Elf Atochem North America, Inc., a Pennsylvania corporation manufacturing solvent-based maskants for the aerospace industry, approached Cyrus A. Jaffari in the mid-nineties regarding a joint venture to develop and market his innovative water-based maskant. Jaffari served as president of Malek, Inc., a California corporation with limited resources and international sales expertise. The parties agreed to form a Delaware limited liability company to conduct the business.
On October 29, 1996, Malek, Inc. filed a Certificate of Formation for Malek LLC with the Delaware Secretary of State. Subsequently, on November 4, 1996, Elf, Jaffari, and Malek, Inc. executed a comprehensive thirty-eight page LLC Agreement. Under its terms, Elf contributed one million dollars in exchange for a thirty percent interest in Malek LLC while Malek, Inc. contributed its rights to the water-based maskant technology for a seventy percent interest, and Jaffari was named manager of the LLC. Elf and Malek LLC also entered into an Exclusive Distributorship Agreement, and Jaffari signed an employment agreement with Malek LLC.
The LLC Agreement contained detailed dispute resolution provisions. Section 13.8 required submission of any controversy or dispute arising out of the Agreement to arbitration in San Francisco, California, and barred members from instituting court actions except to compel arbitration or enforce an award. Section 13.7 provided for the exclusive jurisdiction of California state and federal courts over claims not subject to arbitration and included consent to personal jurisdiction in that state.
On April 27, 1998, Elf filed a complaint in the Delaware Court of Chancery against Jaffari and Malek LLC, asserting claims both individually and derivatively on behalf of Malek LLC. The allegations included breaches of fiduciary duty by Jaffari, such as withdrawing funds for personal use and interfering with business opportunities, as well as breach of contract, tortious interference, and fraud. The Court of Chancery granted the defendants' motion to dismiss for lack of subject matter jurisdiction, prompting Elf's appeal to the Delaware Supreme Court.
View case