Also known as: exculpates · exculpated · exculpating · exculpation · exculpations · exculpatory · exculpatory evidence
Written by attorneys · grounded in primary & secondary sources — see below
To clear a person from blame or accusation by disclosing favorable evidence or by contractual provision relieving a party from responsibility for loss or breach.
Select any source to read its text and confirm it supports the definition.
Omar was held as an enemy combatant after a naval boarding team found weapons on his ship. Months later his counsel located crew statements and ship logs showing he had no knowledge of the cargo. The review board accepted the materials and ordered his release, thereby exculpating him from the enemy-combatant designation.
Elena Estrada stood trial for arson after a fire destroyed her neighbor's garage. The state possessed a lab report showing the accelerant matched fuel stored by the neighbor's son. When the report surfaced after conviction, the court reversed the judgment because the suppressed evidence would have exculpated Estrada.
Eduardo Enriquez faced murder charges when the only eyewitness refused to testify. A reliable out-of-court statement from a bystander describing another shooter was offered by the defense. The trial court admitted the statement, allowing it to exculpate Enriquez and produce an acquittal.
Eric Espinoza was arrested for robbery and questioned without warnings. His later confession was the state's main evidence. After the court suppressed the statement, the remaining proof was insufficient and the charges were dismissed, exculpating Espinoza at trial.
Emily Ellis was charged with drug possession after officers searched her home based on a lead obtained from an unlawful arrest of a visitor. The court suppressed the drugs found inside. Without that evidence the prosecution could not proceed, exculpating Ellis before trial.
Everlasting Insurance refused to pay a claim and faced a class action. The policy contained an arbitration clause with a class waiver. The court enforced the clause, sending the dispute to individual arbitration and thereby exculpating the insurer from class-wide liability.
The prosecution must disclose evidence that is favorable to the accused and material to guilt or punishment. Suppression of such material exculpatory evidence, whether intentional or inadvertent, requires reversal when prejudice results.
No. An exculpatory term drafted by the trustee is invalid unless the trustee proves it is fair under the circumstances and was adequately communicated to the settlor.
Strict application of hearsay rules violates due process when it excludes reliable and critical exculpatory evidence. The Constitution may require admission of trustworthy hearsay if exclusion would deprive the defendant of a fair trial.
…with some specificity in the pages which follow but briefly stated it is this: the prosecution may not use statements, whether exculpatory or inculpatory, stemming from custodial interrogation of the defendant unless it demonstrates the use of procedural safeguards effective to secure the privilege against self-incrimination.…