650 F.3d 839 (2d Cir. 2011)
Defendants Linda O'Connor and Dean Sacco appeal from final judgments entered in the United States District Court for the Northern District of New York following a jury trial before Thomas J. McAvoy, Judge, convicting them of sex trafficking of a child, in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 1591; convicting O'Connor of selling a child for the purpose of producing child pornography, in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 2251A(a), and permitting her child to be used for the production of child pornography, in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 2251(b); and convicting Sacco of buying a child for the purpose of producing child pornography, in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 2251A(b), coercing a child to engage in sexually explicit conduct for the production of child pornography, in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 2251(a), travel in interstate commerce with intent to engage in illicit sexual conduct with a minor, in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 2423(b), and possession of child pornography, in violation of § 2252A(a)(5)(B). O'Connor was sentenced principally to 30 years' imprisonment. Sacco was sentenced principally to imprisonment for life.
On appeal, O'Connor contends, inter alia, that the evidence was insufficient to support her conviction on any count and that the district court deprived her of a fair trial by denying her motions for severance of her trial from that of Sacco. She also challenges certain evidentiary rulings. Sacco contends chiefly that the district court deprived him of a fair trial by denying his attorney's request to withdraw from the case, by admitting in evidence portions of his self-titled autobiography that give an account of his past thoughts and conduct, and by denying his request for a continuance following unexpected testimony from a government witness. Finding no merit in any of defendants' contentions, we affirm the judgments of conviction.
The present prosecution focused on the sexual abuse of O'Connor's daughter--identified in the briefs before us as "S.O."--from 2004 into February 2007. The government's evidence at trial, conducted in May 2008, was presented principally through the testimony of S.O. and numerous other witnesses including social workers, law enforcement agents, and former friends or acquaintances of S.O., O'Connor, or Sacco. Viewed in the light most favorable to the government, the evidence reveals the following.
S.O. testified that she was sexually abused by her mother, by her mother's sex partner, George Lang (or "George" or "Lang"), by Sacco, and by two strangers in encounters arranged by her mother.
O'Connor began abusing S.O. in the bathroom of their home in Deposit, New York, in 2004, when S.O. was 10 years of age. In the guise of helping S.O. wash and dry herself, O'Connor started touching S.O. inappropriately, such as by rubbing her vagina. (See Trial Transcript ("Tr.") 1458-59.) S.O., who by then had been bathing herself for two years, asked her mother to stop; but the abuse escalated; approximately twice a month, O'Connor would lead S.O., naked, from the bathroom to O'Connor's bedroom, where O'Connor, naked, would kiss and touch S.O.'s genitalia and require S.O. to reciprocate. (See id. at 1459-61.) S.O. testified that pleading with her mother to stop was "useless" (id. at 1461) because O'Connor's response was "that she was my mother and I was supposed to do what she said" (id. at 1460). Thus, S.O. ceased to protest. (See id. at 1461.)
In 2004, O'Connor and S.O. were spending substantial amounts of time with George and Renee Lang, a married couple whom S.O. sometimes called "Grandpa" and "Grandma" (id. at 1306). During this period, O'Connor was sometimes late in paying the rent and was threatened with eviction (see id. at 1500-01); Lang would sometimes help O'Connor with the rent (see id. at 1457, 1501).
O'Connor and George Lang communicated frequently online (see id. at 1465), often sending each other pornographic images (see id. at 1237). In 2004, O'Connor and S.O. spent many weekends at the Langs' home in nearby Nineveh, New York; O'Connor and Lang were sex partners, engaging in sexual activities in the Langs' living room after Renee Lang (or "Renee") had gone to sleep and could be heard snoring in the Langs' bedroom. After S.O. walked in on O'Connor and George one night and saw them having intercourse, O'Connor required S.O. to participate in sexual activities with them: George kissed and touched S.O.; O'Connor kissed and touched George; O'Connor kissed and touched S.O. (Tr. 1476-79.)
In the ensuing months, George Lang continued to abuse S.O., sometimes with O'Connor and sometimes individually. George and O'Connor would ply S.O. with liquor before molesting her. One adult would sometimes take photographs of S.O. as she performed sex acts on the other, and George would later show S.O. the photos on his computer. George engaged in oral and manual sex with S.O. but not intercourse. (See id. at 1481-88.)
In late 2004, George Lang was diagnosed with cancer, and his abuse of S.O., although continuing, became less frequent (see id. at 1496). O'Connor and S.O. stopped going to the Langs' home in early 2006 after arguments between O'Connor and Renee or George. (See id. at 1263-65, 1497-98.) In July 2006, Lang succumbed to his cancer. (See id. at 1320.)
In June 2006, a flood forced O'Connor and S.O. out of their home in Deposit, and at the beginning of August they moved into the downstairs apartment of a house at 45 Fair Street in Norwich, New York ("45 Fair"), where their new landlord was Sacco. (See Tr. 1453, 1470, 1502-04.) On the day they moved in, Sacco told them he lived in New Jersey but that since he had to be back in Norwich the next day, he planned to spend the night in his car; O'Connor invited him to sleep in the apartment instead. (See id. at 1507, 1622-23.) During the night, S.O. woke up to find Sacco kissing her; he had removed her clothing and soon was having intercourse with her. Sacco told S.O. to be quiet, and S.O., terrified, obeyed. Sacco eventually stopped, dressed, and left the room, leaving S.O. crying into her pillow. S.O. did not tell O'Connor. (See id. at 1507-09.)
Little more than a week later, S.O. ingested and injected herself with some of her mother's medicines in an attempt to commit suicide. She was hospitalized, and the Chenango County Department of Social Services ("DSS") was notified. (See Tr. 804-05, 1510-11.) Later in August 2006, DSS learned that O'Connor herself had gone to the hospital seeking treatment for kidney stones and had left S.O. at home unsupervised. A DSS caseworker, finding S.O. home alone, with nothing in the kitchen except rotten food and frozen items that S.O. did not know how to prepare, determined that S.O. could not care for herself and arranged to have her transferred to the temporary custody of Renee Lang. (See id. at 815-18.) During the period in which she was living with Renee, S.O. told social workers that Sacco "trie[d] to hug her a lot" and that he "creep[ed] her out" and "scare[d] her." (Id. at 827; see id. at 1521.)
O'Connor, once out of the hospital, showered S.O. with gifts and promised that their relationship would improve; and both of them wanted to resume living together. (See id. at 821-22, 1516-20.) In October, the Family Court held a hearing at which DSS recommended that S.O. instead be placed in foster care. The court rejected that recommendation and returned S.O. to O'Connor's custody. However, in light of DSS's report of S.O.'s prior statements about Sacco's repeated "creep[y]" hugging, the court ordered O'Connor not to allow S.O. to have unsupervised contact with Sacco. (Id. at 826-27.)
O'Connor ignored that condition, and a few weeks later, Sacco sexually abused S.O. again. In late October, the upstairs apartment at 45 Fair had become vacant. Sacco soon arrived at 45 Fair and spoke with O'Connor at the door. After a conversation that S.O. could not hear, O'Connor came in and got S.O., and Sacco instructed S.O. to join him upstairs. (See id. at 1522-23, 1527.)
Upstairs, Sacco had intercourse with S.O. He then used a camera with a zoom lens to take pornographic photographs of her. (See id. at 1523-25.) When she initially refused to pose as instructed, Sacco hit her. (See id. at 1525.) When Sacco finally allowed S.O. to leave, she ran downstairs to her mother, who was in the kitchen. Crying, S.O. told O'Connor, "[M]om, Dean is doing stuff that's hurting me." (Id. at 1526.) O'Connor responded, "[I]t's better than being homeless," and left the room. (Id.)
The next time Sacco abused S.O., on Thanksgiving in 2006, he was joined by O'Connor. After serving S.O. alcohol at dinner (see Tr. 1531), Sacco and O'Connor took S.O. into her bedroom, where, first, Sacco had intercourse with S.O. Then Sacco had intercourse with O'Connor. S.O. was then ordered to perform oral sex on Sacco and to kiss her mother. (See id. at 1528.) Sacco had again brought a camera, which appeared to S.O. to be the same one he had used to take pornographic pictures of S.O. previously; and he and O'Connor took turns taking pictures of each other as they abused S.O. (See id. at 1529.) At one point, after O'Connor and Sacco had ignored S.O.'s pleas to stop, S.O. threatened to tell someone about the abuse. Sacco responded, "[I]f you tell[,] then I'll stab you and rape you as you die." (Id. at 1530.) S.O. believed him. (See id.)
Sacco had intercourse with S.O. twice in December 2006 in the upstairs apartment, including on S.O.'s thirteenth birthday (see Tr. 1540, 1546). On the first occasion, O'Connor remained downstairs after she had spoken with Sacco at the door and ordered S.O. to join Sacco upstairs. (See id. at 1541-42.) Sacco's abuse of S.O. on that occasion was interrupted by O'Connor's knock at the upstairs door to announce--through the door, without opening it--that the family of one of S.O.'s schoolmates had arrived to see S.O. (See id. at 1543.) On the second occasion, O'Connor joined Sacco and S.O. in the upstairs apartment and participated in the abuse of S.O. (See id. at 1547-48.)
Sacco last abused S.O. in February 2007. In the meantime, he and O'Connor had begun to have frequent arguments about money, with Sacco telling O'Connor that she owed him rent and needed to pay him soon. (See id. at 1555-56; see also id. at 2009-11 (testimony of a former Sacco employer (called as a witness by Sacco) that Sacco complained to him that the downstairs tenant at 45 Fair was not paying rent on time).)
There was no evidence that the government found any of the photographs that S.O. testified were taken, and no such photographs were presented at trial. However, the government presented evidence that, in a search of a locked storage unit containing property belonging to Sacco, law enforcement agents had found a used condom. (See id. at 309-10, 327-28.) Forensic analysis revealed that the outside of the condom bore S.O.'s DNA. (See id. at 334-35, 1940-41.)
The government also introduced evidence of Sacco's prior sexual abuse of other young girls, calling as witnesses one of those victims, as well as a police detective who had investigated those events and to whom Sacco had admitted being attracted to girls in the age range of 8-11 years. (See Tr. 438-67, 677-78, 686.) And, as discussed in Part II.B.1. below, the government introduced published writings by Sacco in which he had described his pedophilic sexual appetites.
In December 2006, O'Connor and S.O. rode a bus to Binghamton, New York, and checked into a Best Western hotel in nearby Johnson City. That night, a man S.O. had never seen arrived at their hotel room, and O'Connor told S.O. to "do what the man wants." The man proceeded to undress and to have intercourse and oral sex with S.O. O'Connor sat nearby, speaking only to remind S.O. to follow the man's orders. (See Tr. 1533-37.) S.O. testified that when they arrived in Binghamton O'Connor had "some money but not a lot," and that when the man left the hotel room O'Connor "had a lot more money." (Id. at 1539.)
In January 2007, O'Connor again took S.O. to the Best Western, where they went into a room in which a man S.O. had never seen was waiting. O'Connor told S.O. to follow the man's orders, and the man had intercourse with S.O. and forced her to perform oral sex. Meanwhile, O'Connor sat in the room eating donuts and watching television. (See id. at 1550-53.) S.O. went to the bathroom after the man had finished with her; when she emerged, the man was gone and there was money on the table. (See id. at 1554.)
In late February 2007, O'Connor, after dining with S.O. at a Pizza Hut, was arrested when she attempted to leave without paying the bill. (See Tr. 892-93, 1628-29.) That arrest, along with O'Connor's violation of the Family Court's order not to allow S.O. to have unsupervised visits with Sacco, led to O'Connor's incarceration; at the urging of DSS caseworker Elizabeth Chesebro, O'Connor agreed to let S.O. be placed in foster care. (See id. at 896, 926.) Shortly thereafter, S.O. began to disclose the abuse she had suffered from Sacco--but did not disclose the abuse by her mother--telling a teacher, then Chesebro, and then Patrick Blenis, a Norwich police detective, that Sacco had raped her. (See id. at 1566-68.) On March 14 and 15, with Blenis, his supervisor, and Chesebro at her side, S.O. made controlled telephone calls to Sacco. (See id. at 138-42, 145-52.) Days later, Sacco was arrested on state-law charges, including rape. (See id. at 152-53.) In the meantime, on March 18, as discussed in Part II.B.2. below, Sacco told his friend and landlord, Gerardo DiFiori, about a call he received from S.O., which Sacco had sensed was being monitored. Sacco said he was "in trouble" for doing "something wrong," and "if they get me, they're going to give me 30 years." (Id. at 527.) Pressed for details, Sacco said, "I had sex with a minor," "a prostitute"; "she's 12." (Id. at 528-29.)
In September 2007, fearing that S.O. was suicidal, Chesebro had her admitted to a psychiatric health center. (See Tr. 933-34.) During a conversation at that center the following month, S.O. disclosed to Chesebro that when she was abused by Sacco, O'Connor had acquiesced and had on one occasion taken photographs. (See id. at 937-46.) That disclosure prompted an investigation by state and federal officials, which ultimately led to the arrests of O'Connor and Sacco on federal charges. (See id. at 175-84, 192-94, 947.) In December 2007, S.O. disclosed O'Connor's incestuous conduct, as well as O'Connor's forcing her to have oral and manual sex with George Lang, and intercourse and oral sex with the strangers at the Best Western. (See id. at 959-61.)
In the seven-count indictment initiating the present prosecution, O'Connor and Sacco were charged with selling and buying, respectively, a child for the purpose of producing child pornography, in violation of 18 U.S.C. §§ 2251A(a) and (b), respectively, and 18 U.S.C. § 2 (Counts 1 and 2); and each was charged with sex trafficking of a child, in violation of 18 U.S.C. §§ 1591(a) and (b) and 2 (Count 3), with coercing a minor to engage in sexually explicit conduct for the purpose of producing child pornography, in violation of 18 U.S.C. §§ 2251(a) and 2 (Count 4), and with possession of child pornography, in violation of 18 U.S.C. §§ 2252A(a)(5)(B) and 2 (Count 7). In addition, O'Connor was charged, as the child's parent and custodian, with knowingly permitting her child to engage in sexually explicit conduct for the purpose of producing child pornography, in violation of 18 U.S.C. §§ 2251(b) and 2 (Count 5); and Sacco was charged with travel in interstate commerce for the purpose of engaging in illicit sexual conduct with a minor under the age of 18, in violation of 18 U.S.C. §§ 2423(b) and 2 (Count 6).
As discussed in Part II.D. below, O'Connor, prior to trial, moved for severance of her trial from that of Sacco, arguing principally that her defense and that of Sacco were irreconcilable and that the overwhelming evidence against Sacco would likely result in spillover prejudicial to O'Connor. The district court denied severance.
As discussed in Part II.A. below, two business days before the scheduled start of trial, Sacco's attorney, in a motion filed under seal, requested permission to withdraw as his counsel. The court denied that motion as well.
After an 18-day trial, the jury found O'Connor guilty on three of the five counts against her: Count 1 (selling a child for the purpose of producing child pornography), Count 3 (sex trafficking of a child), and Count 5 (permitting her child to be used by Sacco in the production of child pornography). She was found not guilty on Count 4, which charged her with coercing S.O. to engage in sexual conduct for the purpose of producing child pornography, and Count 7, which charged her with possession of child pornography. Sacco was convicted on all five of the counts against him. O'Connor was sentenced principally to 30 years' imprisonment, to be followed by a life term of supervised release. Sacco was sentenced principally to prison for life.
On appeal, Sacco contends principally that the district court deprived him of a fair trial by denying his attorney's request to withdraw from the case, by admitting in evidence excerpts from his self-titled autobiography, and by refusing to grant a continuance after DiFiori's testimony as to Sacco's admission, which had been unanticipated. O'Connor contends principally that the evidence was insufficient to convict her on any count and that she was deprived of a fair trial by being tried jointly with Sacco. We find no merit in any of defendants' contentions.
Kelly E. Fischer Esq. had been appointed by the court to represent Sacco in this case in February 2008. On March 20, the court scheduled the trial to begin on Monday, April 28, 2008. On Thursday April 24, Fischer asked the court to allow him to withdraw from the case. His motion, accompanied by his affirmation, was filed ex parte and under seal.
In a hearing in open court on April 25, Fischer directed the court's attention to the contents of his sealed affirmation and stated generally that the intensity of his personal feelings with regard to the case against Sacco might affect his ability to effectively represent his client. Citing an Ethical Consideration ("EC") set out in the New York Lawyer's Code of Professional Responsibility (the "Code"), reprinted in N.Y. Jud. Law App. (McKinney 2008), which was applicable at the time of Sacco's trial (but which has since been superseded by N.Y. Rules of Professional Conduct), Fischer stated as follows:
Basically, your Honor, I would cite the ethical consideration under Professional Code of Professional Responsibility EC2-30 which basically says that if the intensity of an attorney's personal feelings might affect--may affect that attorney's ability to effectively represent his client, then the attorney should seek to withdraw. Based on the paperwork that I submitted which basically sets out my position personally, that raises a real concern for me in this case.
THE COURT: All right.
MR. FISCHER: Particularly with respect to the primary witness, almost the exclusive witness against Mr. Sacco, [S.O.].
(Transcript of Proceedings as to Dean Sacco, April 25, 2008 ("Sacco April 25 Tr."), at 3.)
Fischer's affirmation--which is hereby deemed unsealed to the extent that it is described in this opinion (and we leave it to the district court to decide whether the motion should be unsealed in toto)--specified that in preparation for trial, Fischer had performed hours of research, had spoken with a variety of investigators and other sources, and had reviewed every page of the approximately 100 pounds of discovery materials that had been supplied by the government or obtained from other sources. However, Fischer stated that in the past two weeks he had received materials from the government that included the evidence as to Sacco's possession of the used condom bearing S.O.'s DNA. Fischer stated that until that time, he had been confident that he could vigorously defend Sacco's position at trial; but that "single bit of evidence" caused an immediate, involuntary, and substantial shift in his "moral and technical perspective on this case." Stating that his past successes in defending criminal cases were largely due to "the strength of my moral conviction[] and my ability to convey that moral conviction" to juries, Fischer stated that "while I could probably go through the motions to defend Mr. Sacco, my conviction would not be behind that representation." Fischer's affirmation did not cite any provision of the Code that imposed an Ethical Consideration or a Disciplinary Rule ("DR").
The government opposed Fischer's motion to withdraw. It noted that a substitution of counsel would substantially delay the start of trial. It stated that it had been "preparing [S.O.] to testify now for the last month, in addition to preparing all the other witnesses," and S.O. was "ready to walk into this Court and testify about everything that happened to her." (Sacco April 25 Tr. at 6.)
O'Connor's attorney (who had stated in her severance motion that the defense positions of O'Connor and Sacco were irreconcilable) supported Fischer's motion to withdraw on the ground that it would hurt O'Connor's case "if [Fischer] cannot effectively represent Mr. Sacco" (id. at 8). Expressing her doubt as to Fischer's ability to represent Sacco zealously, she stated that "it's only fair for both defendants that they have attorneys that can be zealous advocates on their behalf and I think that's what the law requires, your Honor." (Id. at 9.) As to the latter point, the court stated, "I don't think the law requires zealousness on [the] part of the attorney. I think it requires adequacy on [the] part of the attorney. I know Mr. Fischer is more than adequate." (Id.)
Sacco himself took no firm position on Fischer's motion to withdraw. He expressed both admiration for and frustration with Fischer, saying he had "found Mr. Fischer to be sincere, genuine, intelligent, articulate," but had been "disappointed that our communication has not been continual in the last eight weeks." (Id. at 3.) However, Sacco also said he had an
interest[] in going to trial as quickly as possible I want to get it behind me but I have no indication whatsoever that Mr. Fischer is actually ready at this time. I haven't discussed anything. I haven't seen any motions that he's put forth. I haven't received any replies from any of the letters that I sent him in the last eight weeks. When I read in the newspaper that a trial was taking place on the 28 of April, I was--it couldn't be true. I hadn't spoken to Mr. Fischer so I think there is a little bit of an issue that he may not be ready, although I'd like to go, you know.
(Id. at 17.)
In a written order entered later on April 25, the court denied Fischer's motion to withdraw:
Based upon the information contained in Defense counsel's ex parte motion, and the information obtained at the hearing held on April 25, 2008, the Court finds that there are insufficient grounds to warrant granting the application to withdraw. No actual conflict has been identified and the Court is confident, and expects, that Attorney Fischer will continue to provide Defendant Sacco with appropriate representation. Moreover, aside from some concerns about Attorney Fischer's preparation for trial, Defendant Sacco articulated that he was satisfied with Attorney Fischer's abilities. Without more, the information before the Court is insufficient to demonstrate an actual conflict warranting withdrawal. The motion to withdraw is, therefore, DENIED.
Order dated April 25, 2008 ("Order Denying Withdrawal"), at 1 (emphases added). The court gave the parties an extra week to prepare for trial, scheduling jury selection for May 5, 2008. (See id. at 1-2.)
On April 30, O'Connor, who previously had moved unsuccessfully for severance of her trial from that of Sacco (see Part II.D. below), renewed her motion for severance, stating that Fischer had an "internal conflict with representing his client," which would cause him to provide ineffective assistance to Sacco at trial (O'Connor Memorandum of Law dated April 30, 2008, at 2) and thereby prejudice O'Connor's case (see id. at 5). O'Connor also argued, based on statements by Sacco at the April 25 hearing, that "Fischer's assistance thus far [has] been objectively unreasonable"; that Fischer "ha[d], by his own admission, stated that his assistance w[ould] continue to be inadequate"; and that "Fischer ha[d] expressed an unequivocal unwillingness and inability to conduct a cross-examination of the alleged victim." (Id.) O'Connor stated that "it would appear that Mr. Fischer has done almost nothing to prepare for trial," that he was guilty of an "utter failure to prepare," and that it was "highly unlikely" that Fischer would be prepared for trial on May 5. (Id.)
Fischer, in response to O'Connor's motion, did not take a position on severance but disputed all of her characterizations of his preparedness and his willingness to represent Sacco properly. With respect to preparedness, Fischer stated that except for three specified tasks, "I believe we are prepared to go to trial in this matter." (Letter from Kelly E. Fischer to Judge McAvoy dated April 30, 2008 ("April 30 Letter"), at 2.) With respect to O'Connor's ethics challenge, Fischer stated:
I wish to make it clear that, while my personal, moral and religious beliefs do create some issues for me in the defense of this action, I do not now believe, and do not recall ever[] expressing, in words or substance, "an unequivocal unwillingness and inability to conduct a cross-examination of the alleged victim."
(Id. at 1.)
On this appeal, Sacco, represented by new counsel, contends that the district court's denial of Fischer's motion to withdraw "was necessarily colored by its view, expressed during the conference on the motion to withdraw, that the law does not require an attorney to act as a zealous advocate for his client," and was thus improper. (Sacco brief on appeal at 46.) He argues that
Code of Professional Responsibility Canon 7, entitled "A Lawyer Should Represent a Client Zealously Within the Bounds of the Law," contains Ethical Consideration 7-1, stating "the duty of a lawyer, both to the client and to the legal system, is to represent the client zealously within the bounds of the law, which includes Disciplinary Rules and enforceable professional regulations," id., and Disciplinary Rule 7-101, expressly governing "Representing a Client Zealously." Id.
(Sacco brief on appeal at 47.) We see no basis for reversal--either in the arguments made by Fischer in the district court or in the arguments made by Sacco's new attorney on this appeal.
A ruling denying a motion to withdraw is reviewable for abuse of discretion. See United States v. Oberoi, 331 F.3d 44, 47 (2d Cir. 2003).
We must grant considerable deference to the district court's decision especially when the prosecution of the suit is likely to be disrupted by the withdrawal of counsel. However, if forcing an attorney to continue representation will cause a violation of the Code of Professional Responsibility and possibly subject the attorney to sanctions, it will be an abuse of discretion not to grant the motion to withdraw.
Id. at 47-48 (internal quotation marks and citation omitted).
In the present case, Fischer did not argue, either in his sealed affirmation or in his statements in open court, that there was any Disciplinary Rule that would be violated if he continued to represent Sacco or that his continued representation of Sacco might possibly expose him to sanctions. As noted above, Fischer cited at the hearing former EC 2-30, which he characterized as dealing with whether an "attorney should seek to withdraw" because of the "intensity of [his] personal feelings." (Sacco April 25 Tr. at 3.) That statement actually conflated EC 2-30, which concerned whether an attorney should accept an appointment, with former EC 2-29, which dealt with whether an attorney, having accepted an appointment, should seek to withdraw. The provision most relevant to Fischer's motion to withdraw was EC 2-29, which provided in pertinent part as follows:
When a lawyer is appointed by a court to undertake representation of a person unable to obtain counsel, whether for financial or other reasons, the lawyer should not seek to be excused from undertaking the representation except for compelling reasons. Compelling reasons do not include such factors as the repugnance of the subject matter of the proceeding [or] the belief of the lawyer that the defendant in a criminal proceeding is guilty.
Code, EC 2-29 (emphases added). See also Fiumara v. United States, 727 F.2d 209, 212 (2d Cir.) ("A trial counsel worthy of the name should be capable of subordinating his personal predilections to his professional duty." (internal quotation marks omitted)), cert. denied, 466 U.S. 951 (1984).
Fischer's affirmation made clear that he had accepted appointment by the court to defend Sacco knowing the nature of the charges. He stated that he had proceeded industriously to prepare for trial, conducting interviews, doing research, and examining "100 pounds" of documents. The affirmation quite plainly stated that Fischer wished to withdraw because of his abhorrence of a "single bit" of evidence in the case. Ethical Consideration 2-29 provided that he should not seek to withdraw except for compelling reasons; and if, as EC 2-29 specified, repugnance of the subject matter of the case does not fit into that category, Fischer's revulsion at a single item of evidence in the case surely did not constitute a compelling reason. Finally, Fischer's affirmation's reference to the change in his "technical perspective" (emphasis added) suggests that the condom evidence caused Fischer to believe that his client was guilty. Under the express terms of EC 2-29, such a belief is not a sufficient reason to withdraw.
We thus see no abuse of discretion in the district court's denial of Fischer's motion based on the presentations to the district court. Implicit in the court's statement that it "expect[ed] that Attorney Fischer w[ould] continue to provide Defendant Sacco with appropriate representation," Order Denying Withdrawal at 1 (emphasis added), was the expectation that Fischer would represent Sacco as vigorously as required by the Code. That expectation was entirely reasonable in light of the absence of any suggestion by Fischer in his motion that he would be unable to comply with any of the Code's Disciplinary Rules or any suggestion that his continued representation of Sacco might possibly expose him to a sanction. Further, Fischer made clear in the motion itself that he had done most of the work necessary to prepare for trial. And he indicated in his April 30 Letter that he was ready, able, and willing to proceed to trial and to cross-examine S.O. on Sacco's behalf.
Nor does Sacco's brief on appeal provide any basis for concluding that the district court should have granted Fischer's motion. Although it cites the title of DR 7-101 ("Representing a Client Zealously"), it does not quote or describe any provision of that Rule and does not suggest that Fischer failed to comply with any of the Rule's commands. Further, while Sacco's brief quotes EC 7-1's provision that an attorney should "represent the client zealously," it provides no basis for a conclusion that Fischer did not represent Sacco zealously. His objections to Fischer's performance are to strategic decisions such as the timing of Fischer's objection to the admission of Sacco's self-styled autobiography and the timing of a request for a bench trial. The record makes plain that Fischer competently cross-examined S.O. at trial, and Sacco's brief on appeal does not contend to the contrary.
In sum, the record provides no basis for a conclusion that the denial of Fischer's motion to withdraw deprived Sacco of a fair trial.
At trial, the government offered in evidence eight passages from Sacco's autobiography, in which Sacco had written of his sexual attraction to children and described, inter alia, his sexual acts against "[his] little sister" and her girlfriends while they were asleep. The district court admitted four of the proffered excerpts in full, excluded three, and admitted only part of another. Sacco does not challenge the admissibility of the excerpts under Fed. R. Evid. 413 (authorizing the admission, in a criminal case in which the defendant is accused of sexual assault, of relevant evidence of the defendant's commission of another offense or offenses of sexual assault), and Fed. R. Evid. 414 (authorizing the admission, in a criminal case in which the defendant is accused of child molestation, of relevant evidence of the defendant's commission of another offense or offenses of child molestation). Rather, Sacco contends that all of the passages should have been excluded pursuant to Fed. R. Evid. 403 on the ground that their potential for unfair prejudice substantially outweighed their probative value. Sacco, age 48 when he abused S.O., argues that the autobiography, written shortly before 2000, at most described his thoughts and conduct as a teenager, and thus that they lacked probative value because they were too remote in time. We reject this conclusion.
The trial court's decision not to exclude evidence pursuant to Rule 403 is reviewed only for abuse of discretion. See, e.g., United States v. Larson, 112 F.3d 600, 604-05 (2d Cir. 1997) ("Larson"). Courts confronted with remote-in-time evidence offered under Rule 413 or Rule 414 should conduct a fact-specific and case-specific analysis:
Exclusion of proof of other acts that are too remote in time caters principally to the dual concerns for relevance and reliability. The evaluation of the proffered evidence in light of these concerns must be made on a case-by-case basis to determine whether the significance of the prior acts has become too attenuated and whether the memories of the witnesses has likely become too frail. Neither Rule 403 nor any analogous Rule provides any bright-line rule as to how old is too old.
Larson, 112 F.3d at 605. In Larson, we found no abuse of discretion in the admission of testimony about acts that occurred 16 to 20 years before the trial where "[t]he similarity of the events clearly demonstrated the testimony's relevance." Id.; see also United States v. Davis, 624 F.3d 508, 512 (2d Cir. 2010) (no abuse of discretion in the admission of testimony about conduct occurring some 19 years earlier).
In the present case, the district court plainly conducted a Rule 403 balancing analysis; it excluded some of the proffered excerpts on the ground that they were cumulative or that their probative value was outweighed by the potential for unfair prejudice. (See Tr. 696.) The excerpts that were admitted plainly had high probative value that outweighed any potential for unfair prejudice; they included descriptions of Sacco entering rooms in which young girls were asleep and sexually molesting them--conduct that partially paralleled S.O.'s description of Sacco's first molestation of her. And an excerpt describing an interest in child pornography was consistent with S.O.'s testimony that Sacco forced her to pose for pornographic photographs.
Further, the present case does not involve the usual concerns as to memory or reliability; the passages had been written by Sacco himself. And although Sacco suggests that his predilections as a teenager should be discounted, pointing out that the acts described in his autobiography occurred more than 30 years before his conduct with S.O. and thus were more remote in time than the conduct at issue in the above cases, that argument rings hollow in light of the evident relish with which he wrote the passages just seven years before his molestation of S.O. We see no abuse of discretion in the admission of this evidence.
As indicated in Part I.B. above, Sacco's friend DiFiori testified at trial that Sacco had admitted having sex with a 12-year-old girl. Although DiFiori had been included in the government's list of planned witnesses, this aspect of his testimony had not been anticipated, as DiFiori did not inform the government of Sacco's statement until Friday May 9, 2008, the day DiFiori began his testimony. In light of the surprise testimony, Sacco asked the court to grant a mistrial, or, in the alternative, to strike that testimony from the record or adjourn the trial for at least a week in order to allow Sacco to conduct further investigation into DiFiori's background. O'Connor's attorney preferred not to have a mistrial and requested a curative instruction or a continuance of at least two weeks.
The trial court, accepting the representation of the Assistant United States Attorney that the government had had no prior indication that DiFiori would give this testimony, denied the defense motions. However, "want[ing] to make sure the witness is adequately cross-examined by everybody" (Tr. 548), the court did not require defendants to proceed with their cross-examinations and instead adjourned the trial early that Friday afternoon in order to give them the remainder of that day plus the weekend to prepare to cross-examine DiFiori as to Sacco's statement. On appeal, Sacco contends principally that the denial of a week-long continuance violated his due process and confrontation rights. We are unpersuaded.
The decision whether to grant a continuance is a matter "traditionally within the discretion of the trial judge." Ungar v. Sarafite, 376 U.S. 575, 589 (1964). We review an order denying a continuance for abuse of discretion, and we will find no such abuse unless the denial was an "arbitrary action that substantially impaired the defense." United States v. Beverly, 5 F.3d 633, 641 (2d Cir. 1993). The burden of showing such an impairment is on the party complaining of the lack of a sufficient continuance. See, e.g., United States v. Tin Yat Chin, 476 F.3d 144, 146 (2d Cir. 2007) (new trial not required where defendant was "unable to specify with any particularity how he was prejudiced by not receiving a longer [than one-day] continuance").
We see no arbitrary action or substantial impairment here. The surprise testimony was quite succinct and entirely straightforward. Sacco offers no explanation as to why the extra time on that Friday plus the weekend recess were not sufficient to permit him to prepare an adequate cross-examination, except to state that he needed more time to investigate DiFiori's background. But the fact that DiFiori was to testify at trial had been known to the defendants in advance; presumably they would have conducted at least some investigation into his background in preparation for his expected testimony. And although Sacco contends that further investigation was warranted in light of the unexpectedly damaging testimony, he provides no inkling of what helpful information might have been found.
We also reject Sacco's contention that "DiFiori's testimony was essential to proving . . . that [Sacco] had engaged in sexual intercourse with S.O. when she was twelve years old" (Sacco brief on appeal at 61). Although a direct admission is virtually always damaging, we have no doubt that Sacco would have been convicted without his statement to DiFiori, given S.O.'s explicit testimony and the used condom bearing S.O.'s DNA, which was found among Sacco's stored possessions.
At trial, defendants cross-examined S.O. at length, emphasizing that when Sacco first began abusing her, S.O. did not tell her mother; that when S.O. first told Chesebro and Detective Blenis about Sacco, she did not tell them she had also been abused by her mother or by George Lang; and that some details of her testimony--such as the months in which various incidents occurred--differed from statements she had previously given to DSS caseworkers or to Blenis. O'Connor challenges the sufficiency of the evidence to convict her on any count, arguing generally that S.O.'s testimony was inconsistent, contradictory, and not credible, and that the jury's verdict was against the weight of the evidence. She also contends, inter alia, that particular elements of the three offenses of which she was found guilty were not supported by sufficient evidence. We find no merit in her sufficiency challenges.
O'Connor's general contentions are contrary to well established principles governing review of challenges to the sufficiency of the evidence. In considering such a challenge, we must credit every reasonable inference that the jury could have drawn in the government's favor, see, e.g., United States v. Carson, 702 F.2d 351, 361 (2d Cir.) ("Carson"), cert. denied, 462 U.S. 1108 (1983), and we must affirm the conviction so long as, from the inferences reasonably drawn, the jury might fairly have concluded guilt beyond a reasonable doubt, see, e.g., United States v. Buck, 804 F.2d 239, 242 (2d Cir. 1986); United States v. Taylor, 464 F.2d 240, 244-45 (2d Cir. 1972). The weight of the evidence is a matter for argument to the jury, not a ground for reversal on appeal. See, e.g., United States v. Roman, 870 F.2d 65, 71 (2d Cir.), cert. denied, 490 U.S. 1109 (1989).
"Where there are conflicts in the testimony, we must defer to the jury's resolution of the weight of the evidence and the credibility of the witnesses." United States v. Persico, No. 08-5266, 2011 WL 1661420, at *16 (2d Cir. May 3, 2011); see, e.g., United States v. Morrison, 153 F.3d 34, 49 (2d Cir. 1998). "[W]hen testimonial inconsistencies are revealed on cross-examination, the jury [i]s entitled to weigh the evidence and decide the credibility issues for itself." United States v. Josephberg, 562 F.3d 478, 494 (2d Cir.) (internal quotation marks omitted), cert. denied, 130 S. Ct. 397 (2009). "It is the province of the jury and not of the court" to determine whether a witness who may have been "inaccurate, contradictory and even untruthful in some respects" was nonetheless "entirely credible in the essentials of his testimony." United States v. Tropiano, 418 F.2d 1069, 1074 (2d Cir. 1969), cert. denied, 397 U.S. 1021 (1970); see, e.g., United States v. Cote, 544 F.3d 88, 99 (2d Cir. 2008) ("court must give full play to the right of the jury to determine credibility").
In the present case, S.O. testified that she did not mention O'Connor in her early disclosures with regard to Sacco because she feared that, upon her return to O'Connor's custody, there would be repercussions if she had disclosed the abuse by O'Connor. She also explained that for the same reason, in her early disclosures, she had not mentioned being abused by George Lang because to do so would implicate her mother. She testified, "It's not that I wasn't truthful. I was scared to say everything." (Tr. 1636 (emphasis added).) It was well within the province of the jury to consider all of the evidence, and to conclude that S.O.'s early disclosures were merely incomplete and that her trial testimony was truthful. In light of the above principles, O'Connor's overarching contentions that her convictions should be reversed on the grounds that S.O.'s testimony was not credible or was contrary to testimony of other witnesses, or that the guilty verdicts against her were against the weight of the evidence, provide no basis for reversal.
Nor, as discussed below, is there merit in O'Connor's more particularized sufficiency challenges focusing on specific counts.
With respect to Count 1, O'Connor contends that the government failed to prove that she acted with the knowledge or intent required to support a conviction for selling a child for the purpose of producing child pornography, in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 2251A(a). That section, as it read in 2006-2007,