Concept
Burden of Proving Privilege
Defenses and privileges to defamation
Burden of Proving Privilege
A defendant who claims a privilege must prove the facts that create it. In an action for defamation, the defendant has the burden of proving, when the issue is properly raised, the circumstances necessary for a privilege to publish the defamatory communication.1 The rule fits the nature of the defense. A privilege lets conduct that would otherwise be actionable escape liability because the defendant acted in furtherance of an interest of social importance, whether the defendant’s own, a third person’s, or the public’s.2 The party who asks for that excuse supplies the facts that earn it: who spoke, to whom, and in service of what interest or duty. The words properly raised mark when the burden attaches. It attaches once the defendant asserts the privilege and offers support for it, so a defendant who never claims a privilege, or who claims one without proving the circumstances of the occasion, gets no protection from it. At common law the allocation also deterred. A speaker who believed the statement privileged knew the privilege would still have to be proved, and that was reason to think twice before speaking.3
Proving the occasion is only the first of two stages, because most privileges are conditional. Prosser’s account of the two kinds shows why. When the interest at stake is of paramount importance, the immunity for false statements is absolute, without regard to purpose, motive, or reasonableness. When the interest carries less social weight, the immunity is qualified and depends on good motives and reasonable behavior, so the defendant’s belief in the truth of the statement, the purpose for which it was made, and the manner of publication may decide the case.4 An absolute privilege therefore leaves nothing to litigate about motive. A conditional privilege leaves open whether the defendant abused the occasion, and on that question the burden falls on the plaintiff, as the Pennsylvania statute discussed below provides.5
The two stages also divide the work between judge and jury. Whether the occasion was privileged is a question for the court as an issue of law, unless the facts are in dispute, in which case the jury is instructed on the proper rules to apply.6 Abuse is a different kind of question. Malice may be a jury question, and it is one unless only one conclusion can be drawn from the evidence. It becomes a question of law for the court only when the evidence and all inferences fairly deducible from it lead to conclusions from which reasonable minds could not differ.7 The jury’s role in libel is old. In 1735 a jury acquitted John Peter Zenger, whom New York’s governor had prosecuted for reporting the governor’s misdemeanors and who had spent nine months in prison awaiting trial.8
The Sindorf dispute shows what proof of an occasion involves. At the suggestion of Langton, president of Pennsylvania Jacron, Fridkis, a vice president of a Jacron subsidiary, telephoned Brose, president of Tool Box, to learn whether Sindorf had started working for Tool Box before leaving Jacron. The two men were competitors but friends, and they had held similar conversations about employees before. Fridkis learned that Sindorf had not gone to work for Tool Box until after he resigned from Jacron.9 Facts of this kind are what a defendant offers to establish an occasion: who proposed the call, how caller and listener were connected, and why the information was wanted. What the defendant believed about the truth of the statement and why he spoke belong to the plaintiff’s second stage.
Rosenbloom v. Metromedia, Inc. shows the same allocation in a statute and in a jury charge. The radio station, WIP, defended on truth and privilege.10 The Court recorded that Pennsylvania had enacted the Restatement’s burden-of-proof provisions verbatim, placing on the defendant the burden of proof for the affirmative defenses of truth and privilege.11 The statute, Pa. Stat. Ann. tit. 12, § 1584a, puts these matters on the plaintiff: the defamatory character of the communication, its publication by the defendant, its application to the plaintiff, the recipient’s understanding of its defamatory meaning and of its intended application to the plaintiff, special harm, and abuse of a conditionally privileged occasion.12
The jury charge followed that allocation. The judge told the jury that four findings were necessary for the plaintiff to win. A broadcast had to be defamatory, and a reasonable listener had to conclude that it referred to the plaintiff. WIP also had to have forfeited its privilege to report official proceedings fairly and accurately, either by intending to injure the plaintiff personally or by exercising the privilege unreasonably and without reasonable care. Finally, the reporting had to be false.13 The plaintiff carried the burden on the first three findings, while the defendant carried the burden of proving that the reporting was true.14 The charge thus treated the two defenses differently. Truth, though submitted to the jury as a finding, stayed with the defendant. On privilege, the plaintiff had to show forfeiture, so the plaintiff carried the abuse stage whichever test of abuse the state used.
Students most often lose points here by giving the whole privilege inquiry to one party. A student who makes the defendant prove every part of the privilege, including the absence of abuse, skips the plaintiff’s stage. A student who requires the plaintiff to negate the occasion at the outset reverses the first stage, except in the jurisdictions described next.
The Restatement allocation is the default, but two things can change it. First, a few states allocate differently. West Virginia, for example, treats the absence of a privilege as part of the plaintiff’s case, which puts on the plaintiff the burden of negating the privilege and takes from the defendant the burden of establishing it.15 Second, the constitutional cases required that privileges be revisited.16 States remain free to apply the old strict liability standard and related rules where no public official, public figure, or matter of public interest is involved, though many now require negligence, and there is a new allocation of the burden of proof regarding falsity.17 Unless a problem names a jurisdiction or a constitutional setting that points the other way, answer with the Restatement allocation.