Concept
Opportunity to Avoid Harm
Last clear chance (exception to the contributory negligence bar)
Opportunity to Avoid Harm
A defendant who knows the plaintiff is in danger has not yet had a last clear chance; the defendant must also have been able to do something about it. Both categories of the doctrine end on that requirement, and the Restatement (Second) of Torts states it in nearly identical words in two places. Under § 479(b), the defendant must be “negligent in failing to utilize with reasonable care and competence his then existing opportunity to avoid the harm” once the knowledge conditions of that section are met. Under § 480(c), the defendant “thereafter is negligent in failing to utilize with reasonable care and competence his then existing opportunity to avoid the harm.”1 The knowledge conditions differ because the two kinds of plaintiff differ, but all of them lead to this final question, so it is taught once for both.
Three phrases in the shared text each limit the element. “Then existing” ties the opportunity to a particular moment, the one at which the defendant's knowledge is complete, and § 480(c) marks that moment with the word “thereafter.” Time that passed before the defendant had the required knowledge does not count. A defendant who grasps the danger with too little distance left has therefore satisfied the knowledge conditions and still lacks an opportunity. “Reasonable care and competence” sets the measure: the question is what an actor of ordinary skill, using the time and means actually at hand, would have accomplished, not what a perfect actor could have done. “Avoid the harm” requires that the available means would have worked. A warning that could not have been heard in time, or brakes that could not have stopped the vehicle in the distance remaining, avoid nothing.
The opinion in Thomas explains why the element closes the doctrine. Last clear chance presupposes the defendant's primary negligence, the plaintiff's contributory negligence, and “something new or independent” that gives the defendant “a fresh opportunity to avert the consequences.”2 The opportunity element is where that new factor appears. It also keeps the defendant's fault later in time than the plaintiff's. Without a later chance, the two careless acts run side by side, the case is the ordinary contributory negligence case, and where contributory negligence is a complete bar to recovery, the plaintiff recovers nothing. A defendant with no time or no means to act could not have changed what happened.
A plaintiff who invokes the doctrine must name the means. In one case the plaintiff answered the contributory negligence defense by alleging that the defendant's servant had the last clear chance to avoid injury either by braking or by promptly sounding a warning whistle.3 Braking and warning are the kind of means that count: acts the defendant could perform and that, performed in time, would have prevented the injury. The trial court nonetheless gave judgment for the defendant, so the allegation shows what an opportunity looks like, not that the claim succeeded.4
Missing means defeated the claim in Penn Harris Madison School Corp. v. Howard. A student who had designed a rig for Peter Pan to fly in a school play was injured while testing it during rehearsal, after he jumped from a ladder. Indiana retains contributory negligence in cases against governmental entities, but the court held that last clear chance did not apply: nothing in the record showed that the school could have done anything to avert or prevent the injuries after the student put himself in danger.5 Between them, Thomas and Penn Harris mark the two questions the element asks: was there a later chance, and did the defendant have a way to use it?
The driver in the hypothetical had the knowledge and lacked the chance, which is why the knowledge conditions and the opportunity element must be kept apart. Distance alone is not an opportunity either. The element asks whether the defendant could use the distance with reasonable care and competence, and a driver who loses consciousness a moment after seeing the danger has distance but no way to turn it into a stop. Students often slide from “the defendant could have avoided the accident” to “the defendant had a last clear chance,” but nearly every accident looks avoidable in hindsight. The rule asks what means were then available to this defendant, at the moment the knowledge conditions were met, and whether using them with ordinary competence would have prevented the harm.