Concept
Compensatory Damages
Remedies: damages and injunction
Compensatory Damages
Compensatory damages, measured by the character and extent of the injury to the plaintiff's property interest, are always recoverable in a nuisance action, and every award must answer one practical question: how much of the owner's harm can a single judgment fairly price?1 The Restatement (Second) of Torts lists what shapes the answer: the nature of the interests harmed, the rules governing the measure of damages, the availability and persuasiveness of evidence bearing on the assessment of damages, and, for repeated or continuing torts, the cost of a multiplicity of suits.2 That list formally tests when damages are an adequate substitute for an injunction. It also names the problems every damage award has to solve, because the harm must be turned into a dollar figure that evidence can support, and the harm may keep happening after judgment.
Some nuisances come and go, or may end soon, or will last for a period no one can predict, so their harm is fully known only as it occurs. For those, a court compensates what has already happened and leaves later harm to be measured when it arrives. Other nuisances will probably last indefinitely, and making the owner sue year after year over a harm that is practically certain to recur would impose the cost of a multiplicity of suits that the Restatement counts against the adequacy of damages.3 In that case the court can price the whole stream of harm at once. The measure of damages therefore depends on a prior classification of the nuisance as temporary or permanent, and that classification fixes both what the plaintiff recovers and how many suits the plaintiff must bring.
Temporary Nuisance Damages
When it is not clear whether the harm will continue, the plaintiff can usually recover only for damage sustained up to the time of suit and must bring successive actions for later harm.4 Those later suits are for actual, not prospective, losses.5 Compensatory damages remain available throughout, so the temporary label governs how much of the harm one judgment will price: the harm that has already happened.
The rule spares the court a forecast it cannot make reliably. When no one knows how long the harm will last, a figure for later years is a guess written into a final judgment. If the guess is too high, the owner is overpaid when the nuisance ends soon. If it is too low, the owner cannot reopen the case when the nuisance lingers. Awarding only accrued loss rests every dollar on harm the evidence can show, and a later suit measures later harm when it arrives.
Had the operator been certain to run the plant unchanged for decades, the harm would have been treated as permanent. Past and prospective loss would then have been recovered together in a single action, the measure the next subsection takes up.6
Where the nuisance is abatable, the temporary damage award is the loss in rental value.7 The usual measure of loss of use is the reduction in the land's rental value while the nuisance lasts.8 Courts apply it to the period of actual interference rather than to some longer period. One court calculated damages on ninety days of interference, the length of the harvest season in which the nuisance occurred. Another measured the loss over the actual time of interference instead of the entire rental season.9
What the owner recovers beyond rental value depends on whether the harm ends when the defendant's conduct ends. Noise stops when the activity stops, and then the plaintiff has nothing to repair, so recovery ends with the loss of use. Toxic contamination of groundwater or land is different, because the harm does not terminate when the defendant stops dumping. The plaintiff is entitled to have the land restored if that is feasible, and if the defendant does not restore it, the plaintiff recovers the cost of doing so in addition to diminished rental value for the period until the cleanup is completed.10
Restoration can be difficult and costly, so many courts limit recovery to the depreciated value of the land, which avoids economic waste. The rule of avoidable consequences adds a second check: the injured party must diminish the loss as reasonably as possible.11
Two further heads of recovery complete the temporary-nuisance award. Rental value is a market figure, and an owner who lives with the interference experiences it in ways the market figure may miss. One court allowed damages for inconvenience and lost quality of life when drinking water was polluted, and for the cost of medical check-ups to monitor cancer risk, but refused damages for fear of future harm. Another allowed quality-of-life damages in a public nuisance claim. Damages for annoyance and mental anguish, however, are not the same as damages for emotional distress.12 If the defendant acts with malice, a court may also allow punitive damages.13
The temporary label keeps the door open to an injunction because the two remedies do not overlap. Damages for temporary harm compensate the past interference, and an injunction prohibits future conduct, so granting both produces no double recovery.14 A plaintiff may seek an injunction where the legal remedy is inadequate.15 An exam stem that gives the owner only accrued damages while the defendant keeps operating therefore leaves the injunction question open.
Permanent Nuisance Damages
Damages for permanent harm to land equal the diminution in the property's value: the difference between its fair market value immediately before and immediately after the injury. That figure takes into account the land's past and future diminished productivity.18 When the nuisance will probably be a permanent one, a polluting factory likely to stay in business for example, the plaintiff can and must recover all damages, past and prospective, in one action.19 The plaintiff may join claims for past and prospective injury in a single cause of action, measured by the difference between market value with and without the nuisance.20
Market value can stand in for all future harm because it already reflects the future diminished productivity of the land. A buyer pays less for a parcel beside a plant that will keep running, and that reduction expresses the whole stream of later harm as a present sum. The court need not forecast the loss year by year. The one-action rule also answers the concern with a multiplicity of suits: when harm is likely to continue, annual suits would relitigate a question the first judgment can already settle.21
Boomer v. Atlantic Cement Co. shows permanent damages in a decided case. The defendant's cement plant constantly produced high levels of cement dust that clogged the neighbors' homes. The plant employed 300 people and represented a $45 million investment, while the total damage to the neighbors was $185,000.22 The court found a nuisance but, after balancing the plant's benefits to the community against the plaintiffs' damage, denied the injunction and awarded permanent damages instead.23 The decision is highly controversial, but it shows how courts weigh whether to award an injunction.24 A later section takes up why the court preferred that outcome. For present purposes, a plant that would keep operating produced a once-and-for-all payment rather than a yearly accounting.
Classification takes judgment, because the facts do not always announce their category. A factory whose odors come intermittently and might stop if a filter is installed presents the opposite picture from the cement plant. It is not clear that the harm will continue, so the owners recover for losses to date and may sue again for later harm.25 Continuing pollution may also be seen as a series of separate temporary harms, in which case each invasion supports its own claim.26
The label decides more than the size of the award, because it affects the statute of limitations. If the continuing pollution is treated as separate temporary harms, the limitations period runs from each invasion. A permanent harm is a single wrong, so the landowner might be completely barred. Suppose pollution continued for ten years before the owner sued and the tort limitations period is two years. A permanent classification might bar recovery entirely. A temporary classification would bar damages for the first eight years but leave the last two recoverable.27 A plaintiff who waited ten years therefore has every reason to argue that the harm was temporary, and the defendant has every reason to argue that it was permanent.
The permanent label also bears on injunctions. If the injury is classified as permanent, courts will not issue a preventive injunction against the interference. The owner is already being compensated for future harm through the diminution-in-value measure, and an order abating that harm would duplicate the payment and overcompensate the plaintiff.28 Temporary harm sits differently, since damages cover the past and an injunction reaches only the future. The classifications thus sort the remedial package: temporary harm supports accrued damages and a possible injunction, while permanent harm supports one lump award that has already paid for the future. An exam stem in which the owner recovers diminution in value and also asks to enjoin the same future interference describes double compensation.