Also known as:captures · captured · prize capture · maritime seizure
Written by attorneys · grounded in primary & secondary sources — see below
2 senses
1
in property law
A method of acquiring ownership of unowned resources by reducing them to possession. The first person to capture a fugitive resource such as a wild animal obtains title.
2
Sense 1
1
in property law
A method of acquiring ownership of unowned resources by reducing them to possession. The first person to capture a fugitive resource such as a wild animal obtains title.
Examples5
Naval Prize During Hostilities
Clifford Cox, commanding a privateer commissioned by Congress, seized an enemy merchant vessel on the high seas and brought it into port. The vessel's cargo was sold at auction under federal prize proceedings. Because Congress had authorized rules for captures, the proceeds were distributed according to statute rather than reverting to the original owners.
Enemy Property Seized on Land
Christian Coleman, a U.S. soldier, took possession of cotton bales belonging to a British subject during the War of 1812. The bales were later condemned by a federal court. Title vested in the captor because the seizure occurred under lawful authority and reduced the goods to possession.
Sense 2
2
in wills and trusts
A doctrine under which a donee of a general power of appointment who blends the appointive property with the donee's own property in a will is treated as having appointed failed gifts to the donee or the donee's estate.
Examples1
Failed Appointment in Blended Will
Charlotte Chung, donee of a general power, executed a will that blended appointive property with her own estate and made several residuary gifts. Two of the gifts later failed. The court applied capture and directed the failed portions to Charlotte's estate rather than to the takers in default.
A doctrine under which a donee of a general power of appointment who blends the appointive property with the donee's own property in a will is treated as having appointed failed gifts to the donee or the donee's estate.
Each sense below has its own examples, sources, and questions.
Brown v. United States12 U.S. 110 (1814)
Capture of Stray Livestock
Cameron Cole found a herd of unbranded cattle wandering on open range after a storm. He drove the animals into a corral, fed and branded them. Because he reduced the fugitive livestock to possession, a court awarded him ownership under the rule of capture.
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. v. Dukes564 U.S. 338 (2011)
Oil and Gas Capture by Drilling
Cynthia Carter drilled a well on her land that tapped a common underground reservoir. The extracted oil flowed into her storage tanks. Title to the oil vested in Cynthia once she reduced it to possession even though the pool extended under neighboring tracts.
City of Cleburne, Texas, et al. v. Cleburne Living Center, Inc., et al.473 U.S. 432, 105 S. Ct. 3249, 87 L. Ed. 2d 313 (1985)
Capture of Escaped Prisoner Reward
Carlton Cruz recaptured an escaped convict after the prisoner fled a work detail. He delivered the prisoner to authorities and claimed the posted reward. The court held that Carlton obtained the reward by successfully reducing the fugitive to custody.
County of Sacramento v. Lewis523 U.S. 833 (1998)
Frequently Asked2
What must a claimant show to prevail under the rule of capture for a wild animal?+
The claimant must reduce the animal to possession through physical capture or mortal wounding that deprives it of its natural liberty. Mere pursuit or proximity is insufficient.
How does the Constitution's reference to captures relate to the property rule of capture?+
Article I, Section 8 grants Congress power to make rules concerning captures on land and water, confirming that title to seized property vests according to federal statute once possession is obtained.
Nixon v. United States506 U.S. 224 (1993)
Frequently Asked2
Does the capture doctrine in wills apply to special powers of appointment?+
No. Capture applies only to general powers. Special powers trigger the allocation doctrine instead, which unblends the property and directs it only to permissible appointees.
When does a blending clause trigger capture rather than allocation?+
A blending clause triggers capture when the donee holds a general power and one or more appointed gifts fail. The failed portions are then treated as appointed to the donee or the donee's estate.
497 U.S. 261, 277 (1990)Constitutional Law
…said that somebody "led a good life." They may also mean to refer to the practical manifestation of the human spirit, a meaning captured by the familiar observation that somebody "added life" to an assembly. If there is a shared thread among the various opinions on this subject, it may be that life is an activity which is at…
ContractsFormation of contracts · Mutual assent (including offer and acceptance, and unilateral, bilateral, and implied-in-fact contracts)UBEIntermediate