Concept
Work in Public Places
Nondelegable duties and inherently dangerous work exceptions
Work in Public Places
A hirer that sends an independent contractor to work in a public place cannot hand off the danger that the work creates for the people using that place. The Restatement (Second) of Torts makes one who employs an independent contractor to do work in a public place liable when that work, unless carefully done, involves a risk of making the physical condition of the place dangerous for public use. The liability covers physical harm to members of the public caused by a negligent act or omission of the contractor that makes the place dangerous for their use.1 The rule has four parts: a public place, work that carries that risk if not carefully done, a negligent act or omission by the contractor, and a dangerous physical condition of the place that causes the harm. The hirer answers for the contractor's negligence, which makes this rule one more nondelegable duty of the kind described earlier in this chapter. The hirer may delegate the work, but it cannot delegate its liability to the public.
Three reasons support treating work in public places this way. The first is the scale of the danger: vicarious liability in these cases is presumably based on the wide risk that work in public places creates and the obvious need for particular care to protect the public from injury.2 The second is a policy against delegation. A public authority may not delegate to an independent contractor its responsibility to see that work in a public place is done carefully, and a court that held the owner and operator of an airport terminal could not delegate its duty to keep the facility safe described a general tort policy against letting an entity shift by contract its responsibility for keeping an area used by the public in a safe condition.3 The third is efficiency. Highway work calls for precautions such as barricades, signs, and flagmen that the principal can observe cheaply, and vicarious liability is clearly the efficient rule for accidents that happen because those precautions are missing.4
The inherently dangerous activity exception, which overlaps with this rule, reasons the same way. It holds one who engages another to do work that will create some peculiar risk of injury to others unless special precautions are taken vicariously liable for the contractor's negligence, and its stock example is excavation in or near a public highway. The policy is that special responsibilities go with starting an activity that is dangerous to the community, even when the employer does not control the details.5
A pedestrian who falls into an excavation suffers the harm that the public-place rule describes. In one case a pedestrian fell into a ditch dug by a contractor for a telephone company, and the court held that the company had an affirmative, nondelegable duty to take precautions around the excavation. That court reached its result through a state statute requiring the company to obtain permission from local and state officials before digging, and the treatise that reports the case calls its rationale neither detailed nor especially persuasive.6 The streets themselves carry a similar duty. A municipality's duty to keep its streets in repair appears among the recognized nondelegable duties.7
The rule reaches any hirer of an independent contractor, not only a governmental one. The public-authority cases illustrate the policy, but the rule's words are "one who employs an independent contractor."8 The worker's status still matters, and a hirer does not turn a contractor into a servant merely by setting standards for the job. In Murrell v. Goertz, a newspaper publisher's policies and standards for its distributors and carriers did not rise to the level of supervision, dominion, and control over day-to-day activities that would make a carrier its servant.9
Sections 413 and 416, taught above, start from a different premise: work that the hirer should recognize as likely to create a peculiar risk of physical harm to others unless special precautions are taken.10 Section 416 holds the hirer liable for the contractor's failure to use reasonable care to take those precautions, even though the hirer provided for them in the contract or otherwise.11 The public-place rule asks whether work in a public place, unless carefully done, involves a risk of making the place's physical condition dangerous for public use. Its text does not ask whether the risk is peculiar.12 The two rules can overlap, because excavation in or near a public highway is the classic peculiar-risk example, and a roadside trench may support a claim under either.13 The public-place rule, however, does not require the added showing of peculiarity.
Private land is a separate matter when its possessor holds it open to the public. A possessor who holds land open to the public for any purpose is liable to entrants for failing to use reasonable care to protect them against unreasonably dangerous activities of, or conditions created by, an independent contractor or concessionaire working or operating on the land. That rule is the subject of the next unit.14
Two of the four parts confine the hirer's liability. The contractor must have committed a negligent act or omission, so the hirer is not an insurer against every accident near the work. The negligence must also make the physical condition of the place dangerous for public use, and that requirement anticipates the collateral-negligence limit developed later in this chapter. Under that limit, the employer is not liable where the contractor's negligence creates a collateral risk, one that is not inherent and foreseeable in the dangerous activity that creates the employer's liability. A bricklayer who negligently drops a brick onto a passerby creates a risk of the kind the work carries, while one who negligently drives a truck to the brickyard does not.15
The exact contours of these exceptions vary from one jurisdiction to another. The Restatement Third hinges direct liability for work entrusted to an independent contractor on retained control, and it keeps vicarious liability for hirers in a list of eight situations that includes abnormally dangerous activities, activities posing a peculiar risk, and precautions required by statute or regulation.16 A student should confirm which formulation the governing jurisdiction follows before relying on any single section.
The first two questions concern the setting and the kind of work, facts the hirer fixes when it arranges the job. The last two concern what the contractor did and what that conduct caused. The hirer's own care in selecting or instructing the contractor is not one of the four elements, because liability here rests on the contractor's negligence. A hirer's own failure to provide for precautions is a different claim, governed by § 413, which was taught above.17