Concept
Failure to Inspect Completed Work
General rule of non-liability and the employer's own negligence
Failure to Inspect Completed Work
A hirer who owes a duty to keep land or chattels reasonably safe does not discharge that duty by handing the repair to a contractor and walking away. Restatement (Second) of Torts § 412 says so directly. A person who is under a duty to use reasonable care to maintain land or chattels so that they do not involve unreasonable risk of bodily harm to others, and who entrusts the repair and maintenance to an independent contractor, is subject to liability for bodily harm caused by a failure to use the care the circumstances may reasonably require to ascertain whether the land or chattel is in reasonably safe condition once the contractor's work is completed.1
The earlier exceptions in this chapter ask what the hirer ordered and whom the hirer chose; this one asks what the hirer did after the work was done. In every case the hirer answers for its own negligence, not for the contractor's.2
The first step works as a gate. Section 412 creates no duty over the condition of the property; it takes a duty the law already places on an owner or possessor and says how that duty is performed when a contractor does the repair. A store's duty to keep its premises reasonably safe for customers and a car owner's duty to maintain adequate brakes are examples.3 A hirer with no such duty falls outside the section, and some other exception must carry the plaintiff's claim.
The third step carries the doctrine. The contractor's poor workmanship supplies the danger, but the hirer's liability rests on the hirer's own lapse after completion. A plaintiff must therefore show that reasonable care called for a check, that the hirer made none or a deficient one, and that a proper check would have revealed the danger. Because the section imposes liability only for harm caused by the failure to check, a hidden defect that no reasonable check could expose produces no liability under it.
Once the contractor leaves, the owner alone decides whether the stair, the elevator, or the car goes back into use, and a short check costs little beside the injury an unsafe one can cause. What the circumstances reasonably require is an ordinary negligence question. The foreseeable likelihood of harm, the foreseeable severity of harm, and the burden of precautions drive the answer.4 When the work creates a foreseeable danger to others, reasonable care may require inspection of the finished job.5 A repair to a stair tread, a brake line, or a structural support risks serious injury if it fails, and testing it takes minutes, so reasonable care calls for an actual test. A cosmetic touch-up with no safety function risks little, and a glance can satisfy the duty. The same weighing shows why the rule falls short of a guarantee: an owner need not dismantle finished work without a reason to suspect it, because a deep inspection costs much and finds little when nothing signals trouble.
Both owners held the same kind of preexisting duty, and both contractors' repairs failed, so the contractors' carelessness cannot explain the different outcomes. What each owner did after completion decides them. The grocer skipped a check that would have cost a single step. The hotel owner made the check a careful person would have made and was defeated only by a defect that the check could not reach.
If a reasonable inspection would not have found the defect, does the owner escape altogether? Not always, as Maloney v. Rath shows. A driver's brakes failed three months after a mechanic overhauled them, and the trial court found that she had no reason to know of any defect and that the mechanic's negligent repair caused the failure.6 The court held her liable anyway. Her duty to maintain her brakes was nondelegable, so the mechanic's negligence was no defense to her.7
The outcome differs from a § 412 result because the kind of liability differs. A § 412 claim needs the owner's own failure to use reasonable care in checking, and the findings about the driver's ordinary prudence would have answered it. A nondelegable-duty theory needs no fault by the owner; it makes the owner answer for the contractor's negligence, which is vicarious liability under a separate doctrine covered in another reading. The two theories overlap in practice, because the duties that trigger § 412, such as a possessor's duties to visitors and an auto owner's duty to maintain adequate brakes, appear on the familiar list of duties that courts treat as nondelegable.8 Plaintiffs often plead both, but the two bases must be kept apart, and an owner who inspected reasonably defeats the first without necessarily defeating the second.9
In a repair or maintenance problem, ask first whether the hirer already owed a duty over the condition of the land or chattel, then whether a contractor did the work, and then what the hirer did once the contractor finished. An owner who did nothing when a simple check would have exposed the danger has breached the duty to ascertain safety. An owner who made the check a careful person would have made has not, and the plaintiff's remaining route against that owner runs through a nondelegable duty.