Also known as:supervising lawyers · supervisory lawyer · supervising attorney
Written by attorneys · grounded in primary & secondary sources — see below
A lawyer with direct supervisory authority over another lawyer. The supervising lawyer's reasonable resolution of an arguable question of professional duty shields a subordinate from discipline when the subordinate follows that resolution.
Sources & Authorities· 1 primary source
Select any source to read its text and confirm it supports the definition.
Sophia Singh supervised Simon Stern on a trucking company's defense in a wrongful death suit. After internal searches found no additional GPS records, Sophia directed Simon to file a motion stating the client had no further responsive data. Simon knew backup copies existed on a vendor's servers but filed the motion as directed because Sophia identified the scope of possession and control as an arguable question and her resolution as reasonable. Simon faces no discipline under the rule protecting subordinates who follow a supervisor's reasonable resolution of a debatable professional duty.
Partner's Reasonable Directive Shields Associate
Tammy assigned Sophia to prepare declarations for wage-and-hour litigation using a firm template. Tammy directed Sophia to use a particular interpretation of the possession-and-control rule that Tammy reasonably viewed as arguable. Sophia followed the directive exactly and filed the declarations. Sophia faces no discipline because she acted in accordance with Tammy's reasonable resolution of the debatable professional duty.
Common questions
Frequently Asked
4
When does a supervising lawyer become responsible for a subordinate's ethical violation?+
A supervising lawyer becomes responsible if the lawyer orders the conduct, knowingly ratifies it, or knows of the conduct at a time when its consequences can be avoided or mitigated but fails to take reasonable remedial action. Direct supervisory authority triggers an affirmative duty to make reasonable efforts to ensure compliance, and mere delegation without oversight does not satisfy that duty.
Supporting sources
Does a subordinate lawyer remain personally bound by the ethics rules when following a supervisor's direction?
Yes. A lawyer is bound by the Rules of Professional Conduct notwithstanding that the lawyer acted at the direction of another person. The protection in Rule 5.2(b) applies only when the supervisor's resolution of an arguable question is reasonable. The subordinate must still assess whether that threshold is met.
Supporting sources
What constitutes reasonable efforts by a supervising lawyer in a high-volume matter?+
Reasonable efforts require more than a single verbal instruction or bare delegation. In high-volume tasks such as preparing declarations or intake calls, a supervising lawyer must implement protocols, provide follow-up training, sample work product, or establish review mechanisms to detect inaccuracies, especially when the work will be filed in court.
Supporting sources
Is a chief legal officer subject to discipline for failing to create firm-wide compliance systems?+
Yes. A lawyer with managerial authority has a duty to make reasonable efforts to ensure the organization has measures that give reasonable assurance all lawyers conform to the rules. Informal delegation and general admonitions without training, written policies, or reporting structures do not satisfy that obligation in a large department.
Supporting sources
Professional ResponsibilityRegulation of the legal profession · Responsibilities of partners, managers, supervisory and subordinate lawyersMPREFoundational