Concept
Tacking On Economic Loss
Claims for pure economic loss
Tacking On Economic Loss
A plaintiff who has been physically harmed recovers the money losses that the harm causes. This is the easiest rule in the chapter to state and the least disputed, and it sets the benchmark for every later case: the disputes ahead all involve plaintiffs who have no physical harm of their own.
Section 924 of the Restatement (Second) of Torts supplies the text. It entitles one whose interests of personality have been tortiously invaded, meaning harm to the person's own body and well-being, to damages for past or prospective bodily harm and emotional distress1; loss or impairment of earning capacity2; reasonable medical and other expenses3; and harm to property or business caused by the invasion.4 The first item is noneconomic. The other three carry money losses, and each rides on the physical injury the plaintiff already has. That is what tacking on means: the economic loss attaches to the physical-harm claim and is recovered with it.
Impaired earning capacity is the item students picture first, and it has two parts that are measured differently. Lost earnings are the income missed between the injury and the trial, so a plaintiff who was off work for ten weeks recovers ten weeks of wages. Lost earning capacity is the reduction in what the plaintiff can earn in the future. Because the plaintiff gets one recovery in one lawsuit, the injury's future effect on earnings is compensated at the same trial.5 Past earnings are a matter of arithmetic, while future capacity is a forecast. Courts accept a forecast that is not mathematically exact if it rests on a reasonable evidentiary foundation, and they leave the jury wide latitude in setting the amount.6
Medical and other expenses cover what the plaintiff pays to deal with the injury, and the category extends well past the hospital bill. It includes doctors, nursing, tests, medicines, devices, physical therapy, and travel to obtain these services, along with the cost of substitute labor hired to do work the plaintiff cannot perform and, for a severely injured plaintiff, custodial care.7 The word reasonable sets the limit. The plaintiff recovers the reasonable value of care that was fairly and reasonably necessary to treat the injuries, and defendants often answer with evidence of the discounted amount the plaintiff's insurer actually paid.8
Harm to property or business reaches the plaintiff's commercial losses. An owner whose injuries keep the shop closed loses the profits the shop would have earned, and those profits tack on to the injury claim just as lost wages do.9 The Restatement item covers property and business harm that flows from an invasion of the person. When the tort damages the plaintiff's own property directly, the ordinary damages rules reach the same result. The base measure is the loss in value or the cost of repair, whichever is less, and the plaintiff adds consequential losses such as diminished profits.10 Preble v. Hanna is an example in which the loss was the profit an owner missed while locked out of a business.11
In all four categories the qualifying fact is physical harm to the plaintiff's own person or property, and the dollar amount of the loss never enters the classification. A plaintiff whose own person or property is injured can recover in tort for the accompanying economic harm unless some other rule bars it.12 The Restatement (Third) of Torts: Products Liability § 21 states the same idea in its own setting. It treats economic loss as harm to persons or property when it is caused by, among other things, harm to the plaintiff's person or to the plaintiff's property other than the defective product itself.13 The ordinary limits still govern the tacked-on items. Awards cannot be too remote, speculative, or uncertain, and rules such as the collateral source rule and mitigation also shape what the plaintiff collects.14
Two victims of one negligent act show how this fact sorts claims. The injured employee has a tort claim that includes lost wages. The employer loses output while the employee recovers, but that loss is economic loss that tort law ordinarily refuses to compensate, because letting each such claimant sue would extend recovery to parties far removed from the tort.15 The same divide appears when a ship captain negligently collides with another ship. Damage to the other ship is recoverable. If the collision spills toxic chemicals, the economic loss doctrine rejects the claims of every nearby business that lost customers during the cleanup, as the Fifth Circuit held in Louisiana ex rel. Guste v. M/V Testbank.16
Two features of damages law make the tack-on rule unsurprising. The first is the compensatory aim: damages restore the plaintiff to the pre-injury condition so far as money can, and a plaintiff paid for the broken leg but not for the wages and bills it caused would remain undercompensated.17 The second is the rule's natural boundary. The defendant answers for one victim's own losses, not for the ripples an event sends through a community. Those ripples are what the stranger rule restricts, since letting every affected party sue would reach people far removed from the tort.18
Students most often err on the side of excess caution. A student sees lost profits in a damages claim, remembers that negligence law withholds recovery for pure economic loss, and cuts off a claim that belongs to a physically injured plaintiff. The sound order of analysis asks first whether the defendant physically harmed the plaintiff's own person or property. Only when the answer is no does the analysis in the following sections begin.