Concept
Negligent Orders and Directions
General rule of non-liability and the employer's own negligence
Negligent Orders and Directions
A hirer who tells an independent contractor how to do the work answers for what follows as though the hirer had done the work personally. Section 410 of the Restatement (Second) of Torts makes the employer of an independent contractor subject to the same liability for physical harm caused by an act or omission the contractor committed pursuant to orders or directions the employer negligently gave, as though the act or omission were the employer's own.1 The wrong is the hirer's from the start. The carelessness lies in giving the instruction, and the contractor's compliance is only the route by which that instruction becomes physical harm. A plaintiff therefore needs no theory that imputes the contractor's negligence to the hirer. An owner who specifies that the work be done in an inappropriate manner is liable for its own negligence, not vicariously for the contractor's.2
The hypothetical shows the three things a plaintiff must prove. Running them in order tests any § 410 claim.
The first step decides most disputes, because hirers nearly always say something to a contractor, and only a direction about how the work is done counts. The third step supplies the causal link. A contractor who ignores the instruction and does the job another way has not acted pursuant to it, and the harm cannot be traced to the hirer's command.
Traudt v. Potomac Elec. Power Co. drew the line between an order and a failure to order. Traudt worked for Waco, a contractor PEPCO had hired for asbestos removal, and he sued PEPCO. His complaint was that PEPCO had failed to turn off the electric power or to provide or require special training or equipment. The court called those failures the basis for potential liability under § 413 but refused to equate them with the affirmative "orders and directions" that § 410 contemplates, because doing so would erase the distinction between the two sections. PEPCO had not told Traudt or Waco to work unsafely. It had not directed anyone to use a hammer and screwdriver to unwrap the asbestos, and it specified no means or methods at all beyond requiring compliance with public safety codes and its own safety rules.5 The availability of precautions, which matters under § 413, is immaterial to a § 410 theory. The question is what the hirer commanded.6
The same opinion points to Fry as the case in which § 410 was the primary theory alleged. There the court held that triable issues existed on whether an employer breached its duty by expressly directing an independent contractor to use an unsafe practice, namely to erect a ladder on top of scaffolding to paint upper windows.7 The danger in Fry began with the hirer's own command. In Traudt the hirer left methods to the contractor and asked only for compliance with safety codes. The difference lies in what the hirer communicated, not in how dangerous the job was.
A hirer whose only fault is silence is not automatically safe, because other theories can reach it. When the work will create a foreseeable danger to third persons, ordinary care may require the hirer to insist, in the contract or otherwise, that the contractor take the necessary safety precautions, and then to see that the contractor does so.8 That duty is a separate basis of liability. A plaintiff who pleads negligent orders when the facts show only silence has chosen the wrong section.
Section 414 is the neighboring theory, and it asks a different question. Section 410 looks at the content of what the hirer ordered. Section 414 applies to one who entrusts work to an independent contractor but retains control of any part of it, and it asks whether that control was exercised with reasonable care.9 Reserving general rights does not amount to retained control. PEPCO kept the right to inspect the work, direct changes, and order replacement of employees or equipment, and the court placed those rights among the "general right[s] ... usually reserved to employers" that do not create § 414 liability.10 A hirer who holds such rights but never prescribes a method is therefore not exposed on that fact alone. A hirer who tells the contractor exactly how to do a dangerous task has made the contractor's act its own.