Concept
Defining Economic Loss
Claims for pure economic loss
Pure Economic Loss in Negligence
Defining Economic Loss
Compensatory damages are the money a court awards a person as compensation, indemnity, or restitution for harm that person has sustained.1 Much of that harm is financial. A driver hurt in a collision recovers lost wages and medical expenses, and the Restatement lists harm to property, harm to earning capacity, and the creation of liabilities among the compensatory items that require proof of pecuniary loss.2 Here the money loss raises no special difficulty. The physical injury or property damage already shows an invasion of an interest the law protects, and the dollar figures measure what that invasion cost.
Economic loss plays a narrower role when it is all the plaintiff has suffered. The common law has historically limited compensatory recovery in two ways: damages for purely economic loss generally are not recoverable in tort absent physical injury or property damage, and recovery for emotional distress without physical injury is significantly limited.3 Only the first limit concerns this chapter. A plaintiff whose entire claim is a lost sale, a cancelled contract, or an idle workforce asks for a remedy that negligence law ordinarily withholds, so the question becomes whether the defendant owed that plaintiff any duty to avoid that kind of harm. The sections that follow take up the no-duty rule and its exceptions.
The same dollar loss can therefore be a routine item of damages in one lawsuit and a barred claim in another. The amount does not change, and neither does the financial character of the harm; the source of the loss does. Two preliminary steps fix the label. The first gathers the Restatement's vocabulary of damages, and the second uses that vocabulary to define pure economic loss.
Damages Vocabulary
The Restatement (Second) of Torts uses “damages” in a specific sense: a sum of money awarded to a person injured by the tort of another.4 The word names the remedy, the dollar award. A plaintiff first establishes a tort and then asks what the resulting harm is worth, so every term below belongs to that second step.
Compensatory damages are the part of that money meant to compensate, indemnify, or restore the plaintiff for harm the plaintiff has sustained.5 The plaintiff's own loss sets the measure. Punitive damages, also called exemplary damages, use a different yardstick: they punish and deter wrongdoers in cases of particularly egregious or malicious conduct, and because they play that different societal role, due process constrains the states that award them.6 Economic loss belongs on the compensatory side, and the terms that follow describe how a plaintiff pleads and proves it.
Compensatory damages divide into two groups according to what the plaintiff must allege. General damages are compensatory damages for a harm so frequently resulting from the tort that its existence is normally anticipated and need not be alleged in order to be proved.7 Special damages are compensatory damages for any harm other than one for which general damages are given.8 The line follows notice. A battery that causes bodily harm normally brings physical pain, so a complaint alleging only “a broken leg” supports proof of pain and suffering. Medical expenses, lost wages, and unusual effects such as traumatic neurosis must be specifically pleaded, so that the defendant is on notice that they will be claimed.9
Personal injury practice sorts the same harms a second way, into economic and noneconomic damages. The two classifications are not always coterminous: lost earnings and medical and other expenses are special damages that can be measured objectively, while pain and suffering and emotional distress are general damages whose loss, though real, is fundamentally noneconomic.10 Economic damages in this second sense are actual dollar losses that can be calculated, such as lost earnings, lost earning capacity, and medical expenses. Pain and suffering and loss of enjoyment are intangible, and the jury has no mathematical or accounting basis for valuing them.11 An exam answer that needs the pleading consequence should use “special” in the Restatement's sense and reserve “economic” for describing the kind of loss.
A plaintiff must affirmatively prove economic harm. The Restatement lists compensation that will not be awarded without proof of pecuniary loss: harm to property, harm to earning capacity, and the creation of liabilities.12 The law does not presume a money loss from the event itself, because one collision may cost an owner a trivial repair bill and another owner a month of idle vehicles. For pecuniary losses, courts may expect somewhat more evidence that the loss exists. Some courts are satisfied once existence is shown with reasonable certainty, while others require both existence and amount to be proved with reasonable certainty. The wrongdoer rule eases that burden by letting jurors estimate the loss where the uncertainty results from the defendant's own conduct.13
The contrast in proof shows up inside a single collision.
Both items here sit alongside physical harm the defendant caused. The next subsection uses this vocabulary to isolate the loss that has no physical injury behind it.
Pure Economic Loss Defined
The Third Restatement defines economic loss as pecuniary damage not arising from injury to the plaintiff's person or physical harm to the plaintiff's property.16 Courts that apply the no-duty rule express the same idea as “pure” economic loss. One California case arose from a months-long leak at a natural gas storage facility near Los Angeles. Local businesses sued for income lost because of the leak, and none alleged personal injury or property damage.17 The California Supreme Court used the phrase as shorthand for pecuniary or commercial loss that does not arise from actionable physical, emotional, or reputational injury to persons or physical injury to property, and it held that the gas company had no tort duty to guard against such losses.18 Both formulations look at where the money loss came from, and the amount plays no part. Two plaintiffs can lose identical sums and land on opposite sides of the definition, depending on what physical harm, if any, stands behind the loss.
The physical harm must have fallen on the plaintiff. Physical injury to one party's person or property can produce purely economic harm for another party whose losses are not parasitic on any injury that party suffered. Suppose a defendant's negligent driving causes a collision that forces the closing of a bridge for half a day.19 Real physical harm has occurred, but to other people and their vehicles. A contractor who cannot reach the bid desk before the noon deadline, or a business cut off from its supplier, loses money because of that harm without suffering any of it, and each claim is for pure economic loss. Exam stems often place the physical harm on a third party, and the student who sees a collision and assumes the plaintiff's loss rides on it will misclassify.
Ownership matters as well. The Third Restatement provides that a claimant cannot recover for economic loss caused by unintentional injury to property in which the claimant has no proprietary interest.20 Robins Dry Dock v. Flint illustrates the problem. A dry dock negligently damaged a ship's propeller, the repair took the ship out of operation for another two weeks, and the ship's time charterer sued for the lost profits from that loss of use.21 The Robins Dry Dock section develops the rule that case produced. For now the point is that damage to some property does not by itself turn every resulting loss into an ordinary item of damages. Even the meaning of property damage can be contested in product cases, where the Products Restatement asks whether the product is an integrated whole. If it is, damage to the whole by a component part is not damage to “other property”; the product is deemed to have damaged itself.22
The other side of the line is economic loss that depends on the plaintiff's own physical injury, which courts sometimes call parasitic loss. Out-of-pocket medical expenses and lost wages in an ordinary negligence case are economic losses of this kind, as are lost profits resulting from damage to the plaintiff's own property.23 The Restatement (Second) of Torts likewise counts loss or impairment of earning capacity, reasonable medical and other expenses, and harm to property or business caused by the invasion among the compensable items.24 In these cases the money loss is not itself the tort. It is compensation for economic loss that results from another type of injury, such as personal injury or property damage.25
The line falls here because of how California frames the duty question. In cases involving traditionally compensable injury, such as physical harm to person or property, the court presumes the defendant owed the plaintiff a duty of care and asks whether the circumstances justify a departure from that presumption. It then held that the gas company had no tort duty to guard against purely economic losses.26 The presumption that attaches to physical harm does not help a plaintiff who lost only money, so a court must ask whether the defendant owed that plaintiff any duty at all.
The next section takes up how far that tacked-on recovery reaches. The dollar figures in the two restaurants could be identical, and only the spoiled meat separates a claim the law examines skeptically from one it treats as routine.
The definition also excludes two interests that are not physical but are still personal. Emotional and reputational injury to a person are not pure economic loss, so a plaintiff whose money loss follows from one of them sues in the personal tort, and the loss is damages within it.27 A defamation victim whose customers leave after a false story sues for the injury to reputation, and the lost income is an item of damages in that action. Classifying the harm as a personal tort does not guarantee recovery, since stand-alone emotional distress faces its own limits.28 It does remove the claim from the pure-economic-loss rules taught below.
Pure economic loss must also be separated from the economic torts. The economic torts protect an interest that is itself economic, and the injury that makes the defendant liable is economic or pecuniary loss. That distinguishes them from torts that compensate economic loss only as the consequence of another injury.29 Fraud and interference with contract rights or prospective advantage are intentional torts, so they fall outside the rule.30 Many jurisdictions also allow negligence-related torts such as professional malpractice and negligent misrepresentation to proceed when the plaintiff has suffered only economic harm. The rule therefore tends to preclude only general negligence and strict liability actions that seek recovery for pure economic loss, and those are the claims the rest of this chapter addresses.31
Step 3 does the real work. Fact patterns routinely supply physical harm to someone else, as the bridge collision does, and the student who stops at step 2 will misclassify the plaintiff's loss.