Concept
Court and Jury Roles
Damages for mental distress and other intangible injuries
Damages for Intangible Harm
Court and Jury Roles
Every claim for intangible harm contains two separate questions, and they go to different decision-makers. The first is whether the law treats this kind of loss as something a defendant can be made to pay for. The Restatement (Second) of Torts puts it as whether the harm the plaintiff claims to have suffered is legally compensable, and that question belongs to the court.1 Compensability is built into the definition of a tort itself, which requires that the defendant's conduct cause a compensable injury to the person, property, or recognized interest of another.2 A judge can answer the question without knowing anything about the particular plaintiff, and the answer then governs every case of the same type.
The second question arises only after the court has let a category of harm into the case: did this plaintiff actually suffer it? That is a question of fact, and juries answer it routinely by weighing the credibility of testimony about emotional suffering.3 The jury then puts a dollar figure on whatever it finds, a task taken up in the later sections on measuring awards.
The division follows what each question requires. Compensability turns on policy, and policy should not change from one courtroom to the next. When courts first articulated the general no-duty rule for negligently caused pure emotional loss, they relied on the opportunity for fraud and on the fear that the floodgates of litigation would open.4 One commentator finds those reasons less than completely convincing, because juries assess claims of emotional suffering all the time without much worry about fraud. That debate, however, is about where the line should be drawn, which is a question about the law, not about any one plaintiff. Whether a particular plaintiff felt the distress is different. It depends on credibility and on the circumstances of one person's life, which is the kind of question a jury is suited to answer.
When a defendant objects to an item of intangible damages, the first step is to identify what the objection attacks. An objection that the law does not recognize the item goes to the judge. Courts have declined, for example, to treat litigation-induced stress as part of pain and suffering. In Stoleson v. United States, the Seventh Circuit, applying Wisconsin law, reasoned that an alleged tortfeasor should be able to defend himself without thereby multiplying his damages. A New Jersey decision, Picogna v. Board of Education, likewise held that such stress is not an appropriate element of pain and suffering damages.5 Property damage works the same way. Pain and suffering damages are black-letter unrecoverable in property damage cases, so an owner who is emotionally attached to a family heirloom cannot recover for the resulting emotional suffering when the defendant's negligence damages it.6 In both situations the judge removes the item from the case, and the jury never prices it.
The distinction tells you which kind of argument to make. Attacking a plaintiff's credibility or the size of a figure speaks to the jury and does nothing against a claim for a category the law has already refused to compensate. A legal objection to a category, in turn, does not help against a plaintiff whose recognized harm is simply exaggerated. The later parts of this chapter follow the same order: first which harms the law will recognize, including the limits and caps a court applies, and then how a jury is shown the harm and asked to value it.