Concept
Who Is a Trespasser
Duty owed to adult trespassers
Duty to Adult Trespassers
Who Is a Trespasser
Every premises-liability claim starts with a question about the plaintiff rather than the possessor: where does the law place the person who was hurt? Under the traditional scheme, the answer fixes the duty owed, and the lowest rung belongs to the adult trespasser. Restatement (Second) of Torts § 333 states the consequence. Except as §§ 334 through 339 provide, a possessor is not liable to trespassers for physical harm caused by a failure to exercise reasonable care to put the land in a condition reasonably safe for their reception or to carry on activities so as not to endanger them.1 A court therefore cannot say what a possessor owed until it has decided who the plaintiff was, and that decision usually turns on whether the possessor consented to the plaintiff's presence.
Rowland v. Christian treats this scheme as a departure from the general principle that a person is liable for injuries caused by carelessness. The court noted a suggestion that the special rules for possessors owe their shape to history: the high place land has held in English and American thought, the dominance of the landowning class in England when the rules formed, and the heritage of feudalism.2
The hierarchy that resulted ranks entrants by the benefit they bestow on the possessor. Adult trespassers sit at the bottom, invitees and child trespassers at the top, and social guests and licensees in between.3 A trespasser is a person on the premises without permission who confers no benefit on the owner or occupier, and trespassers take the premises as they find them.4 Child trespassers receive greater protection under the attractive nuisance doctrine, which this reading leaves aside; what follows concerns adult entrants.5 Most courts still begin by classifying the entrant, although a substantial number have extended ordinary care to licensees and even trespassers, and the last section of this chapter returns to those courts.6
Three questions identify a trespasser: what the category covers, how far a given consent reaches, and what follows when a possessor tolerates an entry he never approved.
Consent Defines the Category
A trespasser is anyone who enters another's land without the possessor's express or implied consent.7 The hunter who enters without permission is the standard example: he has no consent and confers no benefit on the owner.8 Consent is the only variable. Give the same hunter permission, and the defining fact is gone.
Because the test looks to consent, the category is broader than the group of entrants who might be sued for the tort of trespass.9 The tort asks whether the actor chose to intrude, and a mistake about the boundary is no defense. Someone who wanders from her own woods across the line into her neighbor's is a trespasser even though she does not know it, because she intended to walk where she walked.10 The duty inquiry reaches further still. A person carried unconscious onto the land by others might be a trespasser for the purpose of determining the possessor's duty of care.11 The status inquiry asks only whether the possessor consented, and neither the entrant's good faith nor his helplessness supplies that consent.
Exceeding the Scope of Consent
Consent has edges, so the category is fluid. A person who is an invitee or licensee in one part of the premises can become a trespasser by entering an area to which no permission extends.13 The facts of Campbell v. Weathers show where the problem arises. The plaintiff entered a tenant's lunch counter and cigar stand, loitered in the front for fifteen or twenty minutes without making a purchase, and then went to the back of the building to use the toilet.14 A visitor admitted to the front of a business has said nothing to show that the back is open to her too, and the status question must be asked of the back separately.
Purpose can mark the boundary as well as area. In Copeland v. Hubbard Broadcasting, Inc., a veterinarian was permitted to bring a student of veterinary medicine to the plaintiffs' home. The 'student' was a television employee who secretly videotaped the treatment of a cat, and the court found a trespass.15 That decision concerns the tort, not the possessor's duty, but it asks the question the status inquiry asks: what did the possessor actually allow?
Tolerated Intruders
Consent can be implied, and the hardest classification questions arise when a possessor never said yes but has watched people enter for years and done nothing. Courts divide on what that silence means. English authority requires that permission be proved, not tolerance, although tolerance may be so pronounced as to be tantamount to permission. A notice forbidding entry, followed by no further steps when people often come, would leave it open to a judge or jury to find implied permission.17 The tendency in this country runs the other way: continued toleration of the entry amounts to permission, and the entrant is a licensee, not a trespasser.18 Other authority holds that a possessor's failure to take steps that would be burdensome, expensive, and perhaps futile does not by itself indicate consent to the entry.19
The split reflects two readings of the same silence. A possessor who does nothing may have accepted the entry, or may simply have judged that stopping it is not worth the cost. One opinion adds that the real basis of liability to tolerated intruders, as Dean Prosser saw it, is only the ordinary duty to protect another where the harm to be anticipated from a risk the possessor is responsible for outweighs the inconvenience of guarding against it.20 Where a court finds no consent, the entrants remain trespassers, and what the possessor owes them is governed by the exceptions to the no-duty rule, taken up in the sections that follow.21