Concept
Ten Commandments in Classrooms
Establishment
Ten Commandments in Classrooms
Stone v. Graham shows the purpose criterion deciding a case by itself. In a per curiam opinion, meaning an unsigned opinion issued for the Court as a whole, the Court held that a statute requiring the Ten Commandments to be posted in public school classrooms violates the Establishment Clause, even though the Kentucky legislature asserted an educational goal.1 Kentucky required a copy of the Commandments in every public classroom, with the copies paid for by private contributions.2 The legislature also required a small-print notation at the bottom of each display: “The secular application of the Ten Commandments is clearly seen in its adoption as the fundamental legal code of Western Civilization and the Common Law of the United States.”3 That notation was the state's answer to the purpose criterion, and the Court's treatment of it drives the opinion.
The Court applied the three-part test of Lemon v. Kurtzman, under which a statute that violates any one part must be struck down.4 It held that Kentucky's statute has no secular legislative purpose, so it violates the first part of the test and therefore the Establishment Clause.5 Failing the first part ended the case, and the Court had no need to consider effect or entanglement.
The notation failed because the Court looked at what the posting is for. The pre-eminent purpose of posting the Ten Commandments on schoolroom walls is plainly religious, and no legislative recitation of a supposed secular purpose can blind a court to that fact.6 Abington School District v. Schempp had already refused to credit the secular purposes asserted for daily Bible reading and recitation of the Lord's Prayer: promoting moral values, countering materialistic trends, perpetuating institutions, and teaching literature.7 A rule that took every recital at its word would let a single sentence of preamble defeat the Clause. The state's related effort to characterize the Commandments in secular terms, as part of the nation's legal heritage, failed for the same reason.8
The text itself explains why the recital could not carry the weight. The Ten Commandments are undeniably a sacred text in the Jewish and Christian faiths.9 Some of their commands concern arguably secular matters: honoring one's parents, murder, adultery, stealing, false witness, and covetousness. The first part, however, concerns the religious duties of believers: worshipping the Lord God alone, avoiding idolatry, not using the Lord's name in vain, and observing the Sabbath.10 The notation described the Commandments' influence on secular law, yet the statute put the whole text on the wall, religious duties included.
The likely effect of the posting confirms its purpose. If the posted copies have any effect at all, it will be to induce schoolchildren to read, meditate upon, perhaps to venerate and obey the Commandments. That may be desirable as private devotion, but it is not a permissible state objective under the Establishment Clause.11 The case thus sits on a line the school cases draw. Public schools may not promote a religious perspective as true or sound, but they may present and describe religion, including competing religious understandings, as part of a secular program of education.12
Kentucky offered two more defenses, and neither worked. Private funding did not change the purpose the Court found plainly religious,14 and the State still spent public money administering the statute, which made the state treasurer a collecting agent for the contributions.15 Nor did it matter that the Commandments were merely posted rather than read aloud, as in Schempp and Engel v. Vitale. It is no defense to urge that religious practices may be relatively minor encroachments on the First Amendment.16 The setting made the posting weightier, not lighter. When government puts its power, prestige, and financial support behind a particular religious belief, the indirect coercive pressure on religious minorities to conform is plain, and that comment has special force in public schools, where attendance is mandatory.17
The school-aid decisions that the dissent invoked come out differently under the same test. Committee for Public Education v. Nyquist, Sloan v. Lemon, Lemon itself, and Board of Education v. Allen all involved state assistance to private schools, and such assistance has the obvious legitimate secular purpose of promoting educational opportunity. Posting the Commandments on classroom walls has no such purpose.18
Justice Rehnquist dissented, and he objected first to the manner of decision. He described the disposition as a “cavalier summary reversal,” without benefit of oral argument or briefs on the merits, of the highest court of Kentucky.19 On the merits, his footnotes make two points. First, he distinguished Schempp, where the Court had noted that the purpose was pursued through readings “without comment” from the Bible: here nothing was compelled, and the statute mandated a comment on the Commandments' secular significance. Second, he called the Court's emphasis on the religious first part of the Commandments beside the point, because the document as a whole has had significant secular impact and the Constitution does not require that Kentucky students see only an expurgated or redacted version.20 The disagreement is over what the recital is worth. The dissent treated the statutory comment as enough to separate Kentucky's posting from Schempp, while the majority held that the statute has no secular purpose.21
A later opinion recalls that in Stone the Court held a Ten Commandments posting statute invalid even though the legislature asserted an educational goal. It adds that the first Lemon criterion does not require exclusively secular objectives.22 Stone's holding is that Kentucky's statute had no secular purpose at all, not merely a mixed one.
Later Ten Commandments cases show how much the setting matters. Distinguishing Stone, the plurality in Van Orden v. Perry described a Ten Commandments monument on the Texas State Capitol grounds as a far more passive use of the text than in Stone, where the text confronted elementary school students every day. It added that Texas treats its Capitol grounds monuments as representing several strands of the State's political and legal history.23 The audience matters elsewhere in Establishment Clause law too. In the aid context the Court has said that college students are less impressionable and less susceptible to religious indoctrination, so religion is less likely to permeate secular education than in primary and secondary schools.24 In a separate case on displays in county courthouses, the Court divided 5–4 and applied Lemon. It held that the displays violated the Clause even though the counties contended they were a secular effort to educate the citizenry on the foundations of American law, and it described the secular-purpose prong as serving the important function of mandating government neutrality toward religion.25 The dissent doubted that the counties acted to promote religion. If the Commandments have a proper place in civic history, it reasoned, even displaying them alone can be civically motivated, especially in a courthouse rather than a school as in Stone.26
Stone is a first-criterion decision under Lemon, and in 2022 the Court said in Kennedy v. Bremerton School District that Lemon had been overruled. It is unclear what that means for the many cases decided under the test, Stone among them.27