best to cover, so a buyer may spend days canvassing suppliers. The limit exists because cover turns the buyer’s market decision into the seller’s bill. A buyer that waits for prices to fall risks little: if they fall, it covers cheaply, and if they rise, it asks the seller to absorb the increase. Reading “unreasonable delay” to confine the buyer to the time a prudent purchaser needs removes that one-way option. How long is too long depends on the market and the goods.
The third requirement turns on what the buyer bought. The replacement need not be identical to the contract goods, but it must be a commercially reasonable substitute, and a buyer who buys superior or significantly different goods has not covered.11 Purchases fail that test in two ways: some buy the wrong goods for this contract, and others buy suitable goods for another purpose.
In Kanzmeier v. McCoppin, the buyer replaced undelivered cattle with cattle that weighed less. The court recognized that a buyer who buys goods substantially different from those contracted for has not covered, and it treated whether a given purchase was in fact cover as a question for the trier of fact. The court in Keller v. Inland Metals All Weather Conditioning, Inc. drew the same limit by comparison: it would be anomalous to hold a covering buyer to goods of the same kind while letting a buyer who seeks market damages recover on the value of different, more expensive goods.12 Neither route lets the buyer bill the seller for an upgrade.
The wrong-purpose failure appears in H-W-H Cattle Co. v. Schroeder. From testimony about the buyer’s order-buying operation, the court concluded that cattle the buyer purchased in Dodge City were not substitutes for the cattle the seller failed to deliver, and it rejected the seller’s argument that the buyer had elected to cover and so limited its damages under § 2-712.13 The Keller goods were wrong in kind; the H-W-H goods were right in kind but tied to nothing this seller owed. A buyer that would have made those purchases anyway has incurred no replacement cost caused by the breach.
The seller bears the burden of showing that cover was not reasonably obtained.14 The allocation fits the setting. A buyer that covers acts in a live market under pressure to secure goods, and a rule requiring it to prove every alternative inferior would discourage the prompt replacement the remedy invites. The seller is the party positioned to point to a cheaper source or a better moment to buy.
A purchase that fails as cover does not leave the buyer without a remedy, but it moves the buyer from the cover formula to the market measure, which applies when and to the extent the buyer has not covered.15 A buyer that does not cover when it should risks more, because a court may deny it incidental and consequential damages.16
Steps two and three decide whether the purchase counts as a replacement at all; steps four and five decide whether the buyer carried it out properly. A buyer that clears all five has valid cover and moves on to the arithmetic.
Computing Cover Damages
A buyer whose purchase qualifies as cover recovers under § 2-712(2) “the difference between the cost of cover and the contract price together with any incidental or consequential damages as hereinafter defined (Section 2-715), but less expenses saved in consequence of the seller’s breach.”18 Section 2-711(1)(a) sends the buyer there.19 In shorthand the formula is Cover − KP + ID + CD − ES, where KP is the contract price, ID incidental damages, CD consequential damages, and ES expenses saved.20 Every figure in a problem belongs to one of those five terms.
The first two terms carry the weight. Had the seller performed, the buyer would have paid the contract price, so only the excess of the replacement cost over that price is attributable to the breach. The contract price comes off in full whether or not the buyer has paid any of it. A buyer that prepaid also recovers what it paid, because the Code lets the buyer recover so much of the price as has been paid in addition to damages, whether or not it cancels.21 That rejects the older rule that forced a buyer to choose between a refund and damages.22
The other three terms adjust the core. Incidental damages cover the reasonable expenses the breach causes the buyer, including commercially reasonable charges, expenses, and commissions in connection with effecting cover.23 Consequential damages add losses that flow from the buyer’s particular needs, but only from circumstances the seller knew or had reason to know about, and they must be proved with reasonable certainty.24 The last term subtracts expenses saved, because a buyer entitled to the position performance would have produced should not also keep money the breach spared it from spending. These are buyer’s terms. Sellers get no consequential damages under Article 2, although a seller may recover lost profit and reasonable overhead when the ordinary measure is inadequate to put it in as good a position as performance.25
A standard illustration supplies the numbers. Acme agrees to sell Wiley 500 anvils at $700 each under a destination contract, so Acme bears the $5,000 cost of transport. Acme breaches, and Wiley reasonably covers with Road Runner at $750 per anvil under a shipment contract, so Wiley pays the $5,000 itself. Neither price includes transport charges.26
A comparison of totals confirms the result. Performance would have cost Wiley $350,000 delivered, while cover cost $375,000 plus $5,000 of transport, or $380,000, so Wiley ends up $30,000 worse off than performance would have left it. The saved-expense term is the one most likely to change such a comparison.
The formula also bends when the substitute is better than the goods due. Suppose Wiley cannot find anvils like Acme’s and contracts with Road Runner for 500 premium anvils at $850 each. Setting incidental expenses aside, and assuming the court accepts the purchase as a reasonable cover, the price gap is $425,000 minus $350,000, or $75,000. But Wiley earns $50 more in profit on each premium anvil, $25,000 across the 500, and that extra profit comes off the award, which leaves $50,000.27 The deduction follows the Code’s general aim of putting the buyer in as good a position as performance would have, and no better.28 Performance would not have given Wiley the extra $50 on each anvil; the breach did, by moving Wiley into a better product. The adjustment presupposes a substitute the court is willing to call reasonable, since a purchase of superior or significantly different goods can fail as cover altogether.29
Decided cases apply the same arithmetic. In Atlan Industries, Inc. v. O.E.M., Inc. the buyer claimed to have received 27,245 pounds of defective resin but proved receipt of only 23,080 pounds. With cover costing 42 cents per pound more than the contract price, the court multiplied by the lower figure and found damages for cover of $9,693.60.30 The multiplier is the quantity the buyer proves it had to replace, and a larger claim without proof adds nothing. An Illinois appellate court applied the formula after a repudiation and rejected the seller’s argument that § 2-713 supplied the measure: that section governs where the buyer has not covered, and where the buyer has covered, § 2-712(2) controls.31
Sellers sometimes argue that the buyer’s loss is smaller than the formula shows because the buyer passed the higher replacement cost along to its own customers. A Kentucky appellate court rejected that argument in Consolidated Aluminum Corp. v. Krieger. Nothing in the cover section or elsewhere in the Code, it reasoned, requires the innocent buyer and its customers to absorb the cost of the seller’s breach, and the only restriction on the remedy is that the buyer make a reasonable purchase in good faith and without unreasonable delay.32 In KGM, the buyer’s cost-plus contract with its own customer let it pass on all but $70,000 of the extra expense of the substitute lettuce, and the seller urged the court not to allow a windfall.33 The California Court of Appeal upheld the § 2-712 award without needing to reach two jury findings the seller challenged.34
The reason runs through the structure of the measure. Cover prices the buyer’s replacement against the seller’s promise, while what the buyer later recoups from a customer depends on a separate contract the seller did not make. Crediting that recoupment would let a breaching seller profit from arrangements between the buyer and a third party. In KGM the point had particular force, because the seller sold the lettuce at the higher market price and made between $800,000 and $1.1 million more than the 9-cent contract price would have paid.35 The rule fits with the premium-anvil deduction. That deduction applies where the substitute is better than the goods due and the buyer earns extra profit from the upgrade, while the KGM seller did not contend that the replacement lettuce was of higher grade.36 Whether a windfall objection has more force against the market-price measure is a question for the market-price section.
Self-Cover and Inventory
Every cover problem so far has involved a buyer that went to another seller, and the statute fits that picture: cover is a “purchase of or contract to purchase goods” in substitution for those due.39 A buyer sometimes meets the shortfall differently, by manufacturing the missing goods itself or by drawing them from stock it already holds. Whether either course counts as cover is unsettled, and the answer decides whether the buyer measures its loss under § 2-712 or falls back on § 2-713, the market-price measure taken up in the next section.40
Some courts treat in-house production as cover. In Dura-Wood Treating Co. v. Century Forest Industries, Inc., the Fifth Circuit let an aggrieved buyer recover the difference between the contract price and what it cost the buyer to manufacture substitute goods in house.41 The Maine Supreme Judicial Court reached a similar result in Cives Corp. v. Callier Steel Pipe & Tube, Inc., where the seller failed to deliver steel tubing, the buyer could not find another supplier, and the buyer recovered the difference between its in-house manufacturing cost and the contract price.42 The rationale is that cover exists to get the buyer the goods it needs, and the money spent making them is a real replacement cost caused by the breach. Those decisions leave open how to price the buyer’s own materials and labor: whether the buyer is held to the historic cost of its components or may charge current market prices when those are higher.43
The Seventh Circuit took the opposite view in Chronister Oil Co. v. Unocal Refining & Marketing, holding that a buyer that covered by drawing on its own gasoline inventory was not entitled to cover damages.44 Unocal sought the difference between the contract price of 60.4 cents per gallon and the 63.14-cent average cost of the inventory it drew on, a claim of 2.74 cents per gallon. On the market it could have bought gasoline for about 55 cents, so the seller’s breach had actually saved it money. Judge Posner reasoned that drawing on inventory is not a “purchase of or contract to purchase goods,” because you cannot “purchase,” in ordinary language or in Code usage, what you already own. He added that doing “violence to the text” of § 2-712 was unnecessary, because § 2-713 supplied a market-price remedy.45
The label controlled the money. Under cover, Unocal’s claim was 2.74 cents per gallon; under § 2-713, market minus contract price comes out negative on those figures, because the market price of about 55 cents sat below the 60.4-cent contract price.46 Unocal’s self-cover also cost more than buying on the market, which distinguishes it from the buyer in Dura-Wood.47 The objection to self-cover concerns the absence of any transaction, not the identity of the seller: one decision allowed a buyer to cover by entering a substitute purchase with the breaching seller itself, citing Kelsey-Hayes.48
A related question arises when the buyer replaces the missing goods from inventory it bought before the breach. In a suit for contract-market damages under § 2-713, a seller argued that the buyer had already covered out of inventory purchased from other sellers before the breach. The court held that if the buyer had built the inventory as a backup against the loss of other sources, such as the defendant, the inventory could constitute cover.49 That holding meets the textual objection, because the buyer did purchase those goods from third parties; only the timing is unusual. The stakes are real, since the market-price measure applies only when and to the extent the buyer has not covered, so a seller that proves cover from backup stock displaces the market formula.50 Ordinary working stock presents a different problem: goods bought for routine production were not acquired to replace anything this seller promised.
A fact pattern in which the buyer makes the goods or uses its own stock calls for naming both approaches. One line treats in-house cost less contract price as cover under § 2-712, as the Fifth Circuit and the Maine court did, and may treat inventory built as a backup the same way.51 The other, led by the Seventh Circuit, holds that nothing was purchased and sends the buyer to § 2-713.52 A complete answer runs the numbers both ways, because the two sections can yield different recoveries, as Unocal’s own figures show.