Also known as: evasions · evasive · evasively · evade
Written by attorneys · grounded in primary & secondary sources — see below
An act or course of conduct by which a person or entity seeks to avoid a legal obligation, rule, or judicial process. The conduct often exploits technicalities, loopholes, or informal means to frustrate enforcement or review while stopping short of outright violation.
Select any source to read its text and confirm it supports the definition.
Elijah Edwards, a licensed attorney, was convicted of willfully attempting to evade income taxes by underreporting earnings through offshore accounts. The disciplinary board imposed sanctions based on the criminal conduct alone. The conviction reflected adversely on his honesty and fitness to practice regardless of the criminal sentence imposed.
Esme Ellington gave statements to police during an informal emergency call after an assault. Prosecutors offered the statements at trial to prove the identity of her attacker. The defense argued the statements were produced to evade the formalized testimonial process that triggers confrontation rights.
Emma Erickson challenged a city zoning ordinance in federal court before exhausting state administrative remedies. The court declined to intervene, noting that premature federal relief would encourage evasion and undermine important state interests embodied in regulatory procedures.
Edith Eberhardt was detained during an investigatory stop. Officers extended the detention to twenty minutes because her evasive answers and contradictory statements delayed the investigation. The court held the extension reasonable under the totality of the circumstances.
Ella Emerson challenged a temporary restraining order that expired before appellate review could occur. The court applied the capable-of-repetition-yet-evading-review exception because the same party faced a reasonable likelihood of identical short-duration action in the future.
Enigma Technologies was hit with a massive punitive damages verdict. The court reduced the award, explaining that an excessive ratio would allow plaintiffs to evade constitutional limits on punishment by recharacterizing compensatory damages as punitive.
Yes. A conviction for willfully attempting to evade income taxes constitutes criminal conduct that reflects adversely on honesty, trustworthiness, or fitness as a lawyer. Discipline may be imposed independent of the criminal sentence.
Supporting sources
An injunction risks permitting evasion when its terms are drafted so narrowly that the defendant can comply while still achieving the prohibited result. Courts must draft orders with reasonable precision to avoid this outcome while still making enforcement practicable.
…v. Vail , 430 U. S. 327 (1977); and Trainor v. Hernandez, ante , p. 434, argue strongly against action which encourages evasion and undermining of other important state interests embodied in regulatory procedures. When the State asserts its sovereignty through the administrative process, no less than when it…
…and punishing interracial marriages. The Lovings were convicted of violating § 20-58 of the Virginia Code: “Leaving State to evade law.” — If any white person and colored person shall go out of this State, for the purpose of being married, and with the intention of returning, and be married out of it, and afterwards…
…steps required by Art. I, §§ 1, 7, make certain that there is an opportunity for deliberation and debate. To allow Congress to
…if it is only applicable to formalized testimonial materials. Ante , at 826. But the Court's proposed solution to the risk of evasion is needlessly overinclusive. Because the Confrontation Clause sought to regulate prosecutorial abuse occurring through use of ex parte statements as evidence against the accused, it also…
…above. See 494 U. S., at 661–665. Small-business owners may speak in their own names, rather than the business’, if they wish to evade
Supporting sources
Courts evaluate the totality of the circumstances. A suspect's evasive answers or contradictory statements that delay the investigation can render a twenty-minute detention reasonable when officers pursue their inquiry diligently.
Supporting sources
The exception applies only when the same complaining party faces a reasonable expectation of repetition and the challenged action is inherently short in duration so that it will consistently evade full judicial review.
Supporting sources
Counting irrevocable gifts made in anticipation of imminent death prevents easy evasion of the surviving spouse's elective share through death-bed transfers or will substitutes that would otherwise remove assets from the probate estate.
Supporting sources