Concept
The Hirer's Exposure
Indemnity between the hirer and the contractor
Indemnity From the Contractor
The Hirer's Exposure
A hirer usually expects an independent contractor's carelessness to remain the contractor's problem, and that expectation is usually right. An independent contractor is engaged to perform services for another but stays independent of that person's own workforce. The contractor is typically paid to accomplish a result and left to choose the means, although the label can hold even when the hirer exercises significant control over how and when the work is done.1 The hirer is ordinarily not answerable for such a contractor's torts, but it can be reached in three ways, and the first two require no fault on its part.2
The first is a nondelegable duty. When a special relation to the public or to the plaintiff creates a duty of enough importance, the obligor cannot escape responsibility for its proper performance by hiring a contractor. A hirer who does hire one is vicariously liable for physical harm caused by the contractor's negligence, even though the hirer was entirely without fault.3 Vicarious liability, in other words, makes the hirer answer for the contractor's negligence without any wrongdoing of its own. A building owner whose contractor lifts heavy objects with a crane above a sidewalk illustrates the point: the risk to passersby is obvious unless special precautions are taken, so the duty is likely nondelegable.4
The second is inherently dangerous activity. A principal can be held liable where the contractor's performance involves one.5 In Majestic Realty Associates v. Toti Contracting Co., the Parking Authority of the City of Paterson hired Toti Contracting to demolish a building next to one owned by Majestic Realty. A wrecking ball operated by a Toti employee knocked a section of wall onto Majestic's roof and caused extensive damage; the employee's own explanation was, "I goofed." Majestic sued the Authority.6 The Authority never swung the ball. Whatever liability it faces rests on the nature of the work it commissioned, not on anything its own people did.
Both vicarious routes stop at the risks that create them. The hirer's vicarious liability is limited to the particular risks that give rise to the exception, and it does not reach a collateral risk, one that is not inherent and foreseeable in the dangerous activity. A bricklayer who negligently drops a brick on a passerby or negligently builds a wall exposes the hirer; the same bricklayer driving negligently to the brickyard does not.7
The third route is the hirer's own negligence. Apart from any rule of vicarious liability, the hirer of an independent contractor is liable under ordinary negligence principles for its own carelessness in dealing with the contractor. It must use reasonable care to select a reasonably competent, experienced, careful, and properly equipped one. When the work creates a foreseeable danger to third persons, ordinary care may require the hirer to insist, in the contract or otherwise, on the necessary safety precautions and then to see that the contractor takes them. Reasonable care may also call for inspection of completed work.8 The more dangerous the activity, the more care the choice demands, and liability follows directly from the lack of care, not vicariously from the relationship.9
The injured plaintiff is not confined to the hirer. A nondelegable duty adds the hirer as a defendant without removing the contractor: just as respondeat superior does not bar suit against a negligent employee, an owner's vicarious liability does not stop the plaintiff from suing the contractor for its negligence. It means only that the owner is liable as well, so the contractor cannot defend by pointing out that the duty is nondelegable.10 Nor is the doctrine strict liability. It still requires a negligently caused harm. What it assures is that the person whose activity caused the harm, and who may properly answer for the negligence of an employee or an independent contractor, compensates the injured party, and by helping supply a financially responsible defendant it lessens the need for strict liability to secure compensation.11 The nondelegable-duty cases, Maloney v. Rath among them, rest on this compensation rationale.
A broad reading of the exception carries a price. It can misallocate the burdens and costs of doing business, because the costs fall on the customers of the contractor's business rather than on the business itself. Indemnity against the contractor is available, but litigation costs, among others, would be imposed unfairly on the party that engaged the contractor.12
The difference between the two scenes governs the rest of this chapter. In the first, Tracy's liability is entirely derivative of the contractor's tort. In the second, part of what Tracy owes is derivative and part is its own fault. The distinction matters because indemnity responds to liability that arises from the contractor's negligence.
A hirer in Tracy's first position has that remedy. Because its liability arises from Hepburn's negligence, Tracy is entitled to indemnity from Hepburn if it pays the judgment, while Hepburn has no right to contribution or indemnity from Tracy.13 A hirer is much more likely to pursue indemnity against a contractor than an employer is against an employee, because a contractor is more likely to have adequate resources and insurance to cover the loss. The law does not generally require a hirer to inquire into a contractor's solvency or insurance coverage,14 but Tracy's lawyer should write into the contract a clause requiring evidence that Hepburn is fully insured, so that the right of indemnity protects the client from absorbing losses caused by Hepburn's negligence.15 The sections that follow ask when indemnity is available and how far it reaches.