Concept
Choosing the Right Tort
Invasion of privacy torts
Choosing the Right Tort
Warren and Brandeis located the privacy right in “an inviolate personality,” not in the principle of private property.1 Section 652A(2) of the Restatement (Second) of Torts now defines the right by listing four ways to invade it: unreasonable intrusion upon the seclusion of another (§ 652B), appropriation of the other’s name or likeness (§ 652C), unreasonable publicity given to the other’s private life (§ 652D), and publicity that unreasonably places the other in a false light before the public (§ 652E).2 Section 652A(1) makes an invader liable for the resulting harm to the other’s interests, but it names no conduct that triggers liability.3 A fact pattern that says only that the defendant “invaded the plaintiff’s privacy” therefore leaves the main work undone. Someone must decide which of the four invasions the facts describe before any element can be applied.
The choice matters because each branch asks a different question of the facts, and an analysis run under the wrong branch imports requirements the claim does not have. Appropriation asks whether the defendant used the plaintiff’s name or likeness for the defendant’s own use or benefit.4 Disclosure asks whether publicity was given to a matter concerning private life that would be highly offensive to a reasonable person and is not of legitimate concern to the public.5 False light asks whether the publicity placed the plaintiff before the public in a highly offensive false light, and whether the defendant knew of or recklessly disregarded the falsity.6 Intrusion, the first item on the list, speaks of seclusion and says nothing about publicity.7 A student who argues truth against an appropriation claim, or demands publicity for an intrusion claim, has answered an element the claim never contained.
This section builds the sorting skill in two steps. Diagnostic Variables supplies four questions that send a fact pattern to its branch. Overlapping Claims then shows why the sort sometimes yields more than one answer, and why the damages rule of § 652H, which compensates the harm the invasion caused, keeps several successful claims from multiplying a single recovery.8
Diagnostic Variables
The four branches differ along four variables, and each one shows in the Restatement’s own wording. Only § 652C speaks of using a name or likeness for the defendant’s “own use or benefit.”9 Only the first item in § 652A(2) concerns intrusion upon seclusion.10 Of the four, only §§ 652D and 652E are framed in terms of publicity, the first of a matter concerning private life and the second of a matter that places the plaintiff in a false light.11 And only § 652E asks about falsity, requiring that the defendant knew of or recklessly disregarded the falsity of what it published.12 Change one fact on any of these variables and the same episode may belong to a different branch. The four questions below are built to find that fact.
A yes to one question identifies a branch that fits. It does not end the sorting, because the same episode may support a second branch or another tort, as the next subsection shows. The order also does some work. The first two questions can be answered from what the defendant did before anyone else heard of it, and the last two split on one fact: whether what was published is true.
The first question isolates the variable that no other branch has. It asks about the plaintiff’s identity and not about the defendant’s profit in general, and the cases bear that out. There is no liability for the mere use of the plaintiff’s name, as when a novel or comic strip gave a character the same name.17 Liability does attach when a publisher advertises a work that does not involve the plaintiff at all, as when a magazine cover falsely stated that the issue contained the plaintiff’s photograph.18
The second question draws the most wrong answers, because students carry the publicity requirement of disclosure and false light into a branch that has none. Intrusion is aimed at the prying itself, and the Restatement’s words for it, unreasonable intrusion upon the seclusion of another, call for no audience.19 The claim fails when the plaintiff had secluded nothing or the intrusion was not unreasonable, and the defendant’s silence afterward has no bearing on either point.
The last two questions turn on a single fact, and a stem often leaves the branch open until the truth of the publication is settled.
False light does not depend on secrecy. Section 652E asks whether the false light would be highly offensive and whether the defendant knew of or recklessly disregarded the falsity, and it does not ask whether the matter was private.20 A defendant who answers a false light claim by saying that nothing private was revealed has answered a question the branch never asks.
Once the branch is chosen, its limits come with it, so the sorting answer and the defense analysis belong together:
- Appropriation does not reach the coincidence of a shared name,21 and it reaches an advertisement for a work only when the work does not involve the plaintiff.22
- Intrusion requires an unreasonable intrusion upon seclusion and no publicity.23
- Disclosure fails when the matter is of legitimate concern to the public. In Sipple’s suit, the court affirmed summary judgment for the publishers under the newsworthiness privilege, because the information was widely known and the publications grew from legitimate political considerations and not from “morbid and sensational prying” into his private life.24 Cox supplies the constitutional side, asking whether the First and Fourteenth Amendments allow a state to extend a damages action for invasion of privacy to the publication of a deceased rape victim’s name that had been publicly revealed in connection with the prosecution.25
- False light requires that the defendant knew of or recklessly disregarded the falsity of what it published.26
Overlapping Claims
Section 652A(2) lists the four invasions as alternatives, and nothing in the list makes one exclude another.28 An episode that meets the elements of two branches therefore supports two claims. Overlap is common because a single course of conduct often injures several interests at once: a watcher takes seclusion, a broadcaster exposes a private matter, and a caption can misdescribe the person pictured. The practical method follows the acts and not the episode. Each act is tested against its own branch, and each claim carries its own defenses.
A single publication can also support different labels, depending on the fact the claim rests on. A magazine cover that falsely stated that the issue included a photograph of the plaintiff produced liability in Lerman, because the work advertised did not involve the plaintiff at all; the cover used the plaintiff’s identity to promote the issue.29 A cover that implied a nude picture of the plaintiff inside, when he appeared fully dressed, produced a triable issue of false light in Solano.30 The two cases show that one cover feature can do both jobs. Appropriation under § 652C asks only whether the defendant used the identity for its own use or benefit,31 while false light under § 652E adds falsity, high offensiveness, and knowledge of or reckless disregard as to the falsity.32 A plaintiff on cover facts may therefore hold two claims with different burdens, and the false light claim is the one that carries a fault requirement.
Illustrations show the label shifting with the facts. In Finger v. Omni Publications International, Ltd., a photograph of a large family illustrated a magazine report that fertilization rates might be enhanced by caffeine, with no real relationship between the picture and the article. The source treats liability as possible and observes that the claim could be considered false light and not commercial appropriation.33 The distinction lies in what the use does. An advertiser that puts a face on a product borrows the pull of that face, so its benefit comes from the identity. A magazine that drops a family photograph into an illustration slot takes little from the identity, while readers receive a false suggestion linking the family to the article’s subject. A claim built on the taking points toward § 652C, and a claim built on the false suggestion points toward § 652E.
Leverton v. Curtis Publishing Co. shows how one photograph can be safe in one use and actionable in another. A newspaper photographer photographed a child who had nearly been hit by a car, and the paper’s publication was a privileged invasion of privacy, because her interest in being left alone was outweighed by the public interest in being informed. Twenty months later a magazine used the photograph to illustrate an article on pedestrian carelessness titled “They Ask To Be Killed,” and the magazine publisher was held liable to the child.34 The privilege protected the news use, and it did not follow the photograph into the illustration.
Plaintiffs also pair privacy claims with torts outside the privacy family. In Cheatham, the plaintiff sued for invasion of privacy and intentional infliction of emotional distress, and the jury awarded $100,000 in compensatory damages and $100,000 in punitive damages.35 Pleading both lets the plaintiff win on whichever theory the proof satisfies. False light and defamation overlap in the same way, as the earlier treatment of false light explained: one false publication that damages reputation can support both. In Borg v. Cloutier, statements ran in the Athol Daily News and a definition appeared on a website, and the plaintiff, a selectman, then ran for reelection and lost.36 A lost election is the kind of consequence § 652H(c) calls special damage when the invasion is its legal cause.37
However many labels succeed, recovery tracks the harm. Section 652A(1) makes the invader liable for the resulting harm to the plaintiff’s interests,38 and § 652H compensates harm to the privacy interest, mental distress proved to have been suffered, and special damage the invasion legally causes.39 Those are harms, and a label is only a route to compensating them. One false article produces one reputational injury and one set of distress whether the court calls it defamation or false light, so a verdict that paid the injury under each label would pay twice for one wrong. Separate acts that cause separate injuries are different: the loss of seclusion when the watching occurs and the exposure from a later broadcast are distinct harms, each measured once. The measure polices double counting and leaves pleading open.
Overlap enlarges the list of claims but does not relax the limits attached to each. Constitutional limits can stand behind a correctly chosen branch whenever the facts involve a published account of real events, as the Cox question shows. The Supreme Court has also held unconstitutional statutes that allocated the profits a criminal makes from writing about his crime toward payment of victims.40
The instruction that has governed this chapter extends to overlap: name the branch the facts fit, apply its own elements and defenses, and repeat the exercise for every other branch an act supports. A student who finds one branch and stops has under-answered a hidden-camera-then-publish stem, and a student who adds damages under each label has over-answered it. The full-credit answer names every branch the facts fit, ties each to the act that supports it, and counts a single harm once.