Concept
Restitution After Total Breach
Restitution interest
Restitution After Total Breach
A buyer pays $20,000 toward a $100,000 tract of land, and the seller then wrongfully refuses to convey title. The buyer recovers the $20,000 in restitution, even if the land is worth only $70,000 and performance would have cost the buyer money.1 The Restatement (Second) of Contracts states the rule behind that result: on a breach by non-performance that gives rise to a claim for damages for total breach, or on a repudiation, the injured party is entitled to restitution for any benefit conferred on the other party by way of part performance or reliance (§ 373(1)).2 The rule uses the same benefit language that defines the restitution interest, so the question stays where earlier sections put it: what does the other side now hold that came from the claimant?
Section 373(1) begins “subject to the rule stated in Subsection (2).” That subsection denies restitution to an injured party who has performed all of its duties and awaits only payment of a definite sum of money for that performance.3 The exception has its own section near the end of this chapter, and nothing below depends on it.
Total breach usually interrupts an exchange partway through. The injured party has already paid, worked, or delivered, and the other side holds that value while the return performance never arrives. The same breach also supports a claim for damages, so the injured party has a choice to make.4 This section follows that order. It asks first which breaches open the door to restitution, then why a claimant who could sue for damages would elect restitution instead.
Total Breach or Repudiation
Section 373(1) asks for two things. The other side must have committed a total breach by non-performance or have repudiated, and the injured party must have conferred a benefit on it by part performance or reliance.5 Later parts of this chapter measure the benefit. This subsection concerns the first requirement, the trigger.
The rule borrows its trigger from damages. A non-performance opens the door to restitution when it gives rise to a claim for damages for total breach, and repudiation opens the door by name.6 Because the rule lists repudiation apart from non-performance, an injured party who faces a refusal to perform need not wait for a performance date to pass and a default to follow.
The label matters because of what it does to the contract. A total breach discharges the injured party’s obligation to perform and any obligation to accept further performance, yet it preserves the right to damages for breach of the entire contract.7 Restitution is a remedy for total breach only. A party injured by a partial breach recovers damages for it and nothing in restitution.8
History explains the limit. In former times a suit for damages was deemed an action to enforce the contract, while a suit for restitution was deemed an election to rescind the contract and pursue a quasi-contractual remedy outside it. Courts now recognize both as remedial rights based on the contract, but the older view still shapes when restitution is available and how it is measured.9 A claimant who keeps the contract in force stays inside it; a claimant who wants restitution must first leave it.
The land buyer’s case runs the other way. The seller’s refusal ended the exchange before the buyer received anything for the $20,000, and once the buyer treats the contract as ended, the only question left is what the seller now holds. The Supreme Court applied the same logic to money advanced under a contract: upon repudiation, principles of restitution normally require the recipient to refund it.10
A total breach or repudiation does not end the contract by itself, because the injured party must act on it. Restitution is available only when the breach is total and the injured party has made two elections. First, the injured party must elect to cancel. If it does not, the contract continues to bind both parties, and the injured party may recover damages for partial breach but not restitution. Second, once cancellation is effective, the injured party generally must choose between restitution (quantum meruit) and damages, and in some cases specific performance is available too. The deadline for that choice varies by jurisdiction.11
The notice that accomplishes cancellation has traditionally been called “rescission,” and the word is a trap.12 A mutual rescission and an aggrieved party’s cancellation produce quite distinct legal relations, yet one word has covered both. The word also echoes the old view, in which a claim for restitution meant electing to rescind and sue outside the contract. An injured party who announces that the contract is “rescinded” therefore invites the argument that it has given up its damages and kept only restitution. A party who wants to keep damages should cancel or declare a total breach, which preserves the right to damages for breach of the entire contract.13 The Uniform Commercial Code avoids the confusion by using the word “cancel.”14 It also preserves remedies for breach when either party puts an end to a contract for the other’s breach, unless a contrary intention clearly appears (§§ 2–106(3), (4) and 2–720).15
Electing Restitution Over Damages
A total breach hands the injured party two claims for one wrong: damages, and restitution of the benefit conferred.17 After cancellation the claimant generally must elect between them.18 A claimant content with the benefit of the bargain can sue for damages and leave restitution unused. In many cases the two dollar figures coincide, and the choice is then academic. When they diverge, the plaintiff will prefer restitution when it is easier to prove than damages and when it will yield a greater recovery.19 Each condition has its own typical setting.
Expectation damages require proof of what performance would have produced. That proof can end in a jury verdict that an appellate court must review, as in Sullivan v. O’Connor, where the Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts reviewed a verdict of contract damages after a plastic surgeon’s unsuccessful effort to shorten the plaintiff’s nose.20 Restitution asks only what the other side received, which is a fact about the past. In Mobil Oil Exploration & Producing Southeast v. United States, the Government broke its promise, and the Supreme Court held that it must give the companies their money back, whether or not the contracts would ultimately have proved financially beneficial to them.21 The Court offered a second example: a purchaser whose lottery operator fails to deliver a ticket gets his money back, whether or not he eventually would have won.
The second reason arises when the contract itself was a bad one. In United States ex rel. Coastal Steel Erectors, Inc. v. Algernon Blair, Inc., a steel-erection subcontractor stopped work because the prime contractor refused to pay for crane rental that the subcontract required. The district court treated the refusal as a material breach that justified the stoppage, yet it subtracted the loss the subcontractor would have suffered by completing and denied recovery. The Fourth Circuit reversed. A subcontractor who justifiably stops work because of the other side’s breach may recover in quantum meruit the value of the labor and equipment already furnished, whether or not it could recover in a suit on the contract.22
The difference lies in what each remedy deducts. Expectation damages subtract the loss the claimant would have suffered by finishing, because they aim to leave the claimant where performance would have left it. For a claimant who stopped only because the other side breached, that subtraction lets the breaching party keep finished work and pay little or nothing for it on the ground that the claimant made a poor bargain. Restitution looks at what the defendant received, so the claimant’s poor bargain never enters the calculation.
The hypothetical keeps the restitution figure below the $40,000 price. Whether the price caps restitution on a losing contract, and how the work is valued, are questions for the later sections on measuring the benefit.
A profitable job reverses the comparison. Suppose the price is again $40,000, the total cost is $32,000, and Owner repudiates after Builder has spent $16,000. Expectation damages come to $24,000, while restitution of work worth $16,000 leaves Builder $8,000 short, which is the profit Builder lost. The election therefore compares two figures on the facts at hand, and neither remedy wins in every case.
Once the claimant has chosen, the two remedies operate as alternatives. Courts occasionally permit both restitution and damages, though the two ordinarily should be in the alternative, and election-of-remedy doctrines sometimes hold the plaintiff to a choice.23 A plaintiff may combine remedies only so far as the total gives no more than one complete compensation or one complete restitution.24 The garage case shows why. The $26,000 of expectation damages and the $30,000 of restitution both pay for the same labor, so a Builder who collected both would take $56,000 for $30,000 of work under a $40,000 contract, counting one performance twice. The tempting answer, that a party wronged by breach should claim everything available, fails for that reason.
The election has a sequence. Restitution is available only after the injured party cancels in response to a total breach, and after cancellation the claimant generally chooses between restitution and damages at a time that varies by jurisdiction. A party with only a partial breach has no election to make, because the contract remains in force and damages are the only remedy.25 The restitution question is also separate from the damages analysis: one appellate court remanded a case because the trial court, resting on the common law rule, never considered whether the appellant was entitled to restitution under the Restatement (Second) of Contracts.26 How a court fixes the amount of a restitution award is the subject of the measuring sections later in this chapter.