Concept
The Basic Division of Labor
Judge and jury roles in deciding fault
Judge and Jury in Negligence
The Basic Division of Labor
Judge and jury do different work in a negligence trial, and what separates their work is the possibility of reasonable disagreement. The Restatement (Second) of Torts draws the line in two parallel provisions. Section 328B provides that in an action for negligence the court determines certain matters.1 Section 328C provides that the jury determines its matters “in any case in which different conclusions may be reached on the issue.”2
The qualifier in § 328C carries the structure. The jury's territory is the space in which different conclusions may be reached, and if the evidence permits only one conclusion, the jury has nothing to choose between. The law's own vocabulary makes the same point from the other side: a question that can have only one right answer must be answered in a courtroom by a judge, and it is therefore a question of law.3 In a negligence case, the court accordingly decides the matters reserved to it and keeps from the jury any issue that has only one right answer.4
Two slip-and-fall cases show the line at work. In the first, a customer in a busy supermarket knocks a bottle of cooking oil off a shelf, and it breaks and spills. The next shopper up the aisle slips on the oil within a minute and a half and sues the store. A sympathetic jury may call the store “unreasonable” for leaving the oil on the floor and return a verdict for the shopper. The judge may nonetheless grant the store's renewed motion for judgment as a matter of law, on the ground that it would be unreasonable to require anyone to clean up a liquid spill in a supermarket aisle within ninety seconds.5
In the second case, a pedestrian slips on an icy walk and sues the owner for failing to clear it. No numerical rule says how much ice must be removed or how soon, and the evidence supports differing views about whether the owner acted unreasonably. Different conclusions may be reached on that record, so the jury decides the issue under the court's statement of the reasonable-care standard.6
The standard is the same open-ended one in both cases, and the records are what differ. On the icy walk, reasonable people could land on either side. In the supermarket, the interval was so short that the judge could say no one should be held to a cleanup within it, and the question left the jury's territory. That ruling does not favor the store. It is a judgment that the law could not demand what the verdict would demand.
Reasonableness depends on facts that vary from case to case, which is why so many negligence issues are ones on which different conclusions may be reached. The foreseeable probability and gravity of harm together determine the magnitude of the risk, so the same omission can be negligent in one setting and not in another. Failing to repair a hole in a rarely used sidewalk might not be negligence, whereas the same failure on a heavily traveled sidewalk would be.7
This division operates inside the adversary system, the source of Anglo-American evidentiary rules and principles, and evidence treatises give the allocation between judge and jury its own overview.8 The rest of the chapter takes it in order: what the court decides, what the jury decides, the motions, instructions, and verdict forms through which the court enforces the line, and the same pattern for causation.