Concept
Other Nondelegable Duties
Nondelegable duties and inherently dangerous work exceptions
Other Nondelegable Duties
The Restatement sections covered so far describe the best-known occasions on which a hirer answers for a contractor's negligence, but they do not mark the outer edge of the doctrine. Courts also hold hirers liable when the duty at stake is one the hirer may not hand off, and the earlier discussion explained what that label does. The harder question is how a court decides that a duty qualifies when no Restatement section says so. Statutes answer part of it, and policy judgments about duties too important to transfer answer the rest. No single test captures either.
Duties Imposed by Statute
Maloney v. Rath shows a statute producing a nondelegable duty. California's Vehicle Code required an owner to keep her brakes in proper working order. A mechanic negligently overhauled or inspected hers, the brakes failed, and the court held that the owner answered for the mechanic's negligence. It tied its result to two Restatement provisions. Section 423 makes one who carries on an activity threatening a grave risk of serious bodily harm unless the instrumentalities are carefully maintained liable for a contractor's negligent maintenance as though the employer had done the work. Section 424 makes one who must provide specified safeguards by statute or administrative regulation liable, to those the duty protects, for a contractor's failure to provide them.1
The court read the motor-vehicle statutes as legislative recognition that a badly maintained vehicle threatens grave risk of serious bodily harm or death, and it placed responsibility for that risk on the person who owns and operates the vehicle. That person benefits most from the vehicle's use, picks the mechanic, can insist on a financially responsible one and demand indemnity, and bears a cost of liability insurance that fairly belongs to the activity of driving.2 The statute made the owner answer for a contractor's carelessness. It did not make her an insurer of every brake failure, because her liability rested on the mechanic's negligent work.3
A statute does not always have that effect, so it begins the analysis and does not end it. The Restatement retains vicarious liability for hirers in eight situations, among them abnormally dangerous activity, peculiar-risk work, and precautions required by statute or regulation, but the contours of these exceptions vary among jurisdictions.4 Some courts have gone further and treated a statutory command as creating a nondelegable duty: a creditor who hires a contractor to repossess a debtor's car is liable when the contractor breaches the peace.5 Others refuse to make a duty nondelegable merely because a statute imposes it. A traveler who hires a cab to reach the airport has engaged an independent contractor, yet is highly unlikely to answer to a pedestrian when the driver violates a traffic ordinance.6 The results follow the policy behind each relationship. The lender is pursuing its own enterprise, and breaches of the peace are a predictable hazard of enforcing a security interest by repossession. The passenger is buying a ride, and nothing in that purchase ties the driver's violation to an enterprise of the passenger's.7
A decision involving a telephone company shows how thin the reasoning for a statutory duty can be. A state statute required the utility to obtain written permission from local and state officials before digging ditches to install cables, and a pedestrian fell into a ditch dug by a contractor the company had hired. The court held that the company “had an affirmative, non-delegable duty to take precautions against the possible and probable injuries around an excavation site constructed through its franchise or permission obtained from the state and local authority,” although its rationale was neither detailed nor especially persuasive.8 The same pedestrian could point instead to the public-place rule taught earlier, which looks to the contractor's work and the dangerous physical condition it creates. An excavation in a public way fits that rule, and the rule does not depend on a statutory permit.9
Duties Too Important to Transfer
A duty can be nondelegable without any statute when its careful performance matters so much to the community or to the plaintiff that the obligor should not be allowed to hand it off. Kleeman v. Rheingold is the standard example. A law firm hired an outside agency to serve process for a client, the agency performed negligently, and the New York Court of Appeals held that lawyers have a nondelegable duty to see that process is validly served. A lawyer therefore cannot avoid responsibility for a process server's negligence by hiring an independent contractor.10 The court's formula was that a duty is nondelegable when “the responsibility is so important to the community that the employer should not be permitted to transfer it to another.”11
The court gave several reasons. The professional rules bar a lawyer from limiting malpractice liability to a client by contract or otherwise.12 The public does not necessarily know that lawyers retain outside agencies, and even a client told that an agency will be used is unlikely to understand that the agency's status as an independent contractor could leave the lawyer immune. A client's reasonable expectations about who will perform a service therefore weigh heavily in deciding whether a duty can be delegated.13 Finally, the responsibility for timely commencement of legal actions, and the liability for failing to achieve it, “must remain squarely on the shoulders of trained and licensed attorneys” who, as members of a learned profession, alone have the knowledge and experience to protect their clients' rights.14
A concurring judge in Kleeman would have decided the case without the doctrine. The concurrence argued that the majority's rule requires lawyers to look beyond a facially sufficient affidavit of service and verify the facts behind it, gives lawyers an incentive to serve process themselves or supervise their servers closely instead of relying on outside specialists, favors large firms with in-house servers over small firms and solo practitioners, and reaches past service of process to matters such as choosing expert witnesses.15 Those objections mark the difference between two routes to the hirer. Ordinarily a lawyer is not liable for the conduct of independent contractors she retains, and liability arises when the contractor performs a nondelegable duty.16 A claim for negligent selection or supervision reaches the lawyer on the ordinary basis, but it requires the client to prove the lawyer's own fault, which a nondelegable duty makes unnecessary.
No General Test
No general definition or test tells a court which duties are nondelegable. One leading statement says the list of such duties is long, that they may be imposed by law (statutory or common), contract, franchise, or charter, and that what they seem to share is a substantial underlying safety purpose. Its examples are the duties a common carrier owes its passengers, a municipality's duty to keep its streets in repair, the duties a landowner or possessor owes lessees and business visitors, an employer's duty to provide a safe place to work, a lessor's or bailor's duty to keep a chattel reasonably safe, a car owner's duty to maintain adequate brakes, and the duty of one who deals with highly dangerous instrumentalities, such as a power company's duty to maintain its wires.18 Commentary on Kleeman reaches the same conclusion: whether a duty is nondelegable is a sui generis inquiry that ultimately rests on policy, and no court has yet devised a clear and concise statement of when a duty qualifies. The same commentary adds that courts should be loath to expand the exception if it is not to swallow the rule.19
Hospital emergency rooms show the same considerations producing opposite results. The Alaska Supreme Court held in Jackson v. Power that a general acute care hospital's duty to provide emergency room care is nondelegable, so the hospital answered for an independent physician working there. The Texas Supreme Court in Baptist Memorial Hospital System v. Sampson declined to find a nondelegable duty for emergency room care.20
These steps are arguments, not elements. A strong showing on several can carry a duty that is weak on the rest, and two courts can weigh them differently, as the hospital cases show.
Keeping the Category Narrow
Courts keep the category narrow because the insulation rule would otherwise disappear. Read broadly, the doctrine could swallow the principle of nonliability for an independent contractor's conduct by declaring every duty of care nondelegable. A homeowner who hired an independent, professional tree service would then answer for a trimmer who dropped a limb onto a neighbor's car, although she had no means of protecting herself by exerting detailed control over the work. Such extraordinary strict liability should be confined to narrow and unusual circumstances.26
The car owner in Maloney and the homeowner with the tree service land on opposite sides of the line. The owner's duty came from statutes aimed at a grave public risk, and she operated the dangerous instrument and benefited from it. The homeowner has no statute, no invitation to the public, and no special relationship to the neighbor, only an ordinary chore that a skilled contractor performs. The doctrine is often invoked when a duty originates in a contract, a statute or administrative regulation, or an invitation to the public, such as opening premises, and the homeowner's duty has none of those origins.27