Concept
Keeping Contractor Liability Separate
Duty to control the conduct of others on one's land or chattels
Keeping Contractor Liability Separate
Section 318 of the Restatement (Second) of Torts reaches a possessor who permits a third person to use land or chattels in the possessor's possession otherwise than as a servant. If present, the possessor must use reasonable care to control the permitted user, but only when the possessor knows or has reason to know of the ability to control and knows or should know of the necessity and opportunity for control.1 The law of independent contractors can also make a person who holds land answer for harm that someone else caused there, and the two bodies of law are easy to confuse. They ask different questions. Section 318 asks whether a possessor had to restrain someone using the property; the answer turns on the possessor's power over that use and on what the possessor knew. The contractor rules ask when a hirer must answer for the work of someone engaged to do a job; the answer turns on the hirer's benefit from the work, the hirer's ability to select and supervise the worker, and public-policy limits on handing off certain duties. This chapter marks only the boundary, because the course teaches the contractor rules in full elsewhere.
An exam stem sorts these cases with one question: whose work, or whose purposes, was the third person serving when the harm occurred? A person using the possessor's garage, boat, or house for his own ends, with permission, is a permitted user, and the § 318 conditions taught earlier in this chapter apply. A person on the property to do a job the possessor engaged him to do falls under the contractor rules, even though he is also there with the possessor's consent. The two frameworks draw responsibility from different sources. Section 318 draws its duty from possession and permission: the possessor chose to let another use what the possessor holds. The contractor rules draw responsibility from the hirer's relation to the work. In Maloney, a California decision about a car owner whose brakes failed after a mechanic's negligent overhaul, the court reasoned that the owner is the party primarily benefited by the vehicle's use, selects the contractor, is free to insist on a financially responsible one and to demand indemnity, and bears an insurance cost properly attributable to the activity.2 Each of those reasons concerns benefit and choice. None depends on whether the hirer was present or could have stopped the worker, and that is why § 318's conditions of presence and ability to control do not decide a contractor case.
The contractor rules reach a hirer by more than one route. First, the independent contractor rule does not relieve a hirer of liability for the hirer's own negligence, as when the hirer carelessly chooses an incompetent and dangerous contractor or fails to exercise appropriate supervision and control.3 Second, the law imposes nondelegable duties, responsibilities that a person cannot hand to a contractor and then escape. In Maloney the owner's duty to maintain her brakes in compliance with the vehicle code was nondelegable, so the mechanic's negligence was no defense for the owner.4 Courts have no clean criterion for deciding which duties are delegable; the decisions rest on public-policy judgments about how important the duty is.5 Treat the contractor rules, then, as a family of routes to the hirer, whose detail belongs to the part of the course devoted to them.
The two frameworks meet where the hirer is also the landowner, because the possession that powers § 318 is the same fact that puts a contractor's work on the hirer's land. A landowner who retains possession of the land, or otherwise retains a degree of control, must exercise that control with reasonable care for the safety of others. An owner who actively directs a contractor's dangerous work on the land may be liable for his own negligence, quite apart from any vicarious liability or nondelegable duty.6 That liability rests on how the owner handled the control he kept. Retained control can also bear on vicarious liability itself, since to the extent the owner keeps control, the supposed contractor looks more like a servant.7 A contractor who does the owner's job by day and borrows the owner's equipment for a personal project at night presents two questions, and each takes its own framework: the day's work goes to the contractor rules, and the personal project goes to § 318.