Concept
What Nondelegable Means
Nondelegable duties and inherently dangerous work exceptions
What Nondelegable Means
The phrase "nondelegable duty" is something of a misnomer. The owner in these cases has delegated the work to an independent contractor, and the law permits that. What the law will not let the owner delegate is the liability: the owner answers vicariously for the contractor's torts committed in the course of the work, as an employer answers under respondeat superior.1 The owner answers for the contractor's negligence even when the owner was entirely without fault.2
The worker in a nondelegable-duty case is an independent contractor rather than a servant, and Murrell v. Goertz shows how a court draws that line. A newspaper publisher set policies and standards that all its distributors and carriers had to follow, but the Oklahoma Court of Appeals concluded that those policies did not rise to the supervision, dominion, and control over the collector's day-to-day activities that would make him the publisher's servant.3 When the collector allegedly assaulted a subscriber, the trial court granted the publisher summary judgment.4 Without servant status, respondeat superior was unavailable against the publisher, which leaves exceptions such as the nondelegable duty as the route to a hirer's liability.
The reason for the exception is an incentive problem. If a hirer could shed liability by delegating, the hirer would have an enormous incentive to delegate to an insolvent contractor, and the injured person would be left with a claim worth nothing. The same reasoning bars a party from escaping liability for negligent performance of a contractual obligation by handing the performance to an independent contractor, and it parallels the rule that a principal cannot escape liability for ultrahazardous or abnormally dangerous activities by hiring someone else.5
The doctrine must stay narrow, because ordinary expectations run the other way. A hirer who engages a carpenter to repair a shop ceiling or a plumber to install the plumbing in a hotel is entitled to assume that a contractor of good reputation will do the work safely. The hirer need not take great pains to investigate the contractor, and the contractor's trade is enough unless the hirer knows the reputation is bad or knows facts that should lead it to realize the contractor is not competent.6 If every duty were nondelegable, that baseline would vanish and every hirer would answer for every contractor's negligence. The sections that follow identify which duties qualify, and this section concerns what follows once a duty does.
Four consequences follow once a duty is nondelegable. The first is that the contractor stays liable. Respondeat superior does not bar a suit against a negligent employee, and a nondelegable duty likewise adds the owner as a defendant without removing the contractor. The contractor therefore cannot defend by pointing to the owner's duty.7
The second consequence concerns what the two defendants can claim from each other. The owner's liability exists only because of the contractor's negligence, so an owner who pays the judgment is entitled to indemnity, meaning full reimbursement, from the contractor. The contractor has no claim for contribution, a sharing of the loss among wrongdoers, and no claim for indemnity against the owner, who is not a joint tortfeasor or any other kind of tortfeasor and is liable only for damages the contractor's tort caused.8 An owner is much more likely to pursue indemnity against a contractor than against a negligent employee, because a contractor is more likely to have the resources and insurance to cover the loss. A careful owner's lawyer will therefore write into the contract a clause requiring evidence that the contractor is fully insured.9
The third consequence marks the limit of the doctrine: the owner answers for the contractor's tort, and the owner does not answer for an accident that was nobody's tort.
Declaring a duty nondelegable therefore makes the owner liable for the contractor's tortious conduct, and it does not make the owner strictly liable for every accident that occurs in the course of the work.10 The Restatement (Second) formulation of the peculiar-risk rule builds that limit into its text. It subjects the hirer to liability for physical harm caused by the contractor's failure to exercise reasonable care to take the special precautions, even though the hirer provided for those precautions in the contract or otherwise.11 That provision is taught in detail below, and for now it shows that a negligent contractor is where the hirer's liability begins.
The fourth point is that not every court classifies the liability as vicarious. In Saiz v. Belen School District, the New Mexico court held that when an employer hires an independent contractor to do work the law recognizes as likely to create a peculiar risk of harm, the employer is directly responsible if reasonable precautions are not taken. That liability is direct, not vicarious, and proof of the contractor's negligence is not an essential element of it.12 The inquiry asks whether the precautions that a person knowing all the circumstances would deem reasonably necessary were present, and it does not ask whether the contractor's failure to take them could be excused under a reasonably prudent person standard.13 The difference shows up when the contractor's omission was reasonable. Under the vicarious framing the contractor was not negligent, so nothing passes up to the hirer, while under the New Mexico test the same excusable omission still leaves the hirer liable.
Neither framing should be confused with the hirer's liability for its own negligence. Plaintiffs often plead both the owner's own negligence and vicarious liability, but the two bases are distinct, and an owner with no vicarious exposure must still answer for its own conduct in connection with the work.14 New Mexico's direct liability also differs from fault-based liability, because it depends on neither the contractor's lack of care nor the owner's lack of care in seeing that the contractor takes the necessary precautions.15 Unless the facts identify a jurisdiction that follows the New Mexico approach, analyze a nondelegable duty as vicarious liability that requires a negligent contractor.