Concept
The Proof Problem
Alternative liability when the responsible defendant cannot be identified
Alternative Liability
The Proof Problem
A negligence plaintiff must prove that the defendant's carelessness was a but-for cause of the harm, and courts today generally require that proof by a preponderance of the evidence. The plaintiff must show it is more probable than not that the injury would not have happened without the defendant's negligence.1 A few courts ask for more and require the plaintiff to eliminate every other cause of the accident.2 The requirement does real sorting work. It separates the defendant whose negligence produced the injury from the defendant whose carelessness, however blameworthy, did not.
The sorting fails on the facts of Summers v. Tice. The plaintiff was hunting quail with two companions, and both companions fired in his direction at the same moment. A single shot struck him in the eye, but he could not prove which companion fired it.3 Both defendants were negligent, and the chance that either one's pellet hit the plaintiff was 50/50.4 A 50 percent chance is not more probable than not, so under but-for analysis the plaintiff loses against each hunter.5 Each hunter can point to the other, and both walk away.
The result is troubling because the reason for demanding proof of causation has not changed. One of the two hunters certainly injured the plaintiff, and both committed the same negligent act. The shooting left no evidence that could tell them apart, and the plaintiff could not supply it. The rule that normally separates responsible defendants from irresponsible ones here lets two negligent defendants escape together. The plaintiff's evidence is no weaker than in an ordinary case. What has changed is that the uncertainty cannot be resolved by any further proof.
The gap is narrow, though. It arises because the defendants did exactly the same thing, so the chances were equal that either caused the harm and there was no logical way to choose between them.6 Contrast a case in which the defendants' conduct differs.
Cases like the light pole are the typical multi-defendant case. Because the jury has some basis for a more-probable-than-not finding, a court is unlikely to invoke the burden-shifting approach that Summers used.7 The hunters' case is the exception in which proof breaks down.
The exception leaves a question open. When two defendants have committed the same negligent act, exactly one of them caused the harm, and no one can say which, someone must bear the risk of that uncertainty. The loss can stay with the injured plaintiff, who did nothing to create the uncertainty. It can also fall on the defendants, each of whom acted negligently. The rest of this chapter examines how courts have answered that question and how narrowly they have drawn the answer.