Also known as: advice and consent · advise-and-consent · Advice and Consent Clause · Senate confirmation
Written by attorneys · grounded in primary & secondary sources — see below
An approval power vested in the Senate by which the President may conclude treaties only with the concurrence of two-thirds of the Senators present and may appoint principal officers only upon Senate confirmation.
President Adams negotiated a manufacturing compact with China that imposed binding production quotas on domestic factories. Abigail Alvarez, a senator, objected that the agreement constituted a treaty. Without Senate concurrence the compact could not bind U.S. manufacturers.
Congress authorized a judicial panel to appoint a special prosecutor whose duties were confined to investigating one cabinet official. Aaron Adams challenged the appointment as bypassing Senate confirmation. Because the role qualified as inferior the appointment stood without advise and consent.
Select any source to read its text and confirm it supports the definition.
President Adams issued an order seizing steel mills during a labor dispute. Anita Ali, a mill owner, sued claiming the action required legislative approval. The order fell outside the President's independent powers and could not proceed without congressional involvement.
Congress created an agency led by a single director removable only for cause. Antonio Alvarado challenged enforcement actions taken by the director. The structure prevented the President from holding the officer accountable and therefore violated separation of powers.
Congress created a claims commission whose members served fixed terms without presidential removal power. Adrian Aguilar contested an adverse ruling by arguing the members were principal officers. The fixed terms and lack of removal authority confirmed they were inferior officers not requiring Senate confirmation.
Congress established a sentencing commission whose members were appointed by the President with Senate confirmation. Alan Ackerman challenged a guideline as an improper delegation. The commission's placement within the judicial branch and limited rulemaking role satisfied constitutional requirements.
No. The Constitution permits Congress to vest appointment of inferior officers in the President alone, the courts, or department heads. Limited duties and narrow jurisdiction mark an officer as inferior and remove the need for Senate confirmation.
Supporting sources
An agreement requires advise and consent when it functions as a treaty by imposing binding long-term obligations on domestic parties. Temporary executive agreements addressing urgent crises may proceed without Senate approval.
Supporting sources
No. The Senate remains in session when it holds pro forma sessions and does not formally declare a recess. The President therefore lacks authority to bypass advise and consent through recess appointments.
Supporting sources
An officer is principal when the role involves broad ongoing authority and policy discretion. Limited duties, narrow jurisdiction, and temporary tenure indicate inferior status that permits appointment without Senate confirmation.
Supporting sources
…violate the Appointments Clause, which gives the President the power to appoint principal officers of the United States with the advice and consent of the Senate, and to appoint inferior officers with the advice and consent of the Senate or, if Congress so provides by law, with the advice and consent of the Senate or by the President…