Thomas A. Dewire died in January 1941. He was survived by his widow Mabel G. Dewire, his son Thomas A. Dewire Jr., and three grandchildren Thomas III, Paula, and Deborah, all children of Thomas Jr. His will placed substantially all his estate in a residuary trust. The income of the trust was payable to his widow for life and, on her death, the income was payable to his son Thomas Jr., the widow of Thomas Jr., and Thomas Jr.’s children.
After the testator’s death, Thomas Jr. had three more children by a second wife. Thomas Jr. died on May 28, 1978, a widower, survived by all six of his children. Thomas III, who had served as trustee since 1978, died on March 19, 1987, leaving a widow and one child, Jennifer. The petition for a declaration of rights concerns the distribution of the one-sixth share of the trust income that had been payable to Thomas III.
In his will, the testator stated that his grandchildren under guidance and discretion of the trustee shall share equally in the net income of the estate. At another point he referred to the trust income being divided equally amongst his grandchildren. The will provided for the trust’s termination twenty-one years after the death of the last surviving child of Thomas Jr. The property of the trust shall be equally divided amongst the lineal descendants of the testator’s grandchildren. There is no explicit provision in the will concerning the distribution of income on the death of a grandchild while the gift of income to grandchildren continues.
A judge of the Probate and Family Court reserved and reported the case on a statement of agreed facts to the Supreme Judicial Court. The Supreme Judicial Court transferred the case on its own motion. The judge listed a large number of issues arising from the artlessly drafted will, but the court addressed them only to the extent necessary to permit a declaration of the present rights of the parties.
View case