Also known as: cogently · cogency · persuasive · compelling
Written by attorneys · grounded in primary & secondary sources — see below
Reasoning or argument that is compelling or convincing.
Select any source to read its text and confirm it supports the definition.
Curtis Cannon served discovery requests on Citadel Security but received incomplete responses. In his motion under Rule 37, Cannon included a detailed certification showing his good-faith efforts to resolve the dispute informally. The court found his submission contained cogent reasoning that justified granting the order to compel.
Carlos Castillo challenged a municipal ordinance that singled out his religious practices. His brief presented evidence that the law targeted specific rituals rather than serving neutral public-health goals. The court deemed his analysis cogent and held the ordinance failed strict scrutiny.
Cody Callahan's will contained ambiguous language about asset distribution. Christopher Collins offered extrinsic evidence showing the testator's consistent plan to favor one beneficiary. The probate court found Collins's constructional argument cogent and adopted it over competing interpretations.
Carmen Choi sought to testify at trial from another state due to medical restrictions. Her motion detailed the health risks of travel and proposed secure video safeguards. The judge found her showing of good cause cogent and permitted contemporaneous transmission.
Charles Cunningham challenged a state policy that treated male and female applicants differently for public benefits. His brief demonstrated that the classification rested on outdated stereotypes rather than genuine differences. The court accepted his intermediate-scrutiny analysis as cogent and struck down the policy.
Crown Pharmaceuticals employees sought recognition of their out-of-state same-sex marriages for benefit purposes. Their counsel presented historical and doctrinal analysis showing that exclusion lacked legitimate justification. The court described the submission as cogent and granted the requested relief.
Courts assess whether an argument is cogent by examining its logical force, factual support, and direct application to the governing rule. A cogent submission typically includes precise citations, clear analysis of the facts, and a persuasive link between the two.
Supporting sources
Yes. Cogent describes reasoning that carries compelling weight because it is both logically sound and factually grounded, making it persuasive to the decision-maker.
Supporting sources
Yes. Even cogent reasoning may be outweighed by stronger contrary authority, controlling precedent, or policy considerations that the court finds more compelling on the specific facts.
Supporting sources
…writ is of extensive remedial nature and issues where the party has a right to have anything done and no other specific means of compelling its performance. Many English cases illustrate the practice of issuing mandamus to compel ministerial acts concerning the public including compelling the presentment of conveyances,…