Also known as:remedies over · right of remedy over · reimbursement right · recourse
Written by attorneys · grounded in primary & secondary sources — see below
A right of recourse against a third party who bears ultimate responsibility for a loss or obligation. The right arises from indemnification or subrogation and permits the party held liable in the first instance to shift the burden to the ultimately responsible party.
Sources & Authorities
How it applies
Common Examples
6
Infringement Suit Notification Failure
Rising Sun Electronics sold circuit boards to Rocky Mountain Mining. A patent holder sued Rocky Mountain for infringement based on the boards. Rocky Mountain received notice of the suit but failed to notify Rising Sun within a reasonable time. Because Rocky Mountain omitted the required notice, it lost any remedy over against Rising Sun for the liability established in the litigation.
Indemnitor Recourse After Payment
Rhapsody Entertainment granted a security interest in its recording equipment to Redwood Bank. A guarantor paid the bank after default. The guarantor then exercised its remedy over against Rhapsody to recover the amount paid, shifting the ultimate burden to the primary obligor.
Select any source to read its text and confirm it supports the definition.
Statutes
Federal Rules
Uniform Acts
Model Codes
Restatements
Casebooks
Dictionaries
Secondary Obligor Recourse Right
Roberto Reyes guaranteed a loan secured by equipment owned by Renata Russo. When the primary debtor defaulted, the secured party enforced the collateral. Roberto retained a right of recourse against Renata for any amount the secured party collected from him.
Collection Charge-Back Right
Redwood Bank held a security interest in accounts receivable of Rhapsody Entertainment. After default the bank collected from account debtors through an agency. Because the collection efforts were commercially reasonable, the bank remained entitled to charge back uncollected amounts to Rhapsody as its remedy over.
Maritime Third-Party Claim
Renee Rogers, owner of a vessel, faced an admiralty claim for cargo damage. She impleaded the cargo handler who had caused the loss. The third-party claim allowed Renee to obtain remedy over against the handler for any liability she ultimately owed the original plaintiff.
Mortgage Assumption Recourse
Rajesh Rao sold mortgaged property to Rebecca Ross. Rebecca assumed the mortgage obligation. When the mortgagee later sought payment from Rajesh after default, Rajesh retained a remedy over against Rebecca to compel performance of the assumed debt.
Common questions
Frequently Asked
4
What must a buyer do to preserve a remedy over in an infringement suit under the UCC?+
The buyer must notify the seller within a reasonable time after receiving notice of the litigation. Failure to give timely notice bars the buyer from any remedy over for liability established by the litigation.
Supporting sources
How does a right of recourse differ from a direct claim against the primary obligor?+
A right of recourse permits the party held liable in the first instance to shift the burden to a third party who is ultimately responsible. It arises from indemnification or subrogation rather than from the original transaction between the claimant and the primary obligor.
Supporting sources
When may a secured party charge back uncollected collateral to the debtor?+
A secured party that collects from account debtors in a commercially reasonable manner may charge back uncollected amounts or exercise full or limited recourse against the debtor or a secondary obligor.
Supporting sources
Does a mortgage assumption create a remedy over for the original mortgagor?+
Yes. When the transferee assumes the mortgage obligation, the original mortgagor who remains personally liable may compel the transferee to perform so that the transferor will not have to discharge the debt.
Supporting sources
431 U.S. 494, 503 (1977)Property
…Although he agrees that the Due Process Clause has substantive content, Mr. Justice White in dissent expresses the fear that our recourse to history and tradition will "broaden enormously the horizons of the Clause." Post , at 549-550. To the contrary, an approach grounded in history imposes limits on the judiciary that are…