Concept
The General Rule of Non-Liability
General rule of non-liability and the employer's own negligence
Hirer Liability for Independent Contractors
The General Rule of Non-Liability
A person who hires an independent contractor generally does not answer for the contractor's torts. Restatement (Second) of Torts § 409 states the rule: "Except as stated in §§ 410-429, the employer of an independent contractor is not liable for physical harm caused to another by an act or omission of the contractor or his servants."1 Three features of that sentence matter. The opening clause makes the rule a default, which §§ 410-429 qualify at length. The phrase "physical harm" confines it to the ordinary accident case. And the words "or his servants" carry the insulation down one level, so the hirer is shielded from the negligence of the contractor's own workers as well as from the contractor's.
The rule protects only a hirer whose worker really is an independent contractor, so every hirer problem begins with classification. When a person lets out work and reserves no control over the work or the workmen, the relationship is that of contractee and independent contractor, not master and servant, and the contractee is not liable for the contractor's negligent or improper execution of the work. Falls v. Scott states the rule in just those terms.2 A hirer of that kind checks the finished product against the specifications instead of supervising how the contractor works.3 Control over the details points the other way. If the principal controls, or by custom or agreement has the right to control, the time, place, and method of the work, the worker is very likely an employee.4 The right to control counts as well as its exercise, so a hirer who holds the right and never uses it very likely still has an employee. Status is always a question of fact, and the parties' own label for their relationship is one factor that never settles it.5
Courts have elaborated further factors beyond control, and the Third Restatement of Agency lists them. They include whether the worker runs a distinct business, who supplies the tools and workplace, and whether pay is by the hour or by the job.6 No single factor decides. The cases are not always consistent, and the customs and common sense of the community may be as reliable a guide as any.7
A homeowner who engages someone to maintain the yard shows how the facts sort the worker. If the homeowner supplies the tools, pays by the hour, sets the schedule, and dictates each task, the worker is likely an employee, and the ordinary vicarious liability of an employer applies in place of § 409. If the worker arrives with a truck and equipment, decides what the yard needs, chooses the hours, and charges a flat seasonal fee, the worker is likely an independent contractor, and § 409 protects the homeowner.
Two justifications support the rule, and the first is control. Vicarious liability makes sense when the principal can influence how the work is done. With an agent who is not subject to the principal's control, there is no basis for vicarious liability, because a principal with no say over the details cannot effectively increase the care taken.8 The hirer of a contractor stands in exactly that position. The contractor commits to a specified output, and the hirer monitors by inspecting the result instead of supervising the work. That method works whenever the output can be specified and checked.9 Liability on such a hirer would do little to raise the level of care, while the contractor, who does control the work, is the party placed to improve it. Courts have sometimes pressed the control premise further than modern law would. Older cases reasoned that hospitals, being corporations that could not legally practice medicine, could not control physicians, and they held hospitals not vicariously liable even for the physicians they employed. That view has changed radically but not universally.10
The second justification concerns who bears the cost of accidents. An owner who turns work over to a contractor knows it is avoiding a potential liability, and the contractor knows it is assuming that liability, so the cost of insuring against tort liability enters the price of the work.11 The party that controls the work therefore also prices and carries the risk the work creates. Neither justification holds up well once the hirer has itself done something wrong, and that is where many of the exceptions begin.
Section 409 is followed by the catalog of exceptions in §§ 410-429, and the catalog has drawn so much attention that the rule is now said to be "primarily important as a preamble to the catalog of its exceptions."12 The comment to § 409 concedes the point: the exceptions are so numerous that the rule applies only "where no good reason is found for departing from it." LaCount v. Hensel Phelps Construction Co. quoted that comment in a case about injuries to an independent contractor's employee, where the hirer argued as a matter of law that the peculiar-risk provisions did not apply. The court framed the question as whether any exception could apply at all.13 The slogan should not be pushed too far, though, because in an ordinary case no exception applies and § 409 decides the matter. A homeowner who hires a paver to resurface the driveway will most likely escape liability when the paver backs into the street and causes an accident. The same is true of an owner who hires an electrical contractor that negligently starts a fire while rewiring the office.14
None of this leaves an injured person without a defendant. A person is always responsible for his own torts, so the contractor, and the worker whose act caused the harm, remain personally liable. Section 409 declines only to add the hirer.15 Murrell v. Goertz shows the typical posture: a customer sued both a carrier, who was collecting for delivery of her morning newspaper, for an alleged assault and battery, and the publisher, and the publisher won summary judgment.16
This reading takes up the exceptions that rest on the hirer's own fault. Seven sections, §§ 410-415, impose liability on that basis. Strictly speaking they are not exceptions to any vicarious-liability rule, but they are exceptions to the rule of non-liability for harm the contractor's act caused, so they are conveniently taught together.18 Five of the seven anchor the units that follow:
- Negligent orders or directions given to the contractor (§ 410).19
- Failure to use reasonable care in choosing a competent and careful contractor (§ 411).20
- Failure to check land or chattels after the contractor finishes repair or maintenance work (§ 412).21
- Negligent exercise of control the hirer kept over part of the work (§ 414).22
- A possessor of land's failure to protect people outside the land from risks the contractor's work creates (§ 414A).23
The other exceptions in §§ 416-429 are exceptions to a vicarious-liability rule in the strict sense, and later readings treat them. The next section draws the line between direct and vicarious liability, because that line decides what a plaintiff must prove against the hirer.