In the fall of 1985, petitioners Community for Creative Non-Violence and Mitch Snyder conceived the idea for a sculpture depicting a contemporary Nativity scene featuring homeless people to dramatize their plight during the annual Christmastime Pageant of Peace in Washington, D.C. Snyder contacted respondent James Earl Reid, a sculptor, and in two telephone calls the parties agreed that Reid would produce the three life-sized human figures while CCNV would build the steam grate and pedestal.
They selected Design Cast 62 as the material, capped the project cost at $15,000 excluding Reid's donated services, set a December 12 deadline, and reached no written agreement while never discussing copyright. After Reid received an advance of $3,000, he made several sketches of figures in different poses. At Snyder’s request, Reid sent CCNV a sketch of a proposed sculpture showing the family in a crechelike setting: the mother seated, cradling a baby in her lap; the father standing behind her, bending over her shoulder to touch the baby’s foot.
Reid sought a black family to serve as a model for the sculpture. Upon Snyder’s suggestion, Reid visited a family living at CCNV’s Washington shelter but decided that only their newly born child was a suitable model. While Reid was in Washington, Snyder took him to see homeless people living on the streets. Snyder pointed out that they tended to recline on steam grates, rather than sit or stand, to warm their bodies. From that time on, Reid’s sketches contained only reclining figures.
From November through mid-December 1985, Reid worked on the statue in his Baltimore studio with assistance from people paid by CCNV installments, and CCNV members visited to check progress and directed the inclusion of a shopping cart for the figures' belongings. On December 24, 1985, 12 days after the agreed-upon date, Reid delivered the completed statue to Washington. Snyder paid Reid the final installment of the $15,000. The statue remained on display for a month. In late January 1986, CCNV members returned it to Reid's studio in Baltimore for minor repairs.
In March 1986, after Snyder requested the sculpture's return, Reid refused, registered a copyright in his name, and planned a tour. Snyder filed a competing registration as CCNV trustee. CCNV and Snyder then sued Reid seeking return of the sculpture and a determination of copyright ownership. Following a two-day bench trial the district court held the sculpture was a work made for hire owned by CCNV, but the Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit reversed and remanded on the possibility of joint authorship, prompting the Supreme Court to grant certiorari.
View case