Concept
What Counts as Acceptance
Acceptance and notice of breach
Acceptance, Notice, and Burden
What Counts as Acceptance
Section 2-606 recognizes three routes to acceptance, and a buyer can take any of them without meaning to. A buyer accepts by signifying to the seller, after a reasonable opportunity to inspect, that the goods conform or that the buyer will take or retain them despite their nonconformity.1 A buyer accepts by failing to make an effective rejection, although that acceptance waits until the buyer has had a reasonable opportunity to inspect.2 And a buyer accepts by doing any act inconsistent with the seller's ownership, unless the act is wrongful as against the seller, in which case it is an acceptance only if the seller ratifies it.3 Courts apply the same three routes.4
Acceptance matters because it fixes the rules that govern the buyer from then on. The buyer's baseline duty is to accept and pay for goods in accordance with the contract,5 and a buyer who holds nonconforming goods escapes that duty by rejection only if the rejection comes within a reasonable time after delivery or tender and the seller is seasonably notified.6 Acceptance ends that option.7 The buyer must then pay at the contract rate,8 must notify the seller of any breach within a reasonable time or be barred from any remedy,9 and must establish the breach.10 Sessa v. Riegle shows how these consequences cascade. The buyer there argued that telephone calls made after the horse was shipped amounted to an effective rejection. The court answered that acceptance precludes rejection of the goods accepted,11 and because the buyer could not make an effective rejection, the burden of proving breach of warranty rested on him.12
The law assigns acceptance from what the buyer says, fails to say, or does, so a buyer who never meant to accept can still be held to have accepted. The reasonable opportunity to inspect, which conditions the first two routes, keeps a buyer from being bound before a fair look at what arrived. The subsections below take the three routes in turn, then the rule for partial acceptance, and finally the line between a rejection that fails and one that is merely wrongful.
Acceptance by Signifying
Acceptance by signifying has two elements in a fixed order: a reasonable opportunity to inspect, then a signal to the seller that the goods conform or that the buyer will take or retain them despite their nonconformity.13 Neither element suffices alone. A buyer who inspects and says nothing has signified nothing under this route, and a buyer who announces satisfaction before looking has not met the opening condition.
Each element serves a purpose. The signal protects the seller, who may stop trying to cure or replace the goods, drop plans to resell them, and treat the sale as closed once told that the buyer will keep them. The inspection element protects the buyer. If a signed receipt or an enthusiastic remark counted whenever it was made, a seller could manufacture acceptance before the buyer could learn what had arrived. The statute therefore counts the signal only after the buyer has had a fair chance to look, measured by what a sensible buyer must do to learn whether goods of that kind conform.
The signal takes many forms and survives a complaint. It needs no formula such as “I accept” and no signed acknowledgment that delivery was in good order; mixing the seller's goods into the buyer's own stock of the same kind can communicate the same message, and an indication of acceptance binds even when the buyer notes defects at the same moment.14 Listing defects does not cancel the signal, because what counts is the buyer's choice to keep the goods, and the seller will rely on that choice.
Informal praise after an inspection can carry the same weight. In Grace Label, Inc. v. Kliff, a buyer who inspected printed cards at the seller's plant and told the seller they were “great” faced the argument that he had signified conformity. The court treated those words as arguably doing so and left to the jury whether the buyer should have discovered the defect he later cited.
The opportunity to inspect must fit the goods. A test run is a perfectly reasonable way to inspect a machine intended for factory use, and a buyer who test-runs a delivered machine has not thereby accepted it, because the buyer is entitled to inspect before accepting.16 Eggl v. Letvin Equipment Co. states the general principle: a reasonable time to inspect under § 2-606 must allow an opportunity to put the product to its intended use or to test whether it performs as intended.17
Zabriskie Chevrolet, Inc. v. Smith applied that principle to a new car. The dealer argued that a spin around the block before the buyer signed the purchase order was the inspection. The court called that equation illusory and unrealistic: to a layman the mechanisms of a modern car are a mystery, and the first few miles of driving are the buyer's first real chance to learn whether the car is what was bargained for. The buyer found the defect within the first mile, well inside a reasonable opportunity to inspect, and the court concluded that in a legal sense he never accepted the vehicle.
The same logic governs a form acknowledgment. A buyer who signs a receipt reciting that a new car conforms, before having any chance to inspect it, and who discovers defects on a test drive, will likely not be held to the recital, because acceptance cannot occur until a reasonable time for inspection has passed.18
Acceptance by Failing to Reject
A buyer who does nothing can accept. Section 2-606(1)(b) makes a buyer an acceptor on failing to make an effective rejection, although acceptance does not occur until the buyer has had a reasonable opportunity to inspect.20 An effective rejection has two requirements: it must come within a reasonable time after delivery or tender, and the buyer must seasonably notify the seller.21 The buyer who says nothing, the buyer who speaks after the time has run, and the buyer who acts promptly but never reaches the seller all fail that test, and the statute treats each as an acceptor. The rule reaches even a wholly nonconforming tender, which still requires affirmative action by the buyer to avoid acceptance.22
The law requires action to reject but not to accept because most tenders satisfy the buyer. A rule that required buyers to signal acceptance would be wasteful, since a seller who has heard nothing can almost always assume the goods were satisfactory.23 The seller needs prompt word when goods are not staying, though, because early notice lets the seller cure, resell, or retrieve the goods while they remain intact. A buyer free to decide at leisure would hold an option on the transaction at the seller's expense.
Acceptance by this route depends on the opportunity to inspect, not on an actual inspection. If actual inspection were required, a buyer could leave a delivered machine in its crate for weeks and answer a demand for the price by saying that no inspection, and so no acceptance, had occurred. The statute rules that out: once the buyer has had a reasonable opportunity to inspect, failing to reject in time is itself the acceptance.24 Nor does acceptance say anything about conformity. A buyer deemed to have accepted nonconforming goods must pay for them but may still collect damages for the breach under § 2-714, even though a normal buyer would rather not have the goods and the obligation to pay.25
Cases in which the buyer was plainly unhappy and still lost show what fails as a rejection. In Connecticut Inv. Casting Corp. v. Made-Rite Tool Co., a buyer of barrel latches inspected them, found some nonconforming, and never told the seller it was rejecting the shipment. It sent back only the latches it found defective, which the seller reworked, and it pressed the seller for delivery. The Massachusetts court held that none of this was a rejection and that the buyer had accepted under § 2-606(1)(b). Because the buyer proved no damages from the late and nonconforming delivery, the seller recovered the full price.
Audio Visual Artistry v. Tanzer draws the same line. The buyer of installed equipment sent the seller a series of punch lists requesting repairs and adjustments. The Tennessee court held that a punch list is not seasonable notice of rejection: a request for repair is by its nature the opposite of a rejection, because it signals that the buyer intends to keep the item and wants more work done on it. Except for the goods the trial court identified as rejected, nothing showed an effective rejection, so the buyer could not cancel, recover the price of, or cover for the goods he had not rejected.26 He did not revoke acceptance of the rest, which stayed in his home through trial, and he owed the contract price for what he accepted.27
An Ohio court reached the same result on simpler facts. In Alarm Device Mfg. Co. v. Arnold Industries, Inc., the buyer kept the goods without making a rejection that complied with the rejection statute, and that conduct constituted acceptance.28 The acceptance also took the sale outside the writing requirement, since a buyer that receives and accepts goods can be held to a contract even without a sufficient writing.29
A reasonable time has no fixed length. It depends on how hard the defect is to discover, how quickly the goods deteriorate, and what the buyer can be expected to know. A furniture buyer who complains of scratches a week after delivery will meet little sympathy, because by then no one can tell who caused them, but a buyer who finds a week after delivery that a twelve-foot table measures eleven feet is more likely still inside the period, since tables do not shrink.30
Perishable goods call for notice almost at once. In Traynor v. Walters, the buyer notified the sellers within 24 hours of delivery that 440 Christmas trees were nonconforming, and the court held that notice reasonable and the rejection effective, so the buyer could recover damages.31 Complex equipment stretches the period, because the buyer must run it to learn whether it works. In Keller v. Inland Metals All Weather Conditioning, Inc., the buyers had to operate a newly installed dehumidifier to learn whether it served its warranted purpose, an employee reported problems four days after installation, and the Idaho Supreme Court upheld the finding that rejection came within a reasonable time.
The long end of the range appears when the buyer changes the goods before objecting. In Intervale Steel Corp. v. Borg & Beck Div., Borg-Warner Corp., the buyer processed the steel it received before it told the seller of any problem. The court held that the reasonable-opportunity-to-inspect language ensures only that a buyer's silence, without more, does not impute acceptance before the buyer has had adequate time to inspect; it does not let a buyer who has drastically changed and used the goods reject them later and avoid being treated as an acceptor, even when the defect was latent.32 The reason goes back to what rejection is for: prompt rejection leaves the goods in a condition the seller can restore, cure, or resell. The buyer in that position still keeps its damages claim for breach of warranty, so a latent defect does not leave it without a remedy.33
A merchant buyer with an obvious defect fares no better. In EPN-Delaval, S.A. v. Inter-Equip, Inc., a buyer that produced sophisticated equipment received specially ordered steel heads that were elliptical rather than hemispherical. The defect was total and blatant, the goods were not complex, and the buyer's own quality control staff could easily have found it, yet notice of rejection came more than two months after delivery. The court held that notice was not given within a reasonable time and that the buyer had accepted the nonconforming heads.
Two clocks run in these cases. The clock for rejection starts at delivery or tender, with room to inspect; the clock for notice of breach starts when the buyer discovers or should have discovered the breach.34 Rejection therefore generally has to come sooner, and a buyer who loses the right to reject by delay can still preserve a damages claim by giving timely notice of breach.
Notice of breach asks less than notice of rejection. In one case, repeated complaints about maintenance, parts, shortages, and defective supplies, together with the seller's assurances that it would resolve the problems, gave a jury enough to infer sufficient and timely notice, because the complaints were “sufficient to let the seller know that the transaction [was] still troublesome and [needed to] be watched.”35 A seller's own knowledge can matter too: allegations that its executives knew the vehicles were unsafe, that seven state attorneys general had opened investigations, that it was considering remedial steps, and that it was already in related litigation established that it knew the transactions were “troublesome and must be watched.”36 The buyer still carries the burden of alleging and proving proper notice, and failing to notify the seller of the breach bars recovery for breach of warranty.37 The contract's own terms can shape the timing: a warranty limited to defects found within a stated period limits the time within which a claim must be asserted, and a defect discovered within that period presumably allows a further reasonable time for notice.38 Later sections develop these rules. For now, the point is that a complaint that preserves damages is not a rejection.
On an exam, a buyer who complains, demands repairs, or presses for faster delivery without ever telling the seller the goods are refused, or who keeps the goods for months before objecting, has made an ineffective rejection and therefore has accepted.
Acceptance by Inconsistent Acts
Section 2-606(1)(c) supplies the third route: a buyer accepts by doing any act inconsistent with the seller's ownership, though an act wrongful as against the seller counts as acceptance only if the seller ratifies it.40 The first two routes turn on what the buyer said or failed to say; this one turns on what the buyer did. A buyer who processes, resells, or alters the goods behaves as their owner, and a seller cannot be expected to go on treating them as its own. The clause needs no announcement and no stretch of silence, and the buyer's later account of its intent does not undo the conduct.
A plant that saws an inch off the legs of a delivered machine and fastens wide feet to the bottoms has done an act inconsistent with the seller's ownership and has accepted the machine, whether or not it has inspected the machine or had an opportunity to.41 Inspection does not matter here because the first two routes wait for it only to avoid binding a buyer on an ambiguous word or silence, and a buyer who cuts into a machine has already treated it as its own.
A buyer that receives goods, processes them, and sells the finished product to a third person, without any effort to reject, has accepted them as well, because those actions are clearly inconsistent with the seller's ownership. Atlan Indus., Inc. v. O.E.M., Inc. so held,42 and a buyer must pay at the contract rate for goods it has accepted.43 Acceptance did not end the case, because a buyer may revoke acceptance of goods whose nonconformity substantially impairs them, a remedy the sections on the effects of acceptance take up.
Weil v. Murray applied the clause to alteration. The buyer of a Degas painting took part in having it cleaned and restored without the owners' consent, and the court held that doing so was an act inconsistent with their ownership whether or not the work improved the painting. The painting's later return did not defeat the owners' claim for the contract price.
The ratification qualifier protects a buyer who has already rejected. Once a rejection is effective, the buyer holds the goods for the seller, so lending, selling, or working on them is wrongful as against the seller. The Code treats such an act as an acceptance only if the seller ratifies it, meaning the seller adopts the act and elects to treat the buyer as having kept the goods.44 The election belongs to the seller because acceptance carries the duty to pay the contract rate and closes off rejection,45 and a rule that let the buyer's own wrong produce those results would give the wrongdoer a say in what the seller may recover.
A further limit keeps the clause from swallowing the rest of § 2-606. All use of goods is theoretically inconsistent with the seller's ownership, and if every use counted under subsection (1)(c), acceptance would arrive the moment the buyer first put the goods to work, before the reasonable opportunity to inspect or the reasonable time to reject had run. One position therefore holds that acts done in ignorance of defects the buyer could not have discovered are never covered by subsection (1)(c), while use and the passage of time can still amount to acceptance under subsection (1)(a) or (1)(b).46 Not every court states the limit; the processing-and-resale rule in Atlan, as quoted above, contains no knowledge requirement.47
The same logic protects a buyer who keeps using goods after rejecting them in order to limit its loss. In Keller v. Inland Metals All Weather Conditioning, Inc., the buyers rejected a dehumidifier, the seller did not remove it, and the buyers could not remove it themselves. Turning the unit off would have let humidity damage the athletic club's pool area and drive customers away, so the Idaho court held that continued use was necessary to mitigate damages and was not an act inconsistent with the seller's ownership. The purpose of the conduct separates Keller from Atlan: the Keller buyers ran the unit to prevent harm that the seller's inaction would otherwise cause, while a buyer that processes and resells goods does what an owner does.
Partial Acceptance of Units
Section 2-606(2) provides that acceptance of a part of any commercial unit is acceptance of that entire unit.49 The rule matters because of what a buyer may do with nonconforming goods. The buyer may reject the whole, accept the whole, or accept any commercial unit or units and reject the rest.50 The third choice needs a rule for where one part ends and another begins, and subsection (2) supplies it: the buyer may divide a delivery along the seams between units but may not cut through one.
The Code defines a commercial unit by how commerce treats the goods. A unit may be a single article such as a machine, a set of articles such as a suit of furniture or an assortment of sizes, a quantity such as a bale, a gross, or a carload, or any other unit treated in use or in the relevant market as a single whole.51 The definition also requires that dividing the unit materially impair its character or value on the market or in use. The two parts do different work. The trade-practice half keeps the test objective, so the unit does not depend on what the buyer finds convenient. The impairment half supplies the reason for the seam: a seller whose furniture set is broken apart holds mismatched pieces worth far less than the set, and a buyer who could pick the best pieces from a nonconforming delivery would use rejection to cherry-pick.
The measure of a unit can be as plain as the way the goods were priced. In Rocheux International of N.J., Inc. v. U.S. Merchants Financial Group, the plastic was ordered and priced by the pound. The court noted that other courts had treated a ton of bentonite and a pound of film as the commercial unit where the goods were priced by that measure, and it adopted a pound of plastic as the unit.52 Because acceptance of part of a unit is acceptance of the whole unit, the inquiry then becomes how many pounds the buyer accepted. A pound is a small unit, so acceptance of some pounds leaves open how many were kept, whereas a bale or a carload as the unit would carry more of the delivery with it. Accepting some of the goods does not accept the whole delivery unless the delivery is itself the commercial unit. The buyer owes the contract rate for each unit accepted,53 and the seller's price claim reaches only that far.
Buyers who divide a delivery along unit lines are using the Code as written. In Traynor v. Walters, the buyer rejected the 440 nonconforming trees in a delivery and recovered damages for them.54 Each tree was a separate article, so nothing tied a good tree to a bad one. Audio Visual Artistry v. Tanzer reached a similar split in a judgment: the trial court found some equipment rejected and the rest accepted, and the Tennessee Court of Appeals left the buyer without remedy as to any item he had not effectively rejected.55 Rocheux and Traynor teach different halves of the rule. Rocheux shows how to find the unit when goods are sold by a measure instead of by the piece, and Traynor shows a buyer leaving each unit whole on one side or the other.
A buyer who wants only part of a delivery must reject the rest affirmatively, because silence about the remainder is acceptance of it. In Van Dorn Co. v. Future Chemical and Oil Corp., a buyer ordered 20,000 cans of each of two kinds and received more than 29,000 of each, and the invoice, a stamped receiving record, and a packing list all showed the overshipment. The Seventh Circuit treated the excess as a nonconformity and held that the buyer's failure to reject it in time operated as acceptance, so the buyer owed the contract rate for every can delivered. The surplus cans were extra units of the same goods, so a buyer that meant to keep only the ordered quantity had to send a rejection covering the surplus.
On an exam, run the analysis on the unit and not on the buyer's preference. Identify how commerce treats the goods, whether as a set, a quantity, or a measure such as the pound, and then ask whether the buyer's acceptance touched any part of a unit. If it did, the entire unit is accepted, rejection of that unit is gone, and the contract rate is owed for it.
Ineffective Versus Wrongful Rejection
Section 2-602(1) sets the test for whether a rejection works: it must come within a reasonable time after delivery or tender, and it is ineffective unless the buyer seasonably notifies the seller.57 That test looks only at procedure and says nothing about whether the buyer had good reason to refuse the goods. Two questions therefore stay separate: whether the buyer rejected in the manner the Code requires, and whether the tender failed to conform so that the buyer was entitled to reject. A rejection that fails the first question is ineffective, and the buyer is treated as having accepted under § 2-606(1)(b) and is exposed to a claim for the price.58 A rejection that passes the first question but fails the second is effective yet wrongful, so the buyer is in breach without having accepted anything.
The wrongful side of the line begins with the buyer's duty. When the seller's tender conforms to the contract, the buyer must accept and pay for it, and a refusal is a breach.59 The refusal can still operate as a rejection. Section 2-602(3) sends the seller's rights regarding goods wrongfully rejected to the general seller's remedies of § 2-703, which presupposes that a rejection may be wrongful and still be a rejection.60
Integrated Circuits Unlimited, Inc. v. E.F. Johnson Co. held that a buyer's rejection was effective whether or not it was justified, and its reasoning runs in a chain. An action for the price lies under § 2-709 only for goods that were accepted, or that were lost, damaged, or not resalable. Section 2-606 defines acceptance to include a failure to make an effective rejection, so a procedurally defective rejection leaves the seller its price claim. By negative inference, any effective rejection, justified or not, bars acceptance and defeats that claim. A seller whose goods were wrongfully but effectively rejected proceeds under § 2-703 for damages instead.
The two classifications lead to different remedies because they describe different relationships between buyer and goods. A buyer who tells the seller promptly and then holds the goods with reasonable care has given the seller what rejection exists to give: early warning, so the seller can retrieve the goods, cure, or resell. A price judgment against that buyer would hand the seller the full contract price while the seller still held goods it could sell elsewhere, whereas damages cover what the seller actually lost. A buyer who skipped the procedure has behaved as owner by keeping the goods without telling the seller they were refused, and the price remedy was built for that situation.
The second buyer's position is the less comfortable one. That buyer must pay at the contract rate for the goods accepted,61 and it carries the burden of establishing the breach in any damages claim over the defect.62 Being right about the goods does not repair an ineffective rejection, and being wrong about them does not turn an effective rejection into an acceptance. On an exam, ask the procedural question first, whether the rejection came within a reasonable time and was seasonably noticed, and only then ask whether the tender conformed.