34 F.3d 462, 24 UCC2d 485 (7th Cir. 1994)
Chronister Oil Company brought this diversity suit against Union Oil Company (Unocal) for breach of contract after agreeing to sell 25,000 barrels of gasoline.1
The contract, made February 9, 1990, provided that Chronister would deliver the 25,000 barrels to Colonial Pipeline on the front seventh cycle at a price of 60.4 cents a gallon.2 Chronister contracted with Enron to fulfill the delivery, and Enron arranged with Crown Petroleum to deliver on March 5, 1990.3
When Colonial rejected the gasoline due to excess water on March 5, Unocal informed Chronister on March 6 and gave it until March 7 to deliver conforming product.4 Chronister offered substitute delivery on the back seventh cycle, which Unocal refused, leading Chronister to sell the gasoline to Aectra Refining at 55.3 cents per gallon while Unocal diverted 25,000 barrels from its inventory with an average cost of 63.14 cents per gallon.5
Chronister sued for damages based on the difference between the contract price and the Aectra sale price, and Unocal counterclaimed for damages based on its inventory cost.6 After a bench trial, the magistrate judge awarded Unocal $26,000 in damages, and Chronister appealed to the Seventh Circuit.7
Whether Chronister breached the contract by failing to deliver the gasoline on the front seventh cycle?8
Under the Uniform Commercial Code as interpreted by the Illinois courts, a seller breaches a contract for the sale of goods by failing to deliver conforming goods at the time and place specified in the contract, and liability for breach is strict.9
Yes. The contract made February 9, 1990, required Chronister to deliver the 25,000 barrels to Colonial Pipeline on the front seventh cycle at a price of 60.4 cents a gallon.10 Chronister arranged delivery through Enron and Crown Petroleum for March 5, but Colonial rejected the gasoline because it contained too much water.11 Although Chronister was not responsible for the contamination, strict liability applies and the failure to deliver conforming product within the cycle constituted a breach.12
Unocal gave Chronister until March 7 to cure, but Chronister could not supply front seventh cycle product and instead offered later-cycle delivery that Unocal properly refused.13 The breach was material because Unocal, like other marketers, depends on timely deliveries to avoid supply interruptions to its dealers while minimizing inventory.14
Chronister breached the contract.15
Whether Unocal could recover damages measured by the difference between its average inventory cost and the contract price after diverting gasoline from its own inventory?16
UCC section 2-712 authorizes a buyer to recover the difference between the cost of cover and the contract price only when the buyer purchases or contracts to purchase substitute goods. Using goods already owned does not constitute cover.17
No. Unocal diverted 25,000 barrels already in its pipeline inventory rather than purchasing substitute gasoline on the open market.1819 The cover remedy supplies a market measure of harm, which is unavailable when a buyer simply reallocates its own existing goods.20
Unocal's diversion was a reasonable response to the breach, but the proper measure of any harm would be opportunity cost, not historical inventory cost.21 The two Illinois cases addressing the issue confirm that self-help from inventory does not qualify as cover.22
Unocal could not recover damages measured by the difference between its average inventory cost and the contract price.23
Whether Unocal suffered any actual damages from the breach in light of the decline in market prices for gasoline?24
Contract damages are intended to place the injured party in the position it would have occupied had the breach not occurred, compensating only for actual loss that the party would otherwise have avoided.25
No. Market prices for gasoline delivered to the Colonial Pipeline had fallen by early March, with comparable sales occurring at approximately 55 cents per gallon.2627 Had Unocal purchased substitute barrels on the market it would have paid less than the 60.4-cent contract price and realized a savings rather than a loss.28 Unocal also had an independent interest in drawing down its Baton Rouge inventory because an impending pressure change would soon render much of that inventory unshippable.29
Unocal's counsel acknowledged at argument that the breach left Unocal better off, a fact evident within fifteen days after the breach. Because Unocal incurred no actual loss, it is entitled only to nominal damages.30
Unocal suffered no actual damages from the breach.31