Concept
The Expectation Interest
Expectation interest (including direct, incidental, and consequential damages)
Expectation Damages
The Expectation Interest
A broken promise raises one question before any other: what is the injured party owed? Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 344 answers that judicial remedies protect one or more of three interests of the promisee: expectation, reliance, and restitution.1 The expectation interest is the promisee's interest in having the benefit of her bargain by being put in as good a position as she would have occupied had the contract been performed.2 The measure compares two worlds, the one in which the promise was broken and the one in which it was kept, and the remedy is the money that closes the gap. Because the comparison looks forward to what performance would have delivered, it can include a profit the promisee had yet to earn. The rest of this chapter prices that gap, first through the common-law formula and then through the buyer and seller remedies of UCC Article 2.
The law measures by performance, and not by what the promisee spent, because parties deciding whether to commit need assurance that neither can receive the other's performance while withholding its own. Without that assurance they might hesitate to deal on mere promises and could not plan with confidence. Contract law supplies it by requiring each party to meet the other's expectations, through willing performance or else through the money equivalent.3 A second justification concerns forgone opportunities. Entering nearly any contract means passing up other chances to earn money, and that kind of reliance defies measurement, which may justify a categorical rule granting the value of the expectancy as the most effective way to compensate for such losses.4
The measure also stops where performance would have stopped. The injured party recovers the monetary equivalent of what she expected, and no more; she cannot recover punitive damages, because contract law compensates the injured party and does not punish the breacher. In theory she also gets no less, though the limits on recovery that later sections take up mean that injured parties rarely receive the full equivalent in fact.5
Courts customarily deliver that equivalent as money damages.6 The Restatement's list of principal remedies opens with a judgment awarding a sum of money due under the contract or as damages7 and includes specific performance, an order requiring performance of the contract or enjoining its nonperformance.8 The list is neither exhaustive nor exclusive. Replevin, reformation, and cancellation supplement it, and a court may in one action both order specific performance and award damages for nonperformance.9
Contract law compensates economic injury only. Unlike tort law, it ordinarily takes no account of emotional or other noneconomic harm, so a party usually incurs no legal sanction for a breach that causes no economic loss, subject to limited exceptions.10
Reliance and restitution start from different reference points. The reliance interest is the promisee's interest in being reimbursed for loss caused by reliance on the contract, by being put in as good a position as she would have occupied had the contract not been made.11 The restitution interest is her interest in having restored to her any benefit she conferred on the other party.12 Expectation looks forward to the performed contract, reliance looks back to the unmade one, and restitution looks at what the other side received. A television that never arrives shows all three: a deposit the seller still holds is a benefit conferred, money spent preparing to receive the set is money spent in reliance, and the extra cost of an equivalent set elsewhere is the expectation loss.
Reliance is the backward-looking measure. It reimburses what the injured party actually spent in preparing for or performing the contract and so gets her back up to zero.13 It proves most useful when the plaintiff cannot prove the profit she would have earned. She then recovers her expenses, a profit of zero but no loss, and lands as close to her expectation as the evidence allows; the defendant can answer by proving that she would have incurred losses.14 The measure also appeals to a party who struck a bad bargain and so had a negative expectation.15
Two surgery cases show how far the choice of measure can move an award. In Hawkins v. McGee, a surgeon promised a perfect hand and left a worse one, and the court measured damages by the difference between the value of the hand as promised and its value as left, an expectation award. In Sullivan v. O'Connor, a self-styled professional entertainer sued a plastic surgeon who had undertaken to shorten her nose. Two operations were expected, the second disappointed, and a third left the nose concave, bulbous, flattened, and asymmetrical.16 Because of the posture of the appeal, the Massachusetts court did not rule finally on the measure, but it appeared to view reliance as the best one. It approved an instruction allowing her to recover the $622 she paid in fees, plus the loss caused by her worsened appearance, plus the pain and suffering of the third operation.17 The logic of that measure would reach the pain of the first two operations as well, since without a contract there would have been no surgery.18 The contrast shows the stakes: expectation prices the world in which the surgery succeeds, and reliance prices the world in which the patient never signed on.
Three features give the expectation measure its shape. It is objective: compensation rests on objective evidence of loss, and the expectations that count are those a reasonable person in the promisee's position would have held, given the parties' language and the surrounding circumstances.19 It is net: performance meant a promise on both sides, so the protected expectation is the value of what the promisor owed less the cost of what the promisee owed in return.20 And it depends on the risk the promisor undertook. A driller who guaranteed only against a higher price for labor owes the cost of getting the well dug by another driller, while one who guaranteed water may owe for cattle lost when none appeared.21 Parties may also reshape the remedy: in most jurisdictions they can limit damages by agreement or send disputes to arbitration, where the arbitrator may award remedies unlike the traditional judicial ones.22