Concept
Analyzing a Hirer Problem
General rule of non-liability and the employer's own negligence
Analyzing a Hirer Problem
Every hirer problem begins from the default rule of Restatement (Second) of Torts § 409: except as §§ 410-429 provide, the employer of an independent contractor is not liable for physical harm caused by an act or omission of the contractor or the contractor's servants.1 The fault-based exceptions in this reading all qualify that default, so the problem can be worked in a fixed order. The order also keeps apart two questions that are easy to run together. The first asks whether the contractor was careless, and the stem usually answers it. The second asks whether the hirer itself said, chose, checked, kept, or knew something that supplies a separate ground of liability, and the plaintiff must prove that ground against the hirer.2 The contractor's carelessness, standing alone, leaves the default in place.
The first two steps work as gates. An employee presents a different problem, because the defendant's right to direct the details of the work brings in respondeat superior, and none of the own-fault theories is needed. Step three is reached only for a genuine independent contractor, whose independence is the premise of § 409. A hirer who escapes liability leaves the plaintiff with the contractor as defendant. A hirer who is liable under step three answers for its own negligence and not for the contractor's.3
Step three holds most of the doctrine, and each theory turns on a question that the facts of a stem can answer.
- A negligent-orders claim asks whether the hirer gave an affirmative direction about how the work was to be done, whether the direction was negligent, and whether the contractor acted pursuant to it (§ 410).4
- A careless-selection claim asks whether the hirer failed to use reasonable care in choosing a competent and careful contractor, either for work that is risky unless skillfully done or to perform a duty the hirer owes to third persons (§ 411).5
- A failure-to-inspect claim asks whether a hirer already bound to keep land or chattels reasonably safe failed to check, after the contractor finished repair or maintenance, whether the property was in reasonably safe condition (§ 412).6
- A retained-control claim asks whether the hirer kept control of some part of the work and failed to exercise that control with reasonable care, causing harm to people whose safety the hirer owed a duty to protect (§ 414).7
- A possessor's-duty claim asks whether a possessor who employed or permitted a contractor to work on the land knew or had reason to know that the contractor's activities, or conditions the contractor created, posed an unreasonable risk of physical harm to people outside the land, and then failed to use reasonable care to protect them.8
These five theories track the points at which a hirer's own conduct can matter. Before the work begins, the hirer chooses a contractor, and reasonable care means choosing one who is competent, experienced, careful, and properly equipped. While the work proceeds, the hirer may specify an inappropriate manner of doing it, fail to require necessary precautions, or use retained control carelessly. When the contractor finishes, reasonable care may require the hirer to inspect the completed work.9 Throughout, a possessor who sees the work endangering people beyond its boundary must act to protect them. Where a stem shows the hirer no such point of involvement, no own-fault theory is available and the plaintiff's claim runs against the contractor alone. Where it shows one, the hirer answers for its own conduct in connection with the work, even if no vicarious theory applies.10
The contractor's status, the contractor's reputation, and the motorist's injury are identical in the two hypotheticals, so none of them explains the different results. What differs is what each homeowner did: the first said nothing about methods, and the second prescribed one. Read every stem for the verbs of the hirer's own conduct, such as told, chose, checked, kept, and saw. Silence about methods is not an order, and a right to inspect only the finished surface is not control of any part of the work. A stem that gives the hirer nothing more leaves the claim without an own-fault theory.
The vicarious exceptions come last because they ask a different kind of question and require no proof of fault by the hirer. Nondelegable duties are one such family. When a duty arises out of a special relation to the public or to the plaintiff and is important enough to the community, a hirer who delegates its performance is vicariously liable for the contractor's negligence even though the hirer was entirely without fault.13 Work that carries a peculiar risk is another family, and other readings take up both. The Third Restatement draws the same line. Section 56 carries forward the rule that a hirer has no duty about the manner of the work except as to parts it controls, and § 55 imposes direct liability for an activity that creates a risk of physical harm and for affirmative duties the hirer hands to a contractor. Sections 57-65 then provide vicarious liability in circumstances similar to, though not identical with, those of §§ 416-429 of the Second Restatement.14 Plaintiffs often plead both kinds of theory, and the two stand or fall separately, so a hirer who defeats every own-fault claim may still face a vicarious one.15