Concept
Failure to Remove Defamation
Publication, republication, and the single publication rule
Failure to Remove Defamation
Publication ordinarily means that the defendant communicated the matter, but Restatement (Second) of Torts § 577(2) also reaches a possessor who communicated nothing. One who intentionally and unreasonably fails to remove defamatory matter that he knows is exhibited on land or chattels in his possession or under his control is subject to liability for its continued publication.1 That person need not have written the matter or put it there. His fault is that he held the means of ending the display, learned what it said, and left it standing. Three conditions must all be present: knowledge of the matter, possession or control of the land or chattel where it is exhibited, and a failure to remove it that is both intentional and unreasonable.
Each condition does separate work. Knowledge comes first, because a possessor cannot intentionally decline to remove what he has never seen; until he learns what the matter says, the rule leaves him alone. Control comes next, because only someone with power over the wall or object can choose to leave the matter up. A passerby who reads a defamatory scrawl on a stranger's fence knows of it but cannot take it down. Reasonableness measures what the possessor did against what he could have done, and it gives him a fair interval to react once he knows. A possessor who can end the harm at little cost and lets it continue is deciding, hour after hour, that readers should keep seeing the matter. That decision is his own publication, distinct from the writer's.
The Restatement's illustration shows how the conditions line up in time. A writes on the wall of the men's washroom in B's tavern that C is an unchaste woman. B does not discover the writing for an hour. After he discovers it, he fails to remove it for another hour although he has ample opportunity to do so, and several men read it during that second hour. B is subject to liability for the continued publication of the libel during the second hour, although not for the original publication.2 The opinion in Boston v. Athearn quotes the illustration, noting that it is the only one the drafters gave and that it concerns a communication exhibited in the physical realm.3 A made the original publication and answers for it. B's liability begins only when he knew of the writing and had a reasonable chance to act, so the first hour, when he knew nothing, falls outside it. The unit of liability is therefore the period after a reasonable opportunity to remove, not the posting itself, and holding B answerable for the whole run of the writing would charge him with A's act.
Hellar v. Bianco applied the same reasoning to a bar. Remarks about the plaintiff's sexual activity, together with her home phone number, had been written on the restroom wall, and liability rested on the owner's failure to remove the writing promptly after learning its content, even though he did not originate it.4 His knowledge and control carried the result; authorship did not matter. Tacket v. General Motors Corp. approached the problem through adoption. It grounded liability on the idea that the defendant implicitly adopted the defamatory statement, and it held that adoption could not be found without a significant time in which to remove the material.5 That limit matches the reasonableness condition, because a possessor who has had only a moment to react has not yet chosen anything.
Online content raises the same question in a new setting, and the later sections on internet intermediaries and republication take it up. The washroom illustration concerns a communication exhibited in the physical realm,6 and the rule's text speaks of land and chattels. Applying it to a website, page, or comment thread is therefore an extension by analogy. The analogy has an obvious pull: a person who knows what a post says, can delete it at little cost, and leaves it up appears to be choosing its continued publication. Whether other doctrines shield an online host from that liability is a separate question for later.