Concept
Burden, Court, and Jury
But for and substantial causes
Burden, Court, and Jury
Legal cause has two parts. The defendant's negligence must be a substantial factor in bringing about the harm, and no rule of law may relieve the defendant of liability because of the manner in which the negligence resulted in the harm.1 Neither part proves itself at trial. Someone must carry the burden of establishing it, someone must say which rules of law govern, and someone must decide whether the proof measures up.
The Restatement (Second) of Torts divides these tasks among plaintiff, court, and jury. Section 328A(c) makes the plaintiff prove that the defendant's failure was a legal cause of the harm the plaintiff suffered.2 Section 328B(e) gives the court the applicability of any rules of law determining whether the defendant's conduct is a legal cause.3 Section 328C(c) gives the jury the determination whether the defendant's conduct is a legal cause of the harm.4 The assignments also run in sequence: the plaintiff produces evidence, the court tests its sufficiency and decides which rules of law apply, and the jury weighs what survives. Every causation dispute therefore sits at one of three gates, and the first step in analyzing it is to find which.
The Plaintiff's Burden
The plaintiff carries the burden on causation as on every element of a tort claim, and that burden has two parts: production and persuasion.5 The plaintiff's own carelessness raises a different issue, which the defense of contributory negligence handles. The defense exists because a negligence rule is meant to encourage optimal care by both parties, and primary liability alone may fall short where one party acts negligently and the other has an opportunity to avoid the accident.6
The burden of production, sometimes called the burden of going forward with the evidence, requires evidence that could support a jury inference that the defendant breached the standard of care, that the plaintiff suffered injury or loss, and that the breach caused it.7 The court decides whether the plaintiff has met this burden by ruling on the legal sufficiency of the evidence. If reasonable people could disagree on each element, the defendant's motion for a directed verdict at the close of the plaintiff's case is denied; if the evidence is legally insufficient on any element, the motion is granted.8 Sufficient evidence only sends the case to the jury, and the jury then determines the weight of that evidence.
The burden of persuasion takes over once the evidence reaches the jury. The jury is instructed that the plaintiff has carried it only if a preponderance of the evidence persuades the jury that the defendant breached, that the plaintiff was injured, and that the breach caused the injury.9 An element the jury finds only as probable as not, one that is 'in equipoise,' is an element the plaintiff has failed to prove.
Persuasion does not demand certainty. In the gun-permit example, the plaintiff did not have to show that Smith could not possibly have shot Doe without the permit; it was enough to convince the jury that she more probably than not would not have been injured but for the defendant's negligence, even though that inference carried some speculation.10
Plaintiffs most often lose on causation at the production stage, where the evidence leaves the question to conjecture. In the ranch-stairs case, the most that could be inferred was that the man was about to climb the stairs when he stumbled and fell. Why he stumbled would still require speculation, and neither suspicion nor speculation is enough to defeat a motion for summary judgment.11 The record put the fall at the stairs, and nothing tied the stairs to the fall.
The first tenant loses before the jury and the third before the court. Both defeats follow from the same allocation, which leaves the plaintiff to supply the evidence that tips the balance.
Courts will occasionally relax that allocation for policy reasons, chiefly where the defendant's negligence was partly responsible for the proof problem and created the very risk of harm that befell the plaintiff.12 Haft v. Lone Palm Hotel is the standard example: the court shifted to the defendant the burden of proving that its negligent failure to provide a lifeguard at a motel pool was not a cause in fact of drownings.13 A milder form of help appears when a negligent act is wrongful because it increased the chance of a particular type of accident and a mishap of that very sort occurs. That combination supports a finding that the negligence caused the harm, and Zuchowicz v. United States is an example of the reasoning.14 The negligent party must then bring in evidence denying but-for cause and suggesting that the wrongful conduct was not a substantial factor.15 The two forms relax the burden to different degrees. Haft moves the burden of proof on cause in fact to the defendant, while the increased-risk reasoning lets the factfinder find causation and then calls on the defendant for contrary evidence.
The exceptions stay narrow, and Lopez v. Alroudhan marks the boundary. A pedestrian who could not remember her accident invoked Haft and did not get the shift, because the defendant's negligence had not opened the gap in her proof.16 Nearly every plaintiff has some gap in the proof, so a rule that shifted the burden whenever proof was thin would swallow the preponderance standard.
The Court's Role
The court has two jobs on causation. Under section 328B(e), it decides the applicability of any rules of law determining whether the defendant's conduct is a legal cause.{{cite:2f49ece8-2856-425e-batc-9449213a8eb2}} Those are the rules in the second part of legal cause, the ones that may relieve the actor from liability because of the manner in which the negligence resulted in the harm.18 They address a recurring problem: whether liability should be cut off even though the defendant's conduct was both negligent and a factual cause of the injury. One suggestion is that the court can raise and treat that problem in connection with any of the four elements of a negligence case: duty, breach, causation, or damage.19
The court's second job comes from the plaintiff's burden of production. After the plaintiff's evidence is in, the court rules on its legal sufficiency, asking whether reasonable people could disagree about each element, causation included.20 If they could, the defendant's motion for a directed verdict is denied and the jury receives the case. If the evidence is legally insufficient on causation, the motion is granted. The ruling keeps the jury from deciding causation on a guess, and it leaves the weighing of sufficient evidence to the jury.
The ranch-stairs claim ended at this gate. The most that could be inferred was that the man was about to climb the stairs when he stumbled and fell, why he stumbled would still require speculation, and the court resolved the case without a jury on summary judgment.21 The same insufficiency at trial would support a directed verdict.
Proof need not be direct to clear the gate. In Martin v. Herzog, evidence of a collision more than an hour after sundown between a car and an unseen buggy proceeding without lights permitted an inference of a causal connection between the collision and the lack of signals, and if nothing else was shown to break the connection, the case was prima facie sufficient.22 The fire-escape example from the earlier discussion of proving the counterfactual works the same way. If Swensson is found in the middle of the hall, his family can argue that he reached the back window, could not get out because there was no fire escape, and ran back toward the front, and that story would show he died because of the landlord's negligence.23
The division between court and jury is therefore a division of questions, and it does not wall law off from fact. Whether a harm falls within the risk that made the conduct negligent turns partly on how broadly the risk is defined and partly on the evidence of what happened, and close cases of that kind are normally left to the jury.24 Once the court has applied the rules of law and found the evidence sufficient, the decision passes to the jury.
The Jury's Role
Section 328C(c) gives the jury the determination whether the defendant's conduct is a legal cause of the plaintiff's harm.26 The jury acts last. By then the court has decided which rules of law bear on legal cause and has found the evidence sufficient for reasonable people to go either way.27
The jury receives the question because the substantial-factor standard is a matter of degree. Unlike the but-for test, it asks the jury to make an intuitive judgment about how much causation is substantial and whether the defendant's negligence reaches that level, and it leaves the jury more leeway in assigning causal responsibility.28 A question of degree answered by intuitive judgment is one the law leaves to the jury.
The jury's authority is real. Sufficient evidence permits an inference of causation without requiring one, because the jury determines the weight of the evidence, and a jury that finds causation only as probable as not has found that the plaintiff did not carry the burden of persuasion.29
The traffic mix-up case shows a question that stays with the jury. Marshall was struck by the Nugent car while a traffic mix-up caused by Socony's servant's negligence was still persisting. The injury was not remote in time or place from the negligence, and the court found no error in leaving proximate cause to the jury.30 Judge Magruder added that events in such a mix-up may unfold in bizarre ways while the defendant is still liable for the result.31 The governing formulation confines a negligent actor's liability to harm resulting from the operation of the risk, or a risk, whose foreseeability made the conduct negligent. Applying it requires defining the risk narrowly or broadly as seems just for the type of case, which is why close calls go to the jury.32
The jury's answers must also fit together. A general verdict reports only who won, so it hides any mistake in the jury's reasoning and in a sense lets the jury ignore its instructions. A special verdict poses a separate question on each element, and the court can then test the answers for consistency. If the jury finds the defendant negligent but finds that the negligence caused the plaintiff no injury, and still awards damages, the court detects the contradiction and grants the defendant's motion for judgment notwithstanding the verdict.33
The usual error is to collapse the stages, treating the jury's weighing as though it came before the court's sufficiency ruling, or the court's gate as though it replaced the jury's finding.