Concept
The Plaintiff's Own Negligence
Justifiable reliance, materiality, and causation
The Plaintiff's Own Negligence
A fraud plaintiff who justifiably relies on a misrepresentation does not lose the claim because the reliance was careless. The Restatement (Second) of Torts § 545A states the rule directly: one who justifiably relies upon a fraudulent misrepresentation is not barred from recovery by his contributory negligence in doing so.1 Contributory negligence is the plaintiff's own failure to use reasonable care, and in an ordinary negligence case it can defeat the claim. The rule is needed because justifiable reliance looks like a negligence test under another name. Both ask whether the plaintiff behaved sensibly, and a defendant who lied will say that the plaintiff should have read the papers, made the call, or looked harder. Section 545A takes that answer away.
The two rules sit uneasily together. Contributory negligence is no defense to fraud, yet the victim must prove justifiable, which is to say reasonable, reliance, and that requirement implies some duty of care on the victim's part.2 One court reconciled the two through notice. The victim of an ordinary accident must use the ordinary care of an average person, even one who is below average at taking care, and so must avoid being negligent. The victim of a deliberate fraud is barred only if he has notice of the fraud, and so he need only avoid "deliberate and reckless risk-taking."3
Notice marks the line because of what each victim has been given. The accident victim must stay alert for dangers not yet noticed. The fraud victim has been handed a statement meant to allay suspicion, and a rule that demanded alertness anyway would require the plaintiff to disbelieve in advance what the defendant worked to make believable. The law asks something narrower: that the plaintiff not go ahead once something has signaled that the statement cannot be trusted.
The same reasoning excludes comparative negligence. A 2020 Restatement comment notes that "[p]rinciples of comparative negligence do not apply to a claim of fraud."4 A plaintiff whose reliance was justifiable therefore does not lose the claim for carelessness, and does not see damages reduced for it either.
Notice can come from the circumstances as well as from anything the defendant says. If "red flags" would put a reasonable person on notice that a statement is false, a court may reject a claim of justifiable reliance because it was unreasonable to proceed in the face of such warning signs without an investigation.5 The notice rule explains why these decisions do not revive contributory negligence: what defeats the claim is the warning the plaintiff held and ignored, not a lapse from ordinary care.
Without such a warning, even a missed precaution does not defeat reliance. In Field v. Mans, a creditor whose reliance on a debtor's representations was justifiable was not barred by the debtor's bankruptcy, even though he could readily have learned the truth by checking the deed records.6
What separates the homeowner from the buyer is what each held when acting. The homeowner had only the contractor's word, and carelessness in trusting it costs nothing. The buyer held a warning and chose to run the risk. The buyer's loss is also a different thing from a deduction for fault. Justifiable reliance is an element that the victim must prove,7 so the plaintiff who acts despite notice fails to establish the claim, while the merely careless plaintiff keeps it whole. The usual exam error is to call the plaintiff's reliance imprudent and then bar or reduce the claim for that reason alone, which applies the defense that § 545A removes as though it were the element of justifiability.
The treatment changes when the defendant's own fault is carelessness rather than deception. Deceit traditionally required an intentional misrepresentation,8 but a claim that requires proof of negligence is subject to the defense of comparative or contributory negligence.9 A plaintiff who sues for negligent misrepresentation can therefore expect the defendant to invoke the plaintiff's own carelessness, which may bar or reduce recovery. Fraud offers no matching comparison, because the defendant's fault is a deliberate choice to mislead.
The prevailing rule has its critics. Under it, a plaintiff who fails to rely justifiably recovers nothing,10 but one commentator argues that such a failure should not bar recovery and should instead reduce damages under comparative fault principles.11 Unless the jurisdiction has adopted that proposal, § 545A and the notice rule govern.