Concept
Care in Conducting Activities
Duty owed to licensees
Care in Conducting Activities
A possessor who is doing something on the land, as opposed to merely letting a condition exist, owes licensees a more demanding duty than the baseline rule suggests. Restatement (Second) of Torts § 341 makes a possessor liable for physical harm caused to licensees by a failure to carry on the possessor's activities with reasonable care for their safety "if, but only if" two things are true: (a) the possessor should expect that the licensees will not discover or realize the danger, and (b) the licensees do not know or have reason to know of the possessor's activities and of the risk involved.1 Section 342 asks what a possessor must disclose about a hazard already sitting on the land. Section 341 asks how the possessor must behave while doing something there. A claim under it therefore alleges careless conduct and needs no hidden defect.
This duty departs from the baseline, under which a possessor owes a licensee little beyond a warning of known hidden dangers. So strong was the common-law solicitude for landowners that the special-duty limitations favoring them were restricted, if not entirely eliminated, only in the last third of the twentieth century.2 For active operations, most courts have now overruled the older decisions and hold that the defendant is under a duty of reasonable care toward licensees.3 The duty reaches not only licensees who have been discovered but also those whose presence might reasonably be anticipated.4 That difference is the practical core of the modern rule. A duty triggered only by discovery would reward the possessor who never looks, because a possessor who does not look never discovers anyone. Extending the duty to anticipated presence requires the possessor to run operations with visitors in mind.
Conduct is treated differently from conditions because of what each asks of the possessor. A static defect calls for precautions taken in advance, such as inspecting and repairing before anyone knows who will come, and the baseline spares the possessor that burden. An activity is the possessor's own conduct at that moment, so doing it carefully calls for attention rather than advance preparation: looking before backing a vehicle, or watching where a load will swing. A licensee who has no idea the activity is under way cannot protect against it the way a guest can step around a loose board in plain view. The possessor is the party best placed to avoid the harm cheaply, which is why the care duty attaches to conduct even where the no-inspection rule shields the possessor from liability for conditions.
The authorities collected for this rule, including Hoffman v. Planters Gin Co., Lipham v. Federated Dep't Stores, Inc., and Jeffries v. Potomac Development Corp., treat the possessor's duty of reasonable care as one about conduct, distinct from the condition of the land.5 Typical operations include driving vehicles, operating cranes, and constructing buildings, and a possessor engaged in them must keep a reasonable lookout for licensees who are permitted to be present.6 The label "active operations" has been under pressure. Courts have defined it broadly, sometimes giving it a strained construction in cases involving dangers known to the occupier.7 That pressure is why the line between an activity and a condition needs its own treatment in the next section.
The two conditions in § 341 ask separate questions, and an activity carried on in plain sight usually fails both. Condition (a) looks at the possessor's side and asks what the possessor should expect a visitor to discover or realize. Condition (b) looks at the licensee's side and asks what the licensee knew or had reason to know about the activity and the risk it carried.8
Three limits keep the duty from growing into the full protection an invitee receives. Each limits what reasonable care asks of the possessor while the activity is under way:
- A possessor may assume that a licensee will watch out for himself to the extent he can.
- A possessor may assume that a licensee will not expect customary activities to be changed for the licensee's benefit.
- A possessor who must keep a reasonable lookout need not keep a constant lookout for a licensee who is unlikely to appear.9
These limits follow from the baseline. If a licensee could demand that routines be reorganized, the possessor would owe the visitor the accommodation the law gives only to those who come in reliance on the premises being prepared for them. A mill operator who runs a saw at the usual hour and in the usual way is doing what any visitor to that property should expect. A constant watch for someone unlikely to appear would impose a real cost for almost no safety benefit. The limits operate at the breach stage. A possessor who reasonably believes the licensee knows of the danger, or will discover it and protect against it, has not acted unreasonably.